The Future of Air Travel: A Survey on Pilotless Planes and Passenger Perceptions

  • Thread starter Thread starter aero2040
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Aircraft Survey
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around perceptions of pilotless planes and the future of air travel, particularly focusing on a survey designed to gather opinions on flying with varying levels of pilot presence. Participants explore their feelings about flying, the frequency of air travel, and conditions under which they would consider flying with one or no pilots in the cockpit. The context includes theoretical and practical implications of automation in aviation by 2040.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express no fear of flying, while others indicate conditional feelings based on specific circumstances, such as the presence of a pilot or the reliability of technology.
  • Responses vary on the frequency of air travel, with some participants indicating they fly 2-5 times a year, while others state they do not fly at all.
  • There are differing opinions on flying with only one pilot in the cockpit, with some stating they would, while others express hesitation or conditional acceptance based on the system's reliability.
  • Several participants indicate they would not fly if there were no pilots in the cockpit, citing concerns about current technology and the need for emergency control options.
  • One participant raises a concern about the terminology used in the survey, suggesting that "atomized" may have been intended to mean "automated," and discusses the implications of such a misunderstanding.
  • A participant with a background in piloting shares personal experiences and concerns related to health and safety while flying, emphasizing the importance of emergency protocols.
  • Another participant critiques the survey format, stating that it does not allow for nuanced responses and expressing frustration with the limitations of the questions.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally express a range of views on the acceptability of flying with fewer or no pilots, indicating that multiple competing perspectives remain. There is no consensus on the implications of pilotless technology or the conditions under which participants would feel comfortable flying.

Contextual Notes

Some responses highlight limitations in the survey's design, particularly regarding the ability to capture nuanced opinions and the potential misunderstanding of terms used in the questions. Participants also express varying degrees of comfort with current aviation technology and its future developments.

aero2040
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
I am working on a project and more precisely about aeronautics in 2040, can you please provide me with your feedback on this survey:
0. Age : [20-30] / [30-40] / [40-50] / [50-60] / [ 60 ...]
1. Do you fear taking a plane? Yes/ No
2. How often do you take an airplane per year ( 2 way travel = 2 times) :
0/ 2-5 / 5-10 / 10 and more
3. Will you take a plane if there is only 1 pilot in the cockpit? Yes/No
4. Will you take a plane if there is no pilot in the cockpit? Yes/No
5. If we are in 2025 and all cargo aircrafts are fully atomized with 0 crashes in 10 years of operation. Would you change your mind?
Yes/No for 1 Pilot
Yes/ No for 0 Pilot

Many thanks in advance for your participation.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
0. Age : [40-50]
1. Do you fear taking a plane? No
2. How often do you take an airplane per year ( 2 way travel = 2 times) : 2-5
3. Will you take a plane if there is only 1 pilot in the cockpit? Yes
4. Will you take a plane if there is no pilot in the cockpit? No
5. If we are in 2025 and all cargo aircrafts are fully atomized with 0 crashes in 10 years of operation. Would you change your mind?
Yes 1 Pilot
No for 0 Pilot
 
0. Age : [20-30]
1. Do you fear taking a plane? No
2. How often do you take an airplane per year ( 2 way travel = 2 times) : 2-5
3. Will you take a plane if there is only 1 pilot in the cockpit? Depends on the system, probably yes
4. Will you take a plane if there is no pilot in the cockpit? Depends on the system, probably yes
5. If we are in 2025 and all cargo aircrafts are fully atomized with 0 crashes in 10 years of operation. Would you change your mind?
Depends on the answers to 3./4. (assuming 3/4 are answered with "yes", there is no reason to change my mind).
 
0. [20-30]
1. No
2. 1
3. Yes
4. No
5. yes for 1 pilot
No for 0 pilot
 
aero2040 said:
I am working on a project and more precisely about aeronautics in 2040, can you please provide me with your feedback on this survey:
0. Age : [20-30] / [30-40] / [40-50] / [50-60] / [ 60 ...]
[20-30]
aero2040 said:
1. Do you fear taking a plane? Yes/ No
No

aero2040 said:
2. How often do you take an airplane per year ( 2 way travel = 2 times) :
0/ 2-5 / 5-10 / 10 and more
2-5

aero2040 said:
3. Will you take a plane if there is only 1 pilot in the cockpit? Yes/No
Yes.

aero2040 said:
4. Will you take a plane if there is no pilot in the cockpit? Yes/No
Probably not. We're not quite at the point where autopilots are robust enough to handle extreme situations.

aero2040 said:
5. If we are in 2025 and all cargo aircrafts are fully atomized with 0 crashes in 10 years of operation. Would you change your mind?
Yes/No for 1 Pilot
Yes/ No for 0 Pilot
I think you mean "autonomous"...only if there were controls that would allow me to take manual control in the event of an emergency. (As it is, most commercial flights run on autopilot during the cruise phase; the pilots fly manually during takeoff and approach and landing.)
 
I would like to remark that "there is no pilot in the cockpit" (or anywhere else in the airplane) does not mean that no pilot could fly the machine in case of an emergency.
 
Thank you all for your answers
 
I can't answer your survey because a lot of the questions don't allow for my answers. That's one reason that I hate surveys. My information is possibly relevant, but I can't enter it because the parameters of the questions don't allow it.
I will tell you what I think about the situation, though, and perhaps you can use that if there's an essay section to your project. So... I'm going to address each of your questions in order, but with the proper answers that are not allowed by the test.
0) Okay, that one is legit. I'm 57.
1) No in principle, but yes in practicality. Aeroplanes are the safest way to travel. I was a pilot and fully intended to do that for a living, and the only times that I have ever been truly happy in my entire life were when I was in the air. I got grounded for being diabetic in 1976, before that ever started, so the rest of my flying was as a passenger. Now... what causes me concern, but not fear, is that I require a constant oxygen supply even in my sleep to be comfortable, but I can survive without it as long as I don't try to move. At a high altitude, I would probably die if there was an equipment failure. If it was a last-minute thing, though, I would rather die in the air than in my bed.
2) Never. Even if I were mobile, I can't afford it. If I could do it, I would be flying constantly.
3) Of course. I used to be that only pilot in the cockpit.
4) Not based upon current technology, unless there is a remote pilot who can take over.
5) A plane that is atomized can't fly because it no longer exists as a coherent mechanism.
If you mean "automated", then no... my opinion would not change from the previous question but the circumstances would. Given the specified safety record, I wouldn't hesitate to board a computer-operated flight as long as the aforementioned oxygen requirements are guaranteed.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
45
Views
7K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
8K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K