Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Throwing a string into a blackhole

  1. Aug 3, 2007 #1
    if i threw a string from a great distance into a blackhole what would happen? if something was attached to the other end of the string would that thing eventually get realed in?
  2. jcsd
  3. Aug 3, 2007 #2


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor

    The short answer is that either the string will break, or the object attached to the string will get reeled in.

    There are physical limits as to how strong a string can be, one of them is imposed by the "weak energy condition", another limit is imposed by requiring that the speed of sound in the string can't be greater than the speed of light.

    There is a rather detailed (and technical) analysis of this online at http://gregegan.customer.netspace.net.au/SCIENCE/Rindler/RindlerHorizon.html

    which uses a relativistic elasticity model (called the hyperelastic model) to model the characteristics of the string.

    The hyperelastic model is (relatively) easy to work with mathematically but will only give sensible results if the input parameters are restricted to a reasonable physical range.

    The webpage includes some gif-movies of the simulation results, and also has some references to the literature on relativistic elasticity.
  4. Aug 3, 2007 #3
    so i just skipped to the end cause i really don't know anything about GR and we have this

    "Although a string lowered in this fashion appears doomed to break eventually, this example shows that there's no reason it can't survive intact not only after crit, but also after the bottom of the string has passed through the horizon according to the string's own definition of simultaneity. In other words, a spacelike slice orthogonal to the world lines of the string's elements can run all the way from the bottom of the string, on the far side of the Rindler horizon, to the point of unreeling, with the tension everywhere remaining well below the limit set by the weak energy condition."

    so now suppose this string was wrapped around a generator. what then? if the string doesn't break and turns the generator we get power from the blackhole? is there something i'm missing?
  5. Aug 3, 2007 #4


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor

    You should read a bit further:

  6. Aug 3, 2007 #5


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    1. You wouldn't be able to enjoy the benefits of this energy indefinitely, since the generator would get pulled closer to the black hole when you do this.

    2. The process you describe doesn't move energy from inside the event horizon to outside, because the rope itself has lots of energy (E=mc2 remember). So the process will put more energy into the black hole, not steal energy from it.
  7. Aug 3, 2007 #6


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor

    You can extract some of an objects rest mass energy by dropping it into a black hole, if that's the point of the original question. Black holes are often associated with very energetic "jets", for instance, and it is the gravitational energy of the infalling matter that helps power them.


    The black hole grows in mass by the 'energy at infinity' of the infalling matter, not by the rest mass of the infalling matter. This means that part of the energy (including the rest energy) of the infalling matter will go into increasing the mass of the black hole, and part will usually be radiated away during the fall in one form or other. So the total energy of the system stays constant, part of the mass of the infalling object is converted into various forms of energy and radiated away, the rest goes into increasing the mass of the black hole.

    While energy conservation can be problematical in GR, a black hole isn't one of those cases where this issue arises. The black hole space-time is static AND asymptotically flat.
    Last edited: Aug 3, 2007
  8. Aug 4, 2007 #7
    From what I understand:

    Let the string, marked off in equal lengths, to be attached to an observer. For the stationary observer well outside of the event horizon, the lengths will appear to Fitzgerald contract infinitely as the string leads toward this limiting surface. For the observer lowered through the event horizon on the string, the lengths conserve themselves locally, but in the direction of the apparent singularity one sees the event horizon as approaching a pointlike gravitational (and observational) collapse.
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook