This hurricane Harvey/Irma is nuts

95 replies · 26K views · last reply
Not just one house; similar story for most of subdivision plus a few nearby subs. We're talking around a few hundred homes northeastern edge of Addicks reservoir. Cutting it close, though
 
Greg Bernhardt said:
Irma now Cat 5
And headed straight for the warmer waters of the gulf. :eek:
 
It looks like it may turn north before entering the Gulf:

Weather map of the Atlantic showing Hurricane Irma's advisory for Tuesday 9:00 AM, with a red bar listing winds of 175 mph, moving west at 14 mph, pressure 929 mb, at 16.7N 57.7W, and a cluster of yellow forecast track lines fanning westward over Cuba and toward Florida, plus a pink UKM track and blue track lines.
 
My youngest daughter just moved from Homestead(just South of Miami) to Kentucky. Looks like good timing. This could be another Andrew or Donna.

Wide view of a flattened area of debris and wreckage under a darkened sky, with bent palm trees and a lightning bolt striking near a water tower labeled HOMESTEAD.


Wind damage not flood
...

Photo of a palm tree trunk with large torn sheets of plywood wrapped around it, beside a light-colored single-story house with a window and shutters in the background.
 
Greg Bernhardt said:
@MarkFL how are you preparing?

I've got all my supplies, and I can board up the windows in less than an hour, as I store boards cut for each window. Generator is good to go, plenty of fuel. I will evacuate with my mother, and youngest sister and her family if that looks prudent.

I'm in NE Florida, on the Atlantic coast about 38 miles south of Jacksonville, and the latest spaghetti models I have seen are beginning to move to the west a bit. But, I know it is still too far off for anything to be considered likely at this point.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stoomart
This is nuts! All three of these storms are expected to be hurricanes by Friday.
NHC map of Atlantic tropical cyclones and disturbances dated Wed Sep 6 2017 10:48 am EDT, showing hurricane symbols for Katia over the Gulf of Mexico, Irma near the Leeward Islands, and Jose in the central Atlantic.


The current track for Irma is frightening. The current forecast is a direct strike on Miami.
NHC forecast cone map for Hurricane Irma, 11 AM AST Advisory 30, September 6, 2017, showing the probable storm track from the Leeward Islands northwest across the Bahamas and Cuba toward Florida, with day-by-day positions and colored watch and warning areas.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: MarkFL
It's about as tall on the map as all of Florida.. That's a big one.

This will be an historic weather map.

Infrared satellite image from GOES-13, dated 06 September 2017 at 2015Z, Naval Research Laboratory, of the Atlantic and Caribbean showing a large swirling hurricane with a well-defined eye east of Hispaniola, plus another storm to the west over Mexico and one to the southeast.
 
I would like to see the mechanical engineers as well as others weigh in on what kind of structures, if any, can stand up to a cat 5. Among other things, I've always thought that building houses out of wood is not wise here in America. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I've read that North America has the worst weather catastrophes of any other region in the world.

I see two basic problems. We have overpopulation and global warming. The effects of overpopulation are clear enough. As for global warming, is there peer reviewed analysis showing that global warming is leading to more severe weather? I've heard there is lots of it; perhaps the weather experts can provide some good examples.

Finally, once again I link to Dr. James Powell. At the top of the page are the following two videos. For the tl;dr crowd, these are very short indeed. I wish more people would visit his site and spread the word. It might cut down on scientific ignorance regarding this question.

http://jamespowell.org/

Best wishes and good luck to all the unfortunate people who are caught up in these weather catastrophes. Kudos to the first responders and the altruistic ordinary citizens who have helped as best they can.



P.S. there are two nuclear power plants which may be in Irma's path.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They keep moving the predicted path Eastward Last night it was centered over Miami.

National Hurricane Center map of Hurricane Irma warning #32 with forecast track in colored dots from the Caribbean northwest toward Florida, with cone of uncertainty and a text advisory box at upper right.


i think there's a good chance it'll miss Florida's mainland .

The Weather Channel current surface analysis map of North America, 7 September 2017 16:12 UTC, showing high (H) and low (L) pressure centres, fronts, precipitation shading, and a hand-drawn arrow labelled 'This easterly flow might grab it' pointing toward the Atlantic near Florida.


old jim
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Spinnor and russ_watters
NASA has a YouTube channel with lots of videos. Here's one that shows global warming from 1880-2015.



They have released a new one for 1880-2016 which is downloadable. This page contains information and links about how they come up with it. I include the 2015 video because at least on my browser the bottom part gets cut off a bit on the NASA page.

https://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/details.cgi?aid=4546
 
This one is interesting because it shows a guy in a wind tunnel at up to Cat 5 wind speed.

 
It looks like Florida is seriously screwed. Irma is now predicted to run straight up the middle of the state all the way to Georgia. :olduhh:
The only upside is that it won't be a major hurricane for very long once it's inland.

