Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around simulating the Circular Restricted Three Body Problem using Excel. Participants explore the challenges of implementing the equations of motion for three bodies, particularly focusing on the transition from a two-body to a three-body simulation.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Homework-related
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant expresses a desire to simulate the Circular Restricted Three Body Problem in Excel but is unsure how to begin, despite having the equations of motion.
- Another participant questions whether the original poster needs help specifically with Excel.
- Several participants note that transitioning from a two-body simulation to a three-body simulation should be straightforward, yet the original poster indicates they are struggling with this process.
- There is a suggestion to move the discussion to a programming subforum, as the question may not be strictly about physics.
- One participant describes the dynamics of the three-body problem, emphasizing the dependence of the third body's motion on the positions and velocities of the first two bodies.
- Another participant points out that the equations of motion could be re-expressed as a single vector equation rather than in component form.
- Questions arise regarding the necessity of vectorial equations and the capabilities of Excel in handling such equations, particularly in relation to differential equation solvers.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on the best approach to simulate the three-body problem in Excel, and there are varying opinions on the necessity of vectorial equations and the challenges involved in the simulation process.
Contextual Notes
There are unresolved questions regarding the specific difficulties faced by the original poster in implementing the equations of motion and the capabilities of Excel for such simulations. The discussion also highlights the potential need for programming knowledge, particularly in VBA, to address the challenges presented.