- #1
kwright
- 8
- 0
Neutron stars formed from supernova events are prohibited from becoming black holes because it is thought that the gravitational force is not enough to overcome Fermi degeneracy of the neutrons or quark gluon soup at the core of these objects, however, addition of more mass can overcome this repulsion and form a black hole. My question is are black hole "cores" not singularities but instead massive bosons formed by the gravitational effects forcing quarks into a singular microstate similar to the formation of Cooper pairs.
I've found a thesis document that discusses the exact line of thought I've been pursuing, remarkable to me because until tonight I had not heard of color superconductivity although I have a layman's understanding of both quantum chromodynamics and superconductivity, which led to my initial question due to my curiosity about absolute zero.
http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/16936/53103752.pdf?sequence=1
In the QCD theory quarks come in different flavors and / or colors, for instance, the neutron is composed of 1 up quark ( a type of flavor) and two down quarks. In the case of cold ultra dense neutron star matter the quarks can break color charge confinement which involves the gluons (strong force) that bind quarks to one another. Similar to low temperature superconductor theories, the quarks can aline in Cooper pairs, essentially becoming bosons from the pairing of fermions. By not obeying the Pauli exclusion principle the quarks may superimpose themselves Cooper pair by Cooper pair. My original question asked if the singularity formed by, say, two neutrons stars merging into a black hole could in fact be a massive boson formed by matter condensed sufficiently by gravity as to have just one microstate at a temperature of absolute zero.
Also it has been found that pairs of top quarks can combine to form Higgs bosons through a mechanism involving gluons. The quark gluon soup imagined to exist within neutron stars should provide a target rich environment due to the breaking of color confinement of the quarks as well as the chiral symmetry breaking due to the Higgs field, a condensate whose carrier is a scalar boson.
It has been theorized that in certain situations gravity was as strong as the other fundamental forces, such as the big bang / early universe setting, perhaps the same scenario exists at the core of collapsed stars. The case of 2 neutron stars forming a black hole with a singularity at the center is reminiscent of two fermions forming a Cooper pair (massive boson) that doesn't require a singularity. I hypothesize that an object that has reached the Planck mass must become a boson in the relativistic conditions at the heart of a black hole and not a singularity. Consequently, the singularity at the beginning of the big bang should also be a boson. I can't prove any of this, I just hate singularities. :)
The problem I have with physical singularities is rather simple. I don't believe there are infinities in nature, but when these infinities showed up in the formulation of QED they were renormalized with empirical data to fit what nature actually revealed. Should a theory arise that actually renormalizes the singularity similar to the renormalizing of the properties of electrons I think it would go far in explaining other phenomena such as dark energy ,big bang zero and the true nature of superconductivity as well as black holes. Mathematical singularities are probably ok as long as they are not used to describe infinities within the scope of what occurs naturally, it's sounds a little like killing a mosquito with a thermonuclear device.
I guess what I'm asking is the following; 1) Is gravitation strong enough to overcome quantum fluctuations of the material (fermions) present at a neutron star core as it proceeds with additional mass to the transition from a neutron star towards full gravitational collapse and 2) would such material be compacted to the extent that there are no "degrees of freedom" essentially forcing fermions to exhibit bosonic character with a microstate of one at zero degrees Kelvin at the "core" thus avoiding singularity while preserving baryon number as well as mass - energy conservation? Present knowledge would suggest the short answer of no, I just want to know why. Respectfully, Keith Wright.Show less
I've found a thesis document that discusses the exact line of thought I've been pursuing, remarkable to me because until tonight I had not heard of color superconductivity although I have a layman's understanding of both quantum chromodynamics and superconductivity, which led to my initial question due to my curiosity about absolute zero.
http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/16936/53103752.pdf?sequence=1
In the QCD theory quarks come in different flavors and / or colors, for instance, the neutron is composed of 1 up quark ( a type of flavor) and two down quarks. In the case of cold ultra dense neutron star matter the quarks can break color charge confinement which involves the gluons (strong force) that bind quarks to one another. Similar to low temperature superconductor theories, the quarks can aline in Cooper pairs, essentially becoming bosons from the pairing of fermions. By not obeying the Pauli exclusion principle the quarks may superimpose themselves Cooper pair by Cooper pair. My original question asked if the singularity formed by, say, two neutrons stars merging into a black hole could in fact be a massive boson formed by matter condensed sufficiently by gravity as to have just one microstate at a temperature of absolute zero.
Also it has been found that pairs of top quarks can combine to form Higgs bosons through a mechanism involving gluons. The quark gluon soup imagined to exist within neutron stars should provide a target rich environment due to the breaking of color confinement of the quarks as well as the chiral symmetry breaking due to the Higgs field, a condensate whose carrier is a scalar boson.
It has been theorized that in certain situations gravity was as strong as the other fundamental forces, such as the big bang / early universe setting, perhaps the same scenario exists at the core of collapsed stars. The case of 2 neutron stars forming a black hole with a singularity at the center is reminiscent of two fermions forming a Cooper pair (massive boson) that doesn't require a singularity. I hypothesize that an object that has reached the Planck mass must become a boson in the relativistic conditions at the heart of a black hole and not a singularity. Consequently, the singularity at the beginning of the big bang should also be a boson. I can't prove any of this, I just hate singularities. :)
The problem I have with physical singularities is rather simple. I don't believe there are infinities in nature, but when these infinities showed up in the formulation of QED they were renormalized with empirical data to fit what nature actually revealed. Should a theory arise that actually renormalizes the singularity similar to the renormalizing of the properties of electrons I think it would go far in explaining other phenomena such as dark energy ,big bang zero and the true nature of superconductivity as well as black holes. Mathematical singularities are probably ok as long as they are not used to describe infinities within the scope of what occurs naturally, it's sounds a little like killing a mosquito with a thermonuclear device.
I guess what I'm asking is the following; 1) Is gravitation strong enough to overcome quantum fluctuations of the material (fermions) present at a neutron star core as it proceeds with additional mass to the transition from a neutron star towards full gravitational collapse and 2) would such material be compacted to the extent that there are no "degrees of freedom" essentially forcing fermions to exhibit bosonic character with a microstate of one at zero degrees Kelvin at the "core" thus avoiding singularity while preserving baryon number as well as mass - energy conservation? Present knowledge would suggest the short answer of no, I just want to know why. Respectfully, Keith Wright.Show less
Last edited by a moderator: