- #1
- 18,767
- 13,586
I am not going to look up specific threads to support that assertion because I assume they have been seen by all those who regularly read threads on the HUP. If necessary, I'll dig up a few.
The two points of view expressed in various threads are as follows
1) Simultaneous measurements for two characteristics that are governed by the HUP can give arbitrarily precise (including exact) values but successive measurements from the same setup will not give the same results. That is the fundamental meaning of the HUP. Single measurements are not constrained by the HUP but repeated measurements based on the same setup do not give consistent results, they give a probability spread like the single slit experiment.
2) Simultaneous measurements of the exact values of two such characteristics of one quantum object at one time is not possible. Period. That is the fundamental meaning of the HUP
As I said, I have seen threads that say one or the other of these is true and the implication is that the other is not.
How about the mods do a FAQ answer on this and pin it in the Quantum Physics Forum?
I do not really want to start that argument here in this thread because the points of view have already been expressed in various threads. Again, what I would like, if possible and reasonable, is for the moderators and Science Advisers to agree on which is true and pin the answer to this forum for all to see.
Thanks,
Paul
The two points of view expressed in various threads are as follows
1) Simultaneous measurements for two characteristics that are governed by the HUP can give arbitrarily precise (including exact) values but successive measurements from the same setup will not give the same results. That is the fundamental meaning of the HUP. Single measurements are not constrained by the HUP but repeated measurements based on the same setup do not give consistent results, they give a probability spread like the single slit experiment.
2) Simultaneous measurements of the exact values of two such characteristics of one quantum object at one time is not possible. Period. That is the fundamental meaning of the HUP
As I said, I have seen threads that say one or the other of these is true and the implication is that the other is not.
How about the mods do a FAQ answer on this and pin it in the Quantum Physics Forum?
I do not really want to start that argument here in this thread because the points of view have already been expressed in various threads. Again, what I would like, if possible and reasonable, is for the moderators and Science Advisers to agree on which is true and pin the answer to this forum for all to see.
Thanks,
Paul