Trouble with difficulty of books

  • Thread starter Thread starter IKonquer
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Books Difficulty
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
3 replies · 3K views
IKonquer
Messages
47
Reaction score
0
I am very confused as to what type of books are appropriate for my level of mathematics. I am trying to learn Abstract Algebra myself so I am reading from Artin's Algebra. Unfortunately I am having a lot of difficulty understand the proofs he presents in the book. So am I right to say this book is way above my head? I've had linear algebra already, but there was no significant proof content. Should I just try an easier book and try to read Artin later? Or am I not spending enough time learning the material?

Also how should books like Artin's Algebra be read?

Thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Last edited by a moderator:
I second Pinter as first book on Abstract Algebra. I also second the suggestion of a book on how to do proofs.
 
IKonquer said:
Also how should books like Artin's Algebra be read?
Thinking more about your general question...

Textbooks in mathematics can be very misleading. The introduction usually says something like: "This book should be accessible to an undergraduate with only a course in X and Y." This is almost always completely false.

The fundamental material in something like Artin is not that hard if you have actually covered all the (real) background material and have some of that nebulous quality of "mathematical maturity." This is a good general rule: Math is easy if you have seen some of it before, it is hard if you haven't. More effort at a book beyond your level is usually not the solution. Go back a step and try to fill in the holes, then try again.

People on this forum have good recommendations for many different topics. However, it can be very difficult to know what level they are aimed at and the recommender may not remember the stage they were at when they read it. Some of the best books out there are almost impossible if you are unprepared, but almost divine if you are ready.

This goes for courses as well. Many people take the wrong course at the wrong time and get convinced that they are bad at mathematics. A good university will design the course progression to get you from A to B with all the right tools. However, you may have to do some of it yourself.

If there is one secret to doing well in math, it is to make sure you have the background sorted out for the next step you are attempting.