Understanding Limit: N=1 +/- sqrt(Ae^(2rt))/sqrt(1-Ae^(2rt))

  • Thread starter binbagsss
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Limits
4 replies · 2K views · last reply
binbagsss
Messages
1,291
Reaction score
12

Homework Statement


[/B]
Trying to understand this limit:
Typeset equation N = 1 ± sqrt(Ae^(2rt)(1 − Ae^(2rt))) / (1 − Ae^(2rt)), followed by text: If A < 0 (required for real solutions) then in the limit t → ∞ the two possible solutions tend to 0 and 2, suggesting they are stable equilibria and the N = 1 equilibrium is unstable.

where ##r>0##

Homework Equations


[/B]
I think it's best to proceed by writing this as:

## N=1 \pm \frac{\sqrt{Ae^{2rt}}}{\sqrt{1-Ae^{2rt}}} ##

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
since ##r>0 ## the exponential term ##\to ## ##\infty## and then since ##A<0## I get two results for ## lim_{t \to \infty} Ae^{2rt} ## depending on ## |A| ##.

a) If ##|A| < 1 ## it goes to zero.
if b) ## |A| \geq 1 ## it goes to ##-\infty##

and where the magnitude of A is not specified in the question.

If it was however for case a) the limit is of an determinate form: ##1 \pm \frac{0}{1} = 1 ##

however for b) i get ## 1 \pm \frac{\sqrt{-\infty}}{\sqrt{1+\infty}}## , and I can't see l'hospital's rule being much use here due to the square root and exponential terms.

Many thanks in advance.
 
Attachments
  • Typeset equation N = 1 ± sqrt(Ae^(2rt)(1 − Ae^(2rt))) / (1 − Ae^(2rt)), followed by text: If A < 0 (required for real solutions) then in the limit t → ∞ the two possible solutions tend to 0 and 2, suggesting they are stable equilibria and the N = 1 equilibrium is unstable.
    limbio.png
    8.2 KB · Views: 966
binbagsss said:

Homework Statement


[/B]
Trying to understand this limit:
View attachment 217254
where ##r>0##

Homework Equations


[/B]
I think it's best to proceed by writing this as:

## N=1 \pm \frac{\sqrt{Ae^{2rt}}}{\sqrt{1-Ae^{2rt}}} ##

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
since ##r>0 ## the exponential term ##\to ## ##\infty## and then since ##A<0## I get two results for ## lim_{t \to \infty} Ae^{2rt} ## depending on ## |A| ##.

a) If ##|A| < 1 ## it goes to zero.
if b) ## |A| \geq 1 ## it goes to ##-\infty##

and where the magnitude of A is not specified in the question.

If it was however for case a) the limit is of an determinate form: ##1 \pm \frac{0}{1} = 1 ##

however for b) i get ## 1 \pm \frac{\sqrt{-\infty}}{\sqrt{1+\infty}}## , and I can't see l'hospital's rule being much use here due to the square root and exponential terms.

Many thanks in advance.

$$f(t) = \frac{\sqrt{A e^{2rt}}}{\sqrt{1-Ae^{2rt}}}
= \frac{e^{-rt}}{e^{-rt}} \frac{\sqrt{A e^{2rt}}}{\sqrt{1-Ae^{2rt}}}
= \frac{\sqrt{A}}{\sqrt{e^{-2rt} - A} } \to \frac{\sqrt{A}}{\sqrt{-A}}$$
 
Ray Vickson said:
$$f(t) = \frac{\sqrt{A e^{2rt}}}{\sqrt{1-Ae^{2rt}}}
= \frac{e^{-rt}}{e^{-rt}} \frac{\sqrt{A e^{2rt}}}{\sqrt{1-Ae^{2rt}}}
= \frac{\sqrt{A}}{\sqrt{e^{-2rt} - A} } \to \frac{\sqrt{A}}{\sqrt{-A}}$$
but A<0, so the numerator is not real?
 
binbagsss said:
but A<0, so the numerator is not real?

Right, but no less real than the original form ##\sqrt{A e^{2rt}}##.
 
Last edited:
Ray Vickson said:
Right, but no less real than the original form ##\sqrt{A e^{2rt}}##.

so then do we not get ## 1 \pm i ## rather than ## 1 \pm 1 ## as in the solution above?