NHC forecast map of Hurricane Irma, advisory 37, 5 AM EDT Friday September 8, 2017, showing the probable track cone from the Caribbean northwest toward Florida and Georgia with 2 AM Sun to 2 AM Wed timestamps.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Spinnor
Hurricane season is the price you pay for those fabulous Florida winters.

Barring a last minute turn East - any substandard construction will get found out, as happened with Andrew. This one must be 4X the diameter of Andrew.
 
jim hardy said:
Hurricane season is the price you pay for those fabulous Florida winters.

Barring a last minute turn East - any substandard construction will get found out, as happened with Andrew. This one must be 4X the diameter of Andrew.
Last description I heard was Irma was bigger than Texas...
 
Visible satellite image of Hurricane Irma over the Caribbean and Florida, with a red arrow labelled 'Call it 6 degrees of latitude ..equals 414 miles' spanning from about 24N to 20N, and a timestamp of 09/08/17 1400Z GOES-13 VIS.


Key West to Jacksonville is only 5.8 degrees
 
Borg said:
It looks like Florida is seriously screwed. Irma is now predicted to run straight up the middle of the state all the way to Georgia. :olduhh:
The only upside is that it won't be a major hurricane for very long once it's inland.

View attachment 210626

In bowling language I think this is going to be a strike though I thought if it hugged the coast more damage would be done?
 
Spinnor said:
In bowling language I think this is going to be a strike though I thought if it hugged the coast more damage would be done?
I think that this will be much worse. The previous path had it going back out to sea after passing over Miami which would have limited the severest winds to a smaller quadrant.

Now the eye will pass over most of the state until it drops down from hurricane status somewhere north of Orlando. Winds in excess of 100 MPH are expected on both coasts. Towns along the center of the state are going to experience 125 - 150 MPH eastward blowing winds followed up minutes later with nearly the same wind speeds coming from the west after the eye passes. Whetever doesn't get blown away from the eastward winds, will be bent over - towards the west. When the westward winds arrive, those things will form a perfect trap for the air. It's going to be terrible for anyplace south of Orlando. North of that will still get hurricane force winds but it shouldn't be above Cat 2 by then.
 
This article shows where, hazardous wastes sites, hospitals, and nuclear plants are WRT possible hurricane Irma paths.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Aufbauwerk 2045
I was looking for an explanation of the European model people are talking about. It is reputed to be the most accurate. I found this page.

To quote from the article:

"Now, you may be wondering, "Why is the official forecast so far to the left, when all of the other models had moved east?" The answer is the European model. This forecast system has superior hardware to run its calculations. But more importantly, it has a method by which it better assimilates real-world data—observations from weather networks around the world, atmospheric soundings, reconnaissance aircraft, and much more—into its calculations."

I normally don't watch TV, but I do when there's something this important going on. I have yet to see anyone point out differences between the models and explain why they differ. I might have missed it, but I've been watching for many hours.

People in authority are making decisions based on these models. This would seem to be an extremely important issue, given that so many lives, not to mention property and money, are at stake! Seems like a good area for a PhD thesis for someone who is qualified.

https://arstechnica.com/science/201...ost-accurate-weather-model-predicts-for-irma/
 
Aufbauwerk 2045 said:
I was looking for an explanation of the European model people are talking about. It is reputed to be the most accurate. I found this page.

To quote from the article:

"Now, you may be wondering, "Why is the official forecast so far to the left, when all of the other models had moved east?" The answer is the European model. This forecast system has superior hardware to run its calculations. But more importantly, it has a method by which it better assimilates real-world data—observations from weather networks around the world, atmospheric soundings, reconnaissance aircraft, and much more—into its calculations."

I normally don't watch TV, but I do when there's something this important going on. I have yet to see anyone point out differences between the models and explain why they differ. I might have missed it, but I've been watching for many hours.

People in authority are making decisions based on these models. This would seem to be an extremely important issue, given that so many lives, not to mention property and money, are at stake! Seems like a good area for a PhD thesis for someone who is qualified.

https://arstechnica.com/science/201...ost-accurate-weather-model-predicts-for-irma/

They were warned the US models would give inferior forecasts.

http://mashable.com/2017/03/10/hurricane-forecasts-suffer-gfs-model-upgrade/#_prSAMDYQmqV
Florian Pappenberger, the director of forecasts at the European Center for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts in Reading, England, said at his agency, there are cases where the model is tinkered with and the results backslide in accuracy rather than taking a step forward.

https://arstechnica.com/science/201...e-been-pretty-terrible-during-hurricane-irma/
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Aufbauwerk 2045
At least one Key West cam is still functioning this morning.

 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stoomart
Borg said:
At least one Key West cam is still functioning this morning.



Strange, the track puts the eye almost over the above with highest winds at 130mph. Winds in the webcam don't look any where near that severe.

WSI tropical cyclone tracking map of Hurricane Irma, September 2017, showing forecast track, wind probability contours and watch and warning zones over Florida and the Gulf of Mexico.


Google maps puts the eye(?), 24.4n 81.5w, 20miles south of Key West at 7am.