Waiting for a Job Offer - Should I Accept Less Due to Age?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FlexGunship
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Age Job
Click For Summary
A recruiter has expressed strong interest in redefining a technical sales manager position for a young candidate, emphasizing both sales and engineering responsibilities, including potential international duties. The candidate is concerned about compensation, as the company seems fixated on their current salary, which does not reflect the new role's responsibilities. They argue that pay should align with the job's demands rather than their current earnings or age. The company has indicated a desire to offer a competitive salary to retain the candidate long-term, but the candidate is wary of being undervalued compared to less qualified candidates. The discussion highlights the complexities of salary negotiations and the importance of presenting a strong case for fair compensation.
  • #31
Don't worry about the recruiter. There are clueless people that exist in the middle that you have to deal with sometimes. Obviously the company people you are talking to are much more important/indicative.

I've been interviewing with a lot of companies these past two months for summer internships, and it's a mix of drooling over my resume/fantastic interviews, and talking with people who treat you like you've never had a job in your life. Some people have no business doing the interviewing/hiring and some are just completely clueless in general. It's very frustrating knowing you have had some great contacts within a company, potentially the top candidate with lots of relevant experience, but then walk out of an interview having no idea where you stand.

The first of the offers came in yesterday, and I expect more.

Everything you're saying about your discussions sounds good to me.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
Evo said:
For the same position? Unless they already work there, nothing should be shared about someone that doesn't work for them, IMO.

Perhaps it's because I worked for a Fortune 50 company, HR would not permit such a thing in an interview with a potential employee. Confidentiality and professionalism was essential.

Oh, and to clarify, no one mentioned ANY names.
 
  • #33
So it seems like they are trying to develop a new position and as such don't have a job description or pay range? What about the original job? Couldn't you take that and then when you get familiar with how things work within that company, be given the new position? By then they should have an idea of what the job is.

I cannot tell you how many times my job completely changed within the same company. Of course they sent me to school each time to learn the "new stuff", it's actually what I liked so much about working for a bleeding edge company, no way you can get stuck in a boring job.
 
  • #34
Evo said:
So it seems like they are trying to develop a new position and as such don't have a job description or pay range? What about the original job? Couldn't you take that and then when you get familiar with how things work within that company, be given the new position? By then they should have an idea of what the job is.

I cannot tell you how many times my job completely changed within the same company. Of course they sent me to school each time to learn the "new stuff", it's actually what I liked so much about working for a bleeding edge company, no way you can get stuck in a boring job.

Well, one of the things that intrigued them is that I've taken on much bigger projects than their company as a whole has. So they see some technical expertise and guidance that I might be able to bring to the company. That's why I think they're hesitant to just give me a "sales" job.

EDIT: Oooooorrrr... none of that is true. I hate trying to guess. I'm a realist, and every time I build up an assessment of the situation, I have to knock myself back to reality.
 
  • #35
FlexGunship said:
Well, one of the things that intrigued them is that I've taken on much bigger projects than their company as a whole has.

Sounds to me like they are looking to you for guidance and leadership.

Why don't you take the bull by the horns? Tell them what they need, how you can fulfill it, and what paltry sum you'll charge them to take their company to the next level? It's not a salary; it's an investment with an ROI!
 
  • #36
DaveC426913 said:
Sounds to me like they are looking to you for guidance and leadership.

Why don't you take the bull by the horns? Tell them what they need, how you can fulfill it, and what paltry sum you'll charge them to take their company to the next level? It's not a salary; it's an investment with an ROI!

Well, I kind of did. After interviews, I send an e-mail thanking each person in attendance for their time and include something a little personal ("hope that thing with such-and-such works out for you").

When I wrote to the president I included a note that said something along the lines of:

[President],

[The recruiter] keeps trying to get me to give him a salary figure. I've tried to explain to him that things seem to be evolving in new directions. Is the job title still going to be "regional sales manager?" [Recruiter] thinks so, but I've gotten a slightly different impression, especially after our one-on-one yesterday.

Just to be clear, I'm willing to take on as much responsibility as you care to entrust to me. I'm willing to make [company] my company and its success my job. I have exactly what you're looking for. I have a few ideas for new applications of your equipment, and I'd love to brainstorm with you engineers. I have this incredible gut feeling that you've got something a lot of people are looking for and we just need to find a way to get them connected with [company] and get them educated.

There are two ways to be heard in a conversation, [president]: you can speak the loudest, or you can have the most interesting things to say.

[Company] has some very interesting things to say.

Hope to hear from you soon,
[Flex]
 
Last edited:
  • #37
DaveC426913 said:
Why don't you take the bull by the horns? Tell them what they need, how you can fulfill it, and what paltry sum you'll charge them to take their company to the next level? It's not a salary; it's an investment with an ROI!

In a nutshell I agree. From what you've written on this thread they are definitely interested in you, forget what the recruiter says. They want you, and they want you for as little as possible. You've apparently exceeded their expectations and I doubt that they want to see you go.
 
  • #38
Yeah Flex, it sure does seem like the ball is in your court, and that this is an opportunity handed to you on a plate to impress them with your value (both kinds).
 
  • #39
Still nothing! I'm starting to think I really biffed the second interview or something.

EDIT: Or maybe he found this thread, and then searched for other posts by me and discovered my dark side...
 
  • #40
FlexGunship said:
Still nothing! I'm starting to think I really biffed the second interview or something.

EDIT: Or maybe he found this thread, and then searched for other posts by me and discovered my dark side...

In the second interview did you feel confident enough to refer to yourself as FlexGunship?
 
  • #41
dacruick said:
In the second interview did you feel confident enough to refer to yourself as FlexGunship?

Oh, sure. I also kicked over a garbage can and asked if he was "ready to rock."

As it turns out, he was not.

(Side note, since I kind of ctrl-c'd and ctrl-v'd my letter to him into this thread, a simple search would've revealed this thread. Google is a wonderful and mysterious thing.)

Got a brief e-mail response. The role has been broadened to either "Key Accounts Manager" or "National Sales Engineer." I was hoping for CEO, but... oh well... The offer hasn't come yet (if there is one), he simply said they'd be in touch "shortly." I'm hoping for at least $11.50/hr plus free snacks from the vending machine.

EDIT: I noticed, suspiciously, that both titles don't exist in the Salary.com database. Oh grumble.

DOUBLE EDIT: Seriously, though, I hope it comes soon, there's this project I've been working on which has got me really frustrated and I don't want to keep working on it. Essentially I'm trying to find the least common denominator of 1/2 and 1/3 whose denominator is expressible as 2N where N is an integer.

TRIPLE EDIT: That double edit was kind of a joke, actually. I wouldn't leave a job to avoid a project. I would, however, leave a job to avoid a co-worker.
 
Last edited:
  • #42
UPDATE:

So, I talked to one of my references and he indicated (in his words) that they were "high on me." And he was fairly certain that I would be getting an offer from them.

Well, it's been two and a half days. I'm used to getting an offer immediately, how long have people had to wait?
 
  • #43
FlexGunship said:
UPDATE:

So, I talked to one of my references and he indicated (in his words) that they were "high on me." And he was fairly certain that I would be getting an offer from them.

Well, it's been two and a half days. I'm used to getting an offer immediately, how long have people had to wait?
Always gotten the job during the first interview, followed up by a formal written offer letter.

It could be that they don't know what to offer you and that's the delay.
 
  • #44
Evo said:
Always gotten the job during the first interview, followed up by a formal written offer letter.

It could be that they don't know what to offer you and that's the delay.

Maybe. They did change the position for me so maybe they were less prepared.
 
  • #45
FlexGunship said:
Maybe. They did change the position for me so maybe they were less prepared.

sounds like you're getting the job. I wouldn't worry too much.
 
  • #46
dacruick said:
sounds like you're getting the job. I wouldn't worry too much.

Or maybe they interviewed someone after me!

Or maybe they decided they couldn't afford a new employee!

Or maybe the Kraken got them!
 
  • #47
FlexGunship said:
Or maybe they interviewed someone after me!

Or maybe they decided they couldn't afford a new employee!

Or maybe the Kraken got them!

You're right, I was being blindly comforting. You probably won't get the job. :-p
 
  • #48
dacruick said:
You're right, I was being blindly comforting. You probably won't get the job. :-p
:-p
 
  • #49
They decided not to make an offer citing, of course, the economy.
 
  • #50
FlexGunship said:
They decided not to make an offer citing, of course, the economy.

Get outta here. I'm sorry to hear the flex :frown:
 
  • #51
dacruick said:
Get outta here. I'm sorry to hear the flex :frown:

I'm really surprised, actually. The only consolation is that they're not hiring anyone. It's not like someone else got the job and I didn't. I just don't know why they went through so much effort creating a new job title, calling me back for a second interview, calling all of my references, explaining their new prototypes, letting me play with their software package, and disclosing all of their liquidity, debt, and related issues...

What a waste of everyone's time.
 
  • #52
FlexGunship said:
I'm really surprised, actually. The only consolation is that they're not hiring anyone. It's not like someone else got the job and I didn't. I just don't know why they went through so much effort creating a new job title, calling me back for a second interview, calling all of my references, explaining their new prototypes, letting me play with their software package, and disclosing all of their liquidity, debt, and related issues...

What a waste of everyone's time.

I feel like they wasted more than your time. There must have been a lot of mental energy invested into this, beyond what we've seen on this thread.
 
  • #53
dacruick said:
I feel like they wasted more than your time. There must have been a lot of mental energy invested into this, beyond what we've seen on this thread.

