Voltage Divider Circuits. Set Me Straight.

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around voltage divider circuits, specifically addressing the behavior of output voltages (V OUT 1 and V OUT 2) in relation to resistors and a voltage source. Participants explore concepts related to current flow, voltage drops across resistors, and the implications of circuit connections.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions whether V OUT 1 is higher than V OUT 2 and how current behaves through the resistors.
  • Another participant asserts that voltage drops across every resistor and that current remains constant through circuit elements, suggesting a specific voltage relationship.
  • Several participants express confusion regarding the circuit's configuration, particularly the absence of a complete path for current flow, leading to claims that V OUT values are zero.
  • There is a discussion about the symbols used in the circuit diagram, with some participants noting that the ground symbol may be misleading.
  • One participant proposes a hypothetical circuit with LEDs and questions whether they would shine equally or at different brightness levels based on the resistors' configuration.
  • A later reply mentions that circuit elements in series will have the same current, implying that identical LEDs would shine equally.
  • Another participant highlights the non-linear voltage-current characteristics of LEDs, indicating a need for practical testing.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying opinions on the circuit's functionality, with some asserting that the circuit is meaningless without a complete path for current, while others attempt to clarify how the components interact. No consensus is reached regarding the behavior of the outputs or the implications of the circuit design.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations in understanding due to the circuit's incomplete configuration and the potential for confusion arising from the symbols used in the diagram. There is also mention of the need for practical experimentation to clarify theoretical points.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in basic electronics, voltage divider circuits, and practical applications of circuit design may find this discussion beneficial.

lucius
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Hello all.

I wonder if anybody could clear this up for a beginner.

In the circuit attached: Is V OUT 1 of a higher voltage than V OUT 2?

Does the current travel at 9V, until it drops at R1? Does it drop again at R2 and give an even lower voltage to V OUT 2? Or does the presence of two resistors apply the total resistance to the entire circuit, giving both V OUTs equally lowered voltage?

Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks.
 

Attachments

  • vd2.gif
    vd2.gif
    4.2 KB · Views: 578
Engineering news on Phys.org
The voltage drops across every resistor.
The current remains the same through every circuit element.
So:
9V > Vout1 > Vout2 > 0

This looks like an LTSpice circuit; have you tried just reading the values for Vout1 and Vout2?

p.s Welcome to PF :smile:
 
I downloaded the program just for this post. I don't yet know how to use it.
So, if I attach LEDs to both V OUTs, they will shine with equal brightness?

edit:

Thanks for the welcome! Sorry if this question should be obvious.
 
Last edited:
Vout2 = 0V. i don't like the voltage source symbol. i can't tell if Vout1 is -3V or +3V.
 
Proton Soup said:
Vout2 = 0V. i don't like the voltage source symbol. i can't tell if Vout1 is -3V or +3V.

The source is +9, if that helps. But I think I get the point guys. Thanks for the help!
 
Last edited:
Proton Soup said:
Vout2 = 0V. i don't like the voltage source symbol. i can't tell if Vout1 is -3V or +3V.

Aaaack, how did I miss this? There's no "circuit" here, no path for current to return to the voltage source.

So it's zero current through the resistors. Then all voltages are zero except at the +terminal of the source which is at +9V.

In principle, you'd want to connect the voltage source back to ground somehow.
 
Redbelly98 said:
Aaaack, how did I miss this? There's no "circuit" here, no path for current to return to the voltage source.

So it's zero current through the resistors. Then all voltages are zero except at the +terminal of the source which is at +9V.

In principle, you'd want to connect the voltage source back to ground somehow.

The symbols are perhaps slightly deceptive. The triangle at the bottom represents the ground. The Voltage source is meant to be a source of positive voltage - must be conventional flow. It's an unusual shape for a "circuit" but irrelevant to my question.

Which was whether each V OUT receives equal (0) voltage or if 1 receives more (1/3) than 2 (0).

Good thinking though.
 
Meaningless circuit because there is no circuit so no current flow and no volt drop so as it stands V1 = V2 = -9 v wrt the +ve of the source.

Does the arrow down mean 'earth' or 'ground'. It si not the right symbol. A arrow like that usually means that circuit connects with another.
 
Pumblechook said:
Meaningless circuit because there is no circuit so no current flow and no volt drop so as it stands V1 = V2 = -9 v wrt the +ve of the source.

Does the arrow down mean 'earth' or 'ground'. It si not the right symbol. A arrow like that usually means that circuit connects with another.

It does mean ground yes. It's an odd symbol; I know. However, that's what LTspice called a ground. Keep in mind I've accumulated a mere five minutes experience with the program, just today.

Say there is a circuit.

9V BATTERY NEG TERMINAL---R1(220)---LED1---R2(110)---LED2---POSITIVE TERMINAL​

In such a situation, where the total resistance leaves 0 voltage, will neither LED shine, or will one shine dimly while the other doesn't at all?

That's the best way in which I can ask this question. If that still doesn't make sense, I clearly understand too little and need to experiment some.

Thanks everyone for so much response!
 
  • #10
lucius said:
The symbols are perhaps slightly deceptive. The triangle at the bottom represents the ground. The Voltage source is meant to be a source of positive voltage - must be conventional flow. It's an unusual shape for a "circuit" but irrelevant to my question.

Which was whether each V OUT receives equal (0) voltage or if 1 receives more (1/3) than 2 (0).

Good thinking though.

I've used LTspice myself, but don't have it installed yet on this computer that I started using a month or 2 ago. Keep playing around with the program and the circuit, you'll learn the more you do it.

To make this circuit "meaningful" you'll need to connect the battery + back to ground. From what I remember, you click on the icon that looks like a line or wire along the top row of the LTspice window. Then you can draw the wire to make the connection. Hit <esc> (I think) to stop drawing the wire.

Say there is a circuit.

9V BATTERY NEG TERMINAL---R1(220)---LED1---R2(110)---LED2---POSITIVE TERMINAL

In such a situation, where the total resistance leaves 0 voltage, will neither LED shine, or will one shine dimly while the other doesn't at all?

Since the elements are all in series, and it's one big loop, both LED's shine equally (assuming they are identical to each other). Also, you could combine the two resistors into a single 330 ohms.

Circuit elements in series always have the same current. So this means the LED's, resistors, and battery all have the same current.
 
  • #11
Redbelly98 said:
I've used LTspice myself, but don't have it installed yet on this computer that I started using a month or 2 ago. Keep playing around with the program and the circuit, you'll learn the more you do it.

To make this circuit "meaningful" you'll need to connect the battery + back to ground. From what I remember, you click on the icon that looks like a line or wire along the top row of the LTspice window. Then you can draw the wire to make the connection. Hit <esc> (I think) to stop drawing the wire.



Since the elements are all in series, and it's one big loop, both LED's shine equally (assuming they are identical to each other). Also, you could combine the two resistors into a single 330 ohms.

Circuit elements in series always have the same current. So this means the LED's, resistors, and battery all have the same current.

Brilliant. Thanks!

Obviously quite an active community here. I look forward to next time. Thanks everyone!
 
  • #12
LEDs have a non-linear V-A curve. I will test some on a power supply later.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
6K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
8K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
68
Views
7K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K