Understanding KVL Equations for Circuit Analysis

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Tiziano

Homework Statement


The following circuit is given.
Circuit schematic with three batteries labelled E1, E2 and E3, resistors R1, R2, R3, R4, internal resistances r and R, junctions C and D, and currents i1, i2 and i3 marked with arrows.

I intend to calculate the current in every resistor (every quantity except i1, i2, i3, is known).

My textbook states that ℰ3-ℰ1 = (R1+R2+R3+R4+2r)*i, but I think it should be -ℰ3+ℰ1 on the left-hand side, since the current enters the negative and leaves the positive terminal of ℰ1 and does the opposite with ℰ3.

Homework Equations


Ohm's generalized law for a closed circuit (the algebric sum of the emf's equals R*i, where R is the total resistance)

The Attempt at a Solution


I've simply computed the same equation of the book, but I don't understand why my signs are wrong.
 
Since you did not show any work, it is difficult to help you.

It is also not clear what is indicated by the curved arrow across the middle leg just below C. What are we to suppose this is?
 
My textbook states that ℰ3-ℰ1 = (R1+R2+R3+R4+2r)*i, but I think it should be -ℰ3+ℰ1 on the left-hand side, since the current enters the negative and leaves the positive terminal of ℰ1 and does the opposite with ℰ3.
Isn't that what they did? (change sides change sign).

The rule is: the sum of the voltages is zero. So, for the big loop:
##\mathscr{E}_1 -R_1i_1 -R_2i_3 -\mathscr{E}_3 +r i_3 +R_4i_3 +R_3i_1 +ri_1 = 0## ... tidy it up, and express as emf = other stuff.

I don't think that ℰ3-ℰ1 = (R1+R2+R3+R4+2r)*i is correct as written though.
 
Hi Tiziano,

To me it looks like you're writing KVL equations for loop analysis of the circuit using loops as follows:
Circuit schematic with three batteries labeled E1, E2 and E3, each in series with an internal resistance r, and resistors R1, R2, R3, R4 and R on the outer and middle branches. Blue loop current labeled i and green loop current labeled i2 are drawn around the circuit.


Is this correct?

If so, I agree with you that the book's equation ℰ3-ℰ1 = (R1+R2+R3+R4+2r)*i does not handle the voltage sources correctly for the given loop with current i (shown in blue above), and that your own version is correct.