Not to mention I bought new clothes for the interview to better reflect what I understood the company image to be, I burned two vacation days (when I only get 10 a year), and I drove 2 hours each way twice.

I don't know... I was excited... thought it would be a great opportunity. I was really looking forward to trying something new, and I felt like I was a great match for what they were looking for.
 
  • #54
FlexGunship said:
I don't know... I was excited... thought it would be a great opportunity. I was really looking forward to trying something new, and I felt like I was a great match for what they were looking for.

Rightfully so. I figure that without that type of excitement, rarely will you be motivated enough to achieve success. I think you used your excitement as a tool to better your chances, and it's unfortunate that you weren't rewarded. If I were you I'd be bummed out, but I wouldn't regret a single thing.
 
  • #55
That sucks, Flex. Hang in there. You shouldn't have to accept a low-ball offer because of your age as long as you have relevant experience. Hope you can find a job that fits your skills.
 
  • #56
FlexGunship said:
I'm really surprised, actually. The only consolation is that they're not hiring anyone. It's not like someone else got the job and I didn't. I just don't know why they went through so much effort creating a new job title, calling me back for a second interview, calling all of my references, explaining their new prototypes, letting me play with their software package, and disclosing all of their liquidity, debt, and related issues...

What a waste of everyone's time.

Don't let it get you down. Might have been an internal hire, and they had to do the public posting and interviews to meet legal requirements, but when they stumbled across you, you gave them a run for their money, so they gave you a fair shake with a second interview before hiring the internal. Or, it could also be the requirement died during the hiring process.

I'm sorry to hear of the lost days of leave - that stinks. Perhaps next interview you can work out some flex time to interview during the week but make it up on the weekend.

I'd tell yourself "I've got the credentials and am in the running - it was close, so I'll just have to do better next time." Work with your local job placement center. We have a very good one here in Colorado Springs, and I'm working with them. Just got a call about a position today, in fact.

Keep at it!
 
  • #57
Wow. Very unexpected. Not that the outcome is REALLY any different from them hiring someone else instead, but it certainly makes everything SEEM like more of a waste.

It might be difficult not to have a sour taste left in your mouth, but you never know what could happen down the road. I was pretty put off by my former company and the poor HR decisions around my going back to school. I wasn't sure if I'd go back, but I committed to what I was doing, gave them a chance and just accepted an offer last week.

Maybe your hard work during these interviews and sacrifice of vacation will pay off down the road and they'll contact you later (not much of a consolation, I know).
 
  • #58
Grr, wish I could make them eat bugs.
 
  • #59
FlexGunship said:
Grr, wish I could make them eat bugs.
Flex,

I believe everything happens for a reason. I bet that the company you were applying at was large one, I work for one so I know how they operate. The HR Dept and Engineering Depts have multiple layers, and processes in place that are slow due to the sheer number of people and steps involved. Breakdowns in communication happen often. I have seen it time and again with offers to prospective employee's. I bet when the last quarter's numbers were tallied, that things didn't look quite as rosy as when you interviewed.

Things will work out for you. You seem to have a good head on your shoulders and are doing everything possible to land a position with commensurate pay worthy of your skills. Hang in there, and try to blow off some steam with a good speed bag session, bike ride, etc... you will feel better once you do.

Rhody... :wink:
 
  • #60
rhody said:
Flex,

I believe everything happens for a reason. I bet that the company you were applying at was large one, I work for one so I know how they operate. The HR Dept and Engineering Depts have multiple layers, and processes in place that are slow due to the sheer number of people and steps involved. Breakdowns in communication happen often. I have seen it time and again with offers to prospective employee's. I bet when the last quarter's numbers were tallied, that things didn't look quite as rosy as when you interviewed.

Things will work out for you. You seem to have a good head on your shoulders and are doing everything possible to land a position with commensurate pay worthy of your skills. Hang in there, and try to blow off some steam with a good speed bag session, bike ride, etc... you will feel better once you do.

Rhody... :wink:

Less than 25 employees actually. I found out what happened from the recruiter. They were set to make me an offer when they had one last candidate. He turned out to be big into business development. They decided that he was what they really needed. Made him an offer, and he refused. As a result though, they decided to look for more candidates like him.
 

Similar threads

Engineering ChemE PhD w/ a Supply Chain Engineer job offer
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Engineering I’m having second thoughts about my job position. How can I proceed with it?
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
5K
Finding support to complete a UK charity registration application
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
521
Job Skills Possibilities of a Career in Physics/Engineering
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
4K
Physics How do I make myself a better job candidate?
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
I always see Mathematician listed as one of the best jobs.
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
Job Skills Leaving a 2nd Master's degree to accept an offer abroad
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
Job Skills Got my BS in Physics but I don't know what to apply for
  • · Replies 108 ·
4
Replies
108
Views
19K
Job Skills Should I go back to school? How do I progress from here?
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Other Searching for jobs in the USA, should I quit?
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
4K