• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products via PF Here!

Small oscillations in nonholonomic systems

  • Thread starter zwierz
  • Start date
335
61
I wonder why nobody discuss this topic in classical mech. courses
 
283
29
Non-holonomic systems are not covered in much detail to begin with. I haven't had to encounter non-holonomic systems in my other courses. Although, I guess you could say the same with Hamilton-Jacobi theory and Poisson Brackets with the exception of quantum mechanics. In my graduate course in classical mechanics we only solved problems involving cars and unicycles with various restraints imposed on the steering wheel, direction of motion (forward/reverse). etc. I'm actually not sure how knowledgeable physicists are in general about non-holonomic systems. What are your experiences?

I know that there is one professor in my department who loves classical mechanics. I never took a course from him, but my peers who did showed and talked about some interesting problems that I didn't get to see when I took classical mechanics.
 
2,087
514
I wonder why nobody discuss this topic in classical mech. courses
If you have something in particular in mind, why not post it for discussion here?
 
335
61
I just copy my answer to the letter of one of the participants:
Example: a hemisphere is rolling about its equilibrium on a horizontal plane. There is no slipping. It is proposed to write equations of motion in the linear approximation.
Reference: E. T. Whittaker A Treatise On The Analytical Dynamics Of Particles And Rigid Bodies
 
2,087
514
I am familiar with that problem, although i do not recall just where it is in Whittaker (my copy is on the shelf, and it stays there most of the time).

Let's consider the answer to your original question in terms of this specific example, the hemisphere rolling on a horizontal plane without slipping. What actual physical system does this model? Can you think of any? I cannot. This is the crux of the matter as to why such problems are not discussed very much; they do not represent actual systems of interest.

Perhaps there is something in that problem (or a similar nonholonomic problem) that could be of great value, but no one has recognized it as yet. In a parallel situation, I am sure that things hung from vines, ropes, and such long before anyone thought to use a pendulum for time keeping. If problems of the sort motivating this thread are of interest to you, perhaps you will be the one to discover some aspect of great use to mankind. I do not think you will find this a crowed field for research.
 
335
61
Actually nonholonomic mechanics is a fundamental and very popular field of modern research. You can make sure of that even with the help of google; not to mention such classical effects as

 
Last edited:
2,087
514
What you have shown under the name Celtic Stone I know as a Rattleback.

It may be a very popular research topic for those who simply want to know, but it is not very popular at all with those that have a specific task to accomplish. When you understand this matter and can completely model it mathematically, what are you then able to do?
 

Want to reply to this thread?

"Small oscillations in nonholonomic systems" You must log in or register to reply here.

Related Threads for: Small oscillations in nonholonomic systems

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top