Ridiculous Survey Questions: Exposing Mundane Attempts at Intelligence

  • Thread starter Thread starter Danger
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Choices Stupid
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

This discussion centers on the frustration with survey questions that lack depth and often force respondents into simplistic dichotomies. Participants share humorous and critical perspectives on questions like the classic "Is the glass half full or half empty?" and the moral dilemma of saving a boy or girl tied to a railroad track. The conversation highlights the absurdity of such questions and the tendency of "Mundanes" to oversimplify complex human experiences. The thread ultimately calls for more thoughtful and nuanced questioning in surveys and educational settings.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of survey design principles
  • Familiarity with psychological testing methods
  • Knowledge of logical reasoning and ethical dilemmas
  • Awareness of cultural references in humor and science fiction
NEXT STEPS
  • Research effective survey question design techniques
  • Explore ethical implications of psychological testing in education
  • Study logical reasoning frameworks for ethical dilemmas
  • Investigate the role of humor in social commentary and critique
USEFUL FOR

This discussion is beneficial for educators, survey designers, psychologists, and anyone interested in the intersection of humor and social critique in questioning methodologies.

Danger
Gold Member
Messages
9,793
Reaction score
250
I've never been given a survey that didn't include at least half a dozen of those, but I'm specifically thinking of ones that Mundanes think make them seem intellectual while the choice of answers that they want you to choose from doesn't include the one that an intelligent person would give. I'll just reference the one that pisses me off more than any other, and would really like to hear what monstrosities have been thrust upon the rest of you guys.

e.g.: There's a 12 oz. beer glass on the bar with 6 oz. of beer in it. Some dip wants to play amateur psychologist and asks whether I'm an optimist who says that it's half full, or a pessimist who says that it's half empty. My response is always: "I'm a realist, you idiot! It's full. It's half-full of beer and half-full of air."

Come on, folks. I need some doozies to laugh at.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
jedishrfu said:
Drink it and say I'm a realist.

Wouldn't that be a pragmatist?
 
Matterwave said:
Wouldn't that be a pragmatist?
:DD
 
Who cares if the beer tastes good.

Beer today gone tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
jedishrfu said:
Beer today gone tomorrow.
You must have a lot better kidneys than me if it takes until tomorrow. In my town, you don't buy beer; you just rent it by the hour.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: kosovo dave and jedishrfu
The answer to that question depends on the situation. If you're in the process of drinking it with the intent of finishing it, then it's half empty. If you're in the process of filling the glass to the top, then it's half full.
 
A boy and a girl are tied to a railroad track. You only have time to save one. Which do you save?
 
DaveC426913 said:
A boy and a girl are tied to a railroad track. You only have time to save one. Which do you save?
Yeah, that's a Kobayashi Maru for sure. It'd be a no-brainer if one was your daughter and the other her rapist, but otherwise there are so many factors that it would come down to a split-second decision that couldn't be reasoned out hypothetically..
Good one.
 
  • #11
Danger said:
[ ... ] Mundanes [ ... ]Come on, folks. I need some doozies to laugh at.
Mundanes?

The daughter tied to the railroad track can replace the son many times over. Always save the female.
 
  • #12
jedishrfu said:
What about the poor train?
It can just wipe its wheels and carry on.

Mundanes?

The daughter tied to the railroad track can replace the son many times over. Always save the female.
Sorry... Mundanes is the term that Science Fiction fans apply to people who aren't. I figure that science fans should be able to use it as well.
The question doesn't state whether or not there are any prior relationships between the 3 people. That's the biggest part of the problem with it.
 
  • #13
DaveC426913 said:
A boy and a girl are tied to a railroad track. You only have time to save one. Which do you save?

Be like Hancock and just stop the train...
 
  • #14
Chicken or egg, what came first?
 
  • #15
Danger said:
asks whether I'm an optimist who says that it's half full, or a pessimist who says that it's half empty

Engineer's answer: the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.
 
  • #16
Vanadium 50 said:
Engineer's answer: the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.
Someone posted a list here once of about 50 answers like this one to this question; answers from many different perspectives. It was pretty funny.
 
