f95toli said:
However, a buffer layer is only one small step of the process and even when you've found a good buffer there is still the problem of introducing it in a production line (at a resonable cost). Hence, there is no guarantee that this will ever be used in mass produced electronics.
In our times, every step is a small step and there's no big jump in scientific progress, especially when it comes to engineering. And all the papers that have been published in the last 10 years have no guarantee that they will ever be useful.
So I am not seeing anything different for this breakthrough. How can you know it's different than any other breakthrough? Are you saying anything new here?
f95toli said:
Most semiconductor companies announce "breakthroughs" every 6 months or so and I've been around long enough to know that most of it never goes anywhere.
I cannot agree with this. It is the same semiconductor companies that bestowed this technology a trillion-fold increase in every sense possible. It is the same semiconductor companies that revolutionized the world with computers, made possible the cell phone you are using right now, the network backbone your net connection is on, your car, your digital watch, your tv, i.e things that you cannot even breathe without, right now.
These are all thanks to those "breakthroughs" that went NOWHERE -- but NOT due to a number of physicists who were "excited" by a weird "quantum mechanical" effect that could ONLY be replicated with a 50$ million worth experimental apparatus.
f95toli said:
Moreover, important is not the same thing as exciting. Like most physicits I am primarily interested in the PHYSICS, not the applications of what I do.
I don't know how you come to that conclusion on behalf of "most physicists". You must have an enormous amount of data, based on polls, personal opinions when it comes to physicists' taste and perception on the delicate difference between "exciting and important" in their professional lives.
----------
My point is (and was) this: It is NOT the people who were working on asymptotic freedom theories back in the 70's who made everything you see today possible. No it was not string theory, not some weird "tunneling time" experiment, or not quantum gravity theories.
It was those semiconductor companies, and it was their little discoveries. To announce a breakthrough like that on behalf of a huge organization like Toshiba takes YEARS of research and involves a SWARM of scientists.
It's not like submitting a paper to PRB and pretending it is the MOST EXCITING experimental work ever!
So, please...