Source transformation with two resistors and voltage sources

9 replies · 2K views · last reply
dwn
Messages
165
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement



Image Attached

Homework Equations



Ohm's

The Attempt at a Solution



Combined the two resistors in series : 250 + 550 = 800 kΩ
Source Transformation (Current Source): V = 140,000(2*10^-6)= 0.28 V
Combine the voltage sources : 6 - 0.28 = 5.72 V

But then I recreated the circuit with these figures and it just doesn't appear correct to me.
Voltage source = 5.72 V
Resistor = 800 + 140 = 940kΩ

Ans: V = 3.35 V R = 228.19 kΩ

I don't see how they're getting these figures.
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic with a -11 V source, a 1,300 kΩ resistor, a 250 kΩ resistor, a 6 V source, a 550 kΩ resistor, a 140 kΩ resistor and a 2 μA current source.
    Screen Shot 2014-03-13 at 3.18.43 PM.jpg
    15.2 KB · Views: 598
Can someone please explain to me what is going on here?
 
The 250 k and 550 k resistors are not in series: there's another connection at the node where they join (the 1300 k resistor) so they cannot be in series.

Your transformation of the 140 k resistor and 2 uA source to a voltage source (Thevenin equivalent) is fine, and combining it with the 6 V source to yield a net 5.720 V source is good too. What's the Thevenin resistance for that new combined source?

Your next step should be to incorporate the 550 k resistor, so another Thevenin equivalent voltage and resistance should result. You should end up with the original -11 V source, the 1300 k resistor and the new Thevenin resistance and voltage all in series.

The steps are summarized in the following figure. Working from right to left, convert and combine/incorporate components into Thevenin equivalent models as you go:

Circuit schematic with three red numbered cut lines (1, 2, 3) crossing the wires, marking sections for source transformation: a -11 V source, 1300 kΩ, 250 kΩ, 550 kΩ, 140 kΩ, a 6 V source and a 2 µA current source.
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic with resistors 1300 kΩ, 250 kΩ, 550 kΩ and 140 kΩ, sources -11 V, 6 V and 2 µA, and three numbered red cut sections labelled 1, 2 and 3 marking the steps.
    Fig1.gif
    4 KB · Views: 859
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
gneill, thank you very much for the clear and concise explanation. However, I do have a question...I thought that we were supposed to create a "black box" and create an open circuit at the end (the node where the 250 and 550 R meet) which would make them in series...apparently this is not the case and I misunderstood.
Do you alway start from the outside and work your way towards the center?
 
dwn said:
gneill, thank you very much for the clear and concise explanation. However, I do have a question...I thought that we were supposed to create a "black box" and create an open circuit at the end (the node where the 250 and 550 R meet) which would make them in series...apparently this is not the case and I misunderstood.
Do you alway start from the outside and work your way towards the center?

You work in the direction that achieves your goal :smile: I know that doesn't seem to help much... But in this case you are apparently looking to find the power dissipated by the 1300 k resistor so you know that you need to leave that one alone --- you can't transform it away into the guts of an equivalent circuit (Thevenin or Norton) because then you couldn't write any equations about it to find current or voltage for it; once you transform-away a component it becomes inaccessible to further analysis. So leaving it alone, you look towards the rest of the circuit. Most of it lies to the right of the 1300 k resistor, so you start at the far end and work back. That usually works well as a general approach.
 
My apologies for the poor quality in the photo. Where have I gone wrong in this problem? Still not arriving at the correct solution.

Note: all resistors are kΩ
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten circuit simplification steps on paper: source transformations reducing a network of resistors, voltage sources and a current source to a single 172 kΩ, 3.784 V source and 140 kΩ resistor, with intermediate values like 0.28 V, 5.72 V and 22 µA.
    Screen Shot 2014-03-13 at 8.41.24 PM.jpg
    33.7 KB · Views: 603
dwn said:
My apologies for the poor quality in the photo. Where have I gone wrong in this problem? Still not arriving at the correct solution.

Note: all resistors are kΩ

In your second step:

Handwritten circuit sketch with a 250 ohm resistor and a voltage source of 6.22 V in a top branch, a 40 resistor on the right, and a 650 resistor down the left side, with the expression 6.22 V over 250,000 equals I equals 22 uA boxed below.


you've opted to transform to a Norton equivalent, but didn't include the 140 k resistance that is also in series with the voltage source. That means you would end up with something like this instead:

Circuit schematic with an 11 V voltage source on the left in series with a 1300 kΩ resistor, a 550 kΩ resistor shunting to the bottom rail, a current source I_N in parallel with a resistor R_N, and a 140 kΩ resistor on the right.


In this problem you have the option of just sticking with Thevenin equivalents all the way through.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten circuit sketch: a 250 ohm resistor in series with a 6.72 V source and a 40 resistor on the top branch, with a 650 resistor on the left branch. Below, handwritten 6.72 V over 250,000 equals I = 27 uA.
    Fig2.gif
    8.3 KB · Views: 654
  • Circuit schematic with an 11 V voltage source on the left in series with a 1300 kΩ resistor, a 550 kΩ resistor branching down to the bottom wire, a current source I_N in parallel with R_N, and a 140 kΩ resistor on the right.
    Fig3.gif
    2 KB · Views: 682
I was able to figure out the resistors and come up with the correct Rx -- what method are they using to find the voltage?

I apologize for the series of questions with this problem, but circuits are not coming easily for me.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten circuit schematic: a 390 ohm resistor in series with a 5.72V voltage source, connected to a 650 ohm resistor on the left branch; below, handwritten 1/390 + 1/650 = 228.19 kΩ.
    Screen Shot 2014-03-13 at 9.51.32 PM.jpg
    8 KB · Views: 554
dwn said:
I was able to figure out the resistors and come up with the correct Rx -- what method are they using to find the voltage?
Well, your thumbnail diagram shows a classic voltage divider scenario... that would yield the Thevenin voltage for that subcircuit.

I apologize for the series of questions with this problem, but circuits are not coming easily for me.
No worries, that's why we're here :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
Fantastic! Love it when this works. Starting the journey is a pain in the butt though.

Thanks for the help gneill