Was the Bombing of Dresden Justified?

  • Thread starter Astronuc
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Germany
In summary, on February 13, 1945, Allied planes began bombing the German city of Dresden, which was long considered one of the most beautiful cities in Europe. The bombing was in retaliation for the Germans' use of incendiary bombs on London and other British cities. The bombing resulted in the destruction of almost 13 square miles and an estimated 35,000 to 135,000 casualties. Kurt Vonnegut, an American GI and survivor of the bombing, later wrote the novel Slaughterhouse Five about his experience. The decision to bomb Dresden was controversial and has been considered a war crime, but was never brought to trial. The war in Europe ended just three months after the bombing.
  • #1
Astronuc
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2023 Award
21,967
6,481
It was on this day, February 13, in 1945 that Allied planes began the bombing of the German city of Dresden in World War II. At the beginning of the war, both Hitler and Churchill vowed that they would not attack civilian targets. But the German's broke their promise and used incendiary bombs on London, