Solving for electric potential using separation of variables

1 reply · 4K views · last reply
nashed
Messages
56
Reaction score
5

Homework Statement


Given two two grounded concentric spherical shells with radii a,b (a<b) and a point charge q between them at a<r=R<b find:

1.The surface charge density of the point charge using the delta function, assume the charge is on the z axis

2.By using the separation of variables method find the electric potential between the shells.

Homework Equations


I have no idea how to insert mathematical equation in the forum but the most relevant equations are the jump discontinuity in the orthogonal part of the field and the general form of the solution of the Laplace equations in spherical coordinates

The Attempt at a Solution



In my first try I tried to solve for the whole volume at once which produced contradictions, in my second attempt I divided the volume and solved for each volume separately but I got stuck on the orthogonality condition for the Legendre polynomials, the precise attempt is shown in the images

Handwritten physics homework on graph paper: problem statement for two grounded concentric spherical shells with a point charge q between them, followed by a handwritten attempt at part 1 with delta-function surface charge density and a double integral set equal to q.
Handwritten derivation on grid paper: a sketch of two concentric circles with a point labelled R, then the assumed separated form of the potential, a general series solution with Legendre polynomials, and boundary conditions at r = a and r = b plus a jump condition at R.
Handwritten derivation on graph paper matching boundary conditions at r = R with Legendre expansion coefficients, concluding that A_l, B_l are zero, contradicting the surface charge term sigma/epsilon_0.
Handwritten notes titled attempt 2 showing a sketch of two concentric spheres with a point charge, then a series solution for the potential in volume I and boundary conditions on the spheres, followed by the corresponding expansion and boundary conditions for volume II.
Handwritten derivation on grid paper, labelled Volume I and Volume II, with series solutions for potential in each region built from Legendre polynomials and boundary conditions at the shells, ending with a jump condition for the radial derivative.
Handwritten working on grid paper: an integral over theta from 0 to pi of a sum of Legendre terms with radial factors, rewritten as a surface integral, followed by an orthogonality relation for Legendre polynomials P_l(x) with integration over x from -1 to 1.
Handwritten derivation on lined paper: a sum over l of integrals of Legendre polynomials times sine theta, equated to a left side and right side with q over epsilon naught, using orthogonality of Legendre polynomials.
 
Your second approach should work. However, I noticed a few errors:

Page 1: Your expression for σ is incorrect. You want to write a surface charge density for the surface r = R. Thus, ∫σdA = q for this surface. There is no integration over r here. Think about the expression for dA for this surface.

Page 4: Your powers of r in ##\Phi_I## and ##\Phi_{II}## don't appear to be correct. For example, see eq. 14 here http://www.luc.edu/faculty/dslavsk/courses/phys301/classnotes/laplacesequation.pdf

Page 4: Check the signs in the equation at the bottom of the page for the boundary condition involving R+ and R-. Recall that ##\vec{E} = -\nabla \Phi##. ( I don't understand the equation in the middle of the page, just before "in Volume II".)

Page 7: You forgot the ##\delta_{l,l'}## that occurs when doing the integral on the left at the top of the page.

There is another boundary condition that you can use. What can you say about the continuity of ##\Phi## at r = R when ##\theta \neq 0##?