Tensor Products - Issue with Cooperstein, Theorem 10.3

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Math Amateur
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Tensor Theorem
2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading Bruce N. Coopersteins book: Advanced Linear Algebra (Second Edition) ... ...

I am focused on Section 10.2 Properties of Tensor Products ... ...

I need help with an aspect of the proof of Theorem 10.3 ... ... basically I do not know what is going on in the second part of the proof, after the isomorphism between ##X## and ##Y## is proven ... ... ... ...Theorem 10.3 reads as follows:
Textbook page showing Theorem 10.3 on isomorphic tensor products, followed by its proof defining V, W, X, Y, the multilinear map f, and the linear map T from Y to X.

Handwritten-style proof text from a linear algebra textbook: a linear map S from X to Y defined on tensor products, a claim that the map sigma is multilinear, and a displayed chain of equalities checking additivity in the first argument.

Handwritten-style typeset proof text on tensor products: a linear map S from V tensor W to Y, with a displayed chain of equalities for S((v1 tensor ... tensor vs) tensor (w1 tensor ... tensor wt)) ending in v1 tensor ... tensor vs tensor w1 tensor ... tensor wt.

Question 1

In the above proof by Cooperstein, we read the following:" ... ... ... it follows that ##S## and ##T## are inverses of each other and consequently##X## and ##Y## are isomorphic. ... ... ""Surely, at this point the theorem is proven ... but the proof goes on ... ... ?

Can someone please explain what is going on in the second part of the proof ... ... ?Question 2

In the above proof we read:"... ... Then ##g (w_1, \ ... \ ... \ , w_t)## is a multilinear map and therefore by the universality of ##V## there exists a linear map ##\sigma (w_1, \ ... \ ... \ , w_t)## from ##V## to ##Y## ... ... "

My question is as follows:

What is meant by the universality of ##V##"and how does the universality of ##V## lead to the existence of the linear map ##\sigma## ... ... ?Hope someone can help ... ... Peter
 
Attachments
  • Theorem 10.3 statement and the opening of its proof: the tensor product (V1 ⊗ ... ⊗ Vs) ⊗ (W1 ⊗ ... ⊗ Wt) is isomorphic to V1 ⊗ ... ⊗ Vs ⊗ W1 ⊗ ... ⊗ Wt, with notation V, W, X, Y and the map f defined, followed by the linear map T.
    Cooperstein - 1 - Theorem 10.3 - PART 1.PNG
    46.5 KB · Views: 817
  • Handwritten-style proof text from a linear algebra textbook: defines a linear map S from X to Y on tensor products, shows S and T are inverses, then checks multilinearity of sigma in the first argument with a chain of equalities.
    Cooperstein - 2 - Theorem 10.3 - PART 2.PNG
    107 KB · Views: 769
  • Handwritten-style typeset proof excerpt on tensor products: defines a linear map sigma-hat from W to L(V,X), a bilinear map h, a linear map S from V tensor W to Y, and a chain of equalities for S applied to a tensor of vectors.
    Cooperstein - 3 - Theorem 10.3 - PART 3.PNG
    72 KB · Views: 789
Last edited:
Math Amateur said:
Question 1

In the above proof by Cooperstein, we read the following:" ... ... ... it follows that ##S## and ##T## are inverses of each other and consequently##X## and ##Y## are isomorphic. ... ... ""Surely, at this point the theorem is proven ... but the proof goes on ... ... ?

Can someone please explain what is going on in the second part of the proof ... ... ?
The theorem is only proven at that point subject to proving the existence of the map ##S##, which has not yet been done. Note the words a little above that, which say 'We will prove the existence of a linear map ##S##...'
The remainder of the proof after the statement '... are isomorphic' is the proof of the existence of ##S##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
Thanks Andrew ... appreciate your help as usual ...

Do you have an answer to my second question ..

Peter