  • #18
zoki85 said:
Chicken or egg, what came first?
Nice try, but that one doesn't actually qualify in that one of the answers is obviously correct. Birds descended from dinosaurs, so the eggs existed for millions of years before the contents thereof evolved into chickens.
Vanadium, I giggle at your response; good one.
 
  • #19
If you could be anyone in the world, who would you want to be?
Or,
If you could be reincarnated, who would you want to come back as?
 
  • #20
Danger said:
e.g.: There's a 12 oz. beer glass on the bar with 6 oz. of beer in it. .
Is a 12oz beer glass really 12 oz full, or 12 oz just up to the white line?. So 6 oz is not even half full. The mundane asking the question has got it wrong already from the start.
 
  • #21
256bits said:
Is a 12oz beer glass really 12 oz full, or 12 oz just up to the white line?. So 6 oz is not even half full. The mundane asking the question has got it wrong already from the start.
I don't know where you live. Speaking as one who spent more than 20 years tending bar, I can say that I've never seen a glass with a line on it except one time as a customer in one strange bar in another city. That particular size of glass is one with straight sides and a handle on it. Exactly to the level of the brim, its volume is 12 oz. It is filled with beer to more or less 3/8" from that limit. That depends upon how much head springs up, (which in itself depends upon several factors), how steady the bartender's hands are, how much he cares, and how much he likes or dislikes the customer. It's all legit because it is sold as a "mug of beer", not by the fluid content. Overpours and underpours average out, so anyone who has more than a couple breaks even. By the same token, some bars sell a 16 oz glass as a pint, while others use a 20 oz glass. That's specified on the menu, and no one expects it to be full right to the top.
In any event, a 12 oz glass with beer up to the line is still full; it just has less air in it than the one with 6 oz of beer.
 
  • #22
Less-than-sensible questions can be found in Education and in the personality job-fit questionnaires to online employment applications. Exact specific examples, I do not remember.
 
  • #23
256bits said:
just up to the white line

Let me guess - you live in Europe. In the US, glasses usually don't have these lines.
 
  • #24
256bits said:
If you could be reincarnated, who would you want to come back as?
I don't know how I missed your post the first time around. One of my buddies came up with the best answer that I can remember ever hearing. When asked what he would come back as, his immediate response was, "The brass pole in a strip club."
 
  • #25
The Great White North.
But that is not to say they were ubiticus.
I would have thought maybe someone else might have remembered them, or had seen one.
There were a couple in the cupboard growing up. The ones with the heavy bottom, slim waist, and spreading out at the top.
 
  • #26
Danger said:
The question doesn't state whether or not there are any prior relationships between the 3 people. That's the biggest part of the problem with it.
For me, the biggest part is that it's a false test.

Nobody is going to choose which one based on gender. And the conceit of the question is that saving one or the other tells something about what kind of person you are. It doesn't. Well unless, in answering the question, you really did choose based on their gender, in which case you've merely been given some with which to hang yourself.
 
  • #28
256bits said:
The Great White North.
The ones with the heavy bottom, slim waist, and spreading out at the top.
Fellow Canuck here.
I think that I know the ones to which you refer, now that you provided more info. I've seen sets of them once or twice in private homes, and in fancy restaurants where they are provided with a bottle of beer, but almost never a public bar. They're fancy versions of Pilsner glasses, usually around 7—12 oz, and fairly expensive. Flat sides on the bottom section, right?

Dave, I see your point, but I still think that it's just a subset of mine.
 
  • #29
A train is heading north, while its smoke is heading south. How many pancakes does it take to cover a doghouse?

I'll have to get a hold of my dad to get the answer... I can't seem to remember it at the moment.
 
  • #30
Drakkith said:
A train is heading north, while its smoke is heading south. How many pancakes does it take to cover a doghouse?

I'll have to get a hold of my dad to get the answer...
Was your dad a follower of Timothy Leary? :D
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
7K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
10K
  • · Replies 65 ·
3
Replies
65
Views
11K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
5K