The inelastic collision between a disk and a rotating platform

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Leo Liu
Messages
353
Reaction score
156
Homework Statement
A FR question in 2019 AP Physics C Exam (Version 2)
Relevant Equations
Rotational Kinetic Energy, Conservation of Angular Momentum
A disk is dropped on a platform rotating at a constant angular speed ##\omega_i## as shown below.
Diagram of a disk above a horizontal rotating platform on a vertical axle, with a rightward arrow beside the platform indicating its rotation direction.

The question asks whether the final kinetic energy of the platform is conserved. I understand the angular momentum is always conserved provided that the net torque is 0, so I wrote the following equation:
$$I_{platform} \omega_i = (I_{platform}+I_{disk}) \omega_f$$
From this I inferred that ##\frac 1 2 I_{platform} {\omega_i}^2 \neq \frac 1 2 (I_{platform}+I_{disk}) {\omega_f}^2##.

My questions are as follows: Why is the energy not conserved in the collision, and how is the energy dissipated?

Thank you in advance.
 
Attachments
  • Printed AP Physics C 2019 free-response question text: a student uses a rotating platform with rotational inertia 3.1 kg·m² to find the rotational inertia of an unknown object dropped onto it, and a graph of final angular speed against initial angular speed is to be drawn.
    1588882478810.png
    14.5 KB · Views: 218
  • Multiple-choice question on kinetic energy of a spinning platform before and after an object is dropped on it, with options Kf < Ki, Kf = Ki, Kf > Ki, a justification prompt, and a grading rubric with a red-circled example answer about an inelastic collision.
    1588883047773.png
    19.3 KB · Views: 184
Last edited:
What force must act between the platform and the disk in order to equalise their angular velocities? Does this force dissipate mechanical energy into anything else?
 
etotheipi said:
What force must act between the platform and the disk in order to equalise their angular velocities? Does this force dissipate mechanical energy into anything else?
I think it's kinetic friction because the angular speed of the platform decreases as the rotation of the disk speeds up. Am I right?
 
Leo Liu said:
I think it's kinetic friction because the angular speed of the platform decreases as the rotation of the disk speeds up. Am I right?

Yes that's right.

And friction dissipates mechanical energy into thermal energy. Actually, the total work done by friction at the interface, ##W##, is the change in mechanical energy of the system. The change in thermal energy of the system is ##-W##. Energy is conserved... just not KE!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Leo Liu