Using Gauss theorem for surface integrals over multiple planes

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
fonseh
Messages
521
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


Is the solution provided by the author wrong ? Stokes theorem is used to calculate the line integral of vector filed , am i right ?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


To find the surface integral of many different planes in a solid , we need to use Gauss theorem , right ?
 
Attachments
  • 3D diagram of the plane x + y + z = 2 forming a triangular face in the first octant, with intercepts marked 2 on the x, y and z axes, and boundary curves labelled C1, C2 and C3 with orientation arrows.
    492.JPG
    17.8 KB · Views: 504
  • Worked solution showing curl of F as the determinant with i, j, k row, result 0i + 2j + 0k, surface integral set up over region R with normal vector and integral of 2 dA equal to 4, plus an alternative line citing Stokes theorem.
    490.JPG
    26.4 KB · Views: 529
  • Handwritten worked solution evaluating a line integral around three segments C1, C2 and C3 of a closed path, with the final sum 4 + 2 + -2 = 4.
    491.JPG
    28.4 KB · Views: 504
The author doesn't seem to specify what surface integral he is asking for. If he wants ## \int F \cdot dA ##, Gauss' law works for the surface enclosing a volume, and wouldn't apply here. If he wants you to evaluate ## \int \nabla \times F \cdot \, dA ##, you can use Stokes theorem and alternatively compute the line integral of ## \oint F \cdot \, ds ## around the perimeter. ## \\ ## editing... If the author wants you to evaluate ## \int F \cdot \, dA ##, there are no shortcuts that I know of=neither Gauss' law or Stokes theorem will apply. You simply need to crank it out the long way... And none of us are infallible=it is my guess the author made a mistake.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: fonseh
Charles Link said:
The author doesn't seem to specify what surface integral he is asking for. If he wants ## \int F \cdot dA ##, Gauss' law works for the surface enclosing a volume, and wouldn't apply here. If he wants you to evaluate ## \int \nabla \times F \cdot \, dA ##, you can use Stokes theorem and alternatively compute the line integral of ## \oint F \cdot \, ds ## around the perimeter. ## \\ ## editing... If the author wants you to evaluate ## \int F \cdot \, dA ##, there are no shortcuts that I know of=neither Gauss' law or Stokes theorem will apply. You simply need to crank it out the long way... And none of us are infallible=it is my guess the author made a mistake.
Do you mean that the author maybe mean find the line integral and not find surface integral in this question ?
 
fonseh said:
Do you mean that the author maybe mean find the line integral and not find surface integral in this question ?
Frequently in such problems the author wants you to demonstrate Stokes' theorem by working it both ways. It's a learning thing.