Variation of parameters inhomogeneous DE help

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around solving an inhomogeneous second-order differential equation of the form x²y" - 3xy' + 4y = x⁴. Participants are exploring the associated homogeneous equation and the method of variation of parameters.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the need to find the roots of the homogeneous equation to determine the complementary solution y(h). There are questions about whether the roots are imaginary and if the quadratic formula should be used. Some participants mention given solutions for the homogeneous equation and explore the implications of using variation of parameters versus undetermined coefficients.

Discussion Status

There is an ongoing exploration of the problem, with some participants providing guidance on the use of given solutions and the change of variables. Others reflect on their previous approaches and clarify their understanding of the methods involved.

Contextual Notes

Participants are working under the constraints of a homework assignment, which includes specific methods to be used for solving the differential equation. There is an emphasis on understanding the relationship between the particular and general solutions.

xtipd
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Ok here's my problem:
1. Solve the inhomogeneous second order de:
x^2y" - 3xy' + 4y =x^4


2. Worked: y(p) = 1/4*x^4

Given: y(1) = x^2
y(2) = log(x)*x^2


3. I just need help getting the roots of the given de so i can determine y(h) of this de. As i have already solved the particular solution y(p) and then the general solution
y(g) = y(h) + y(p)

Im thinking this has imaginary roots as i gave it a crack to get y(h) and the best i could think of was (r - 2/x) - 1/x = 0, which doesn't really lead me anywhere i think.

Do i have to use the quadratic formula to get the roots of this equation? and if so some pointers in the right direction would be much appreciated!

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
solve x^2y" - 3xy' + 4y=0 to get two solutions,y1(x) and y2(x), for the variations of parameters method.
 
Last edited:
xtipd said:
Ok here's my problem:
1. Solve the inhomogeneous second order de:
x^2y" - 3xy' + 4y =x^4


2. Worked: y(p) = 1/4*x^4

Given: y(1) = x^2
y(2) = log(x)*x^2


3. I just need help getting the roots of the given de so i can determine y(h) of this de. As i have already solved the particular solution y(p) and then the general solution
y(g) = y(h) + y(p)
? You are given that two independent solutions to the associated homogeneous equation are x^2 and log(x)x^2.

Im thinking this has imaginary roots as i gave it a crack to get y(h) and the best i could think of was (r - 2/x) - 1/x = 0, which doesn't really lead me anywhere i think.

Do i have to use the quadratic formula to get the roots of this equation? and if so some pointers in the right direction would be much appreciated!
You don't need to do that at all, you are given those solutions!
Of course, the general solution to the entire equation is y(x)= Ax^2+ Blog(x)x^2+ (1/4)x^4 but I suspect you got that yp by "undetermined coefficients" so have not followed the instructions to use "variation of parameters".

Thanks
Although, as I said, you do not need to solve the characteristic equation, no it does not have imaginary roots. You can convert a "Euler type" or "equipotential equation" to a "constant coefficients" equation with the change of variables t= log(x) or x= e^t.
dy/dx= dy/dt dt/dx= (1/x)dy/dt so d^2y/dx^2= d ((1/x)dy/dt)/dx= (1/x) d(dy/dt)/dx- 1/x^2 dy/dx= (1/x)^2 d^2y/dt^2- (1/x^2)dy/dt so x^2d^2y/dt^2- 3x dy/dx+ 4y= x^2(1/x^2)(d^2y/dt^2- dy/dt)- 3x (1/x)dy/dt+ 4y= d^2y/dt^2- 4 dy/dt+ 4y= 0. The characteristic equation for that constant coefficients equation, and so for the equipotential equation, is r^2- 4r+ 4= (r- 2)^2= 0 which has r= 2 as a double root. For a constant coefficients equation, that would mean the solution was y= Ae^(2t)+ Bte^(2t). Since t= log(x), e^(2t)= e^(2log(x))= e^(log(x^2))= x^2 and te^(2t)= log(x)x^2, as "given".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
HallsofIvy said:
? You are given that two independent solutions to the associated homogeneous equation are x^2 and log(x)x^2.


You don't need to do that at all, you are given those solutions!
Of course, the general solution to the entire equation is y(x)= Ax^2+ Blog(x)x^2+ (1/4)x^4 but I suspect you got that yp by "undetermined coefficients" so have not followed the instructions to use "variation of parameters".


Although, as I said, you do not need to solve the characteristic equation, no it does not have imaginary roots. You can convert a "Euler type" or "equipotential equation" to a "constant coefficients" equation with the change of variables t= log(x) or x= e^t.
dy/dx= dy/dt dt/dx= (1/x)dy/dt so d^2y/dx^2= d ((1/x)dy/dt)/dx= (1/x) d(dy/dt)/dx- 1/x^2 dy/dx= (1/x)^2 d^2y/dt^2- (1/x^2)dy/dt so x^2d^2y/dt^2- 3x dy/dx+ 4y= x^2(1/x^2)(d^2y/dt^2- dy/dt)- 3x (1/x)dy/dt+ 4y= d^2y/dt^2- 4 dy/dt+ 4y= 0. The characteristic equation for that constant coefficients equation, and so for the equipotential equation, is r^2- 4r+ 4= (r- 2)^2= 0 which has r= 2 as a double root. For a constant coefficients equation, that would mean the solution was y= Ae^(2t)+ Bte^(2t). Since t= log(x), e^(2t)= e^(2log(x))= e^(log(x^2))= x^2 and te^(2t)= log(x)x^2, as "given".

We were given the solution y(1) = x^2 was a solution, then had to prove y(2) = log(x)x^2 is also a solution.

Haha your spot on about me getting y(p) via constant coefficients, which i ended up realising just before and ajusted my solution. Seems so stupid now i look back at it.

I did end up using the change of variables with x= e^t and also got the root r(1)= r(2) = 2 so y= Ae^(2t)+ Bte^(2t) just like you mentioned, and went on to get the general solution.

All cleared up now, help was much appreciated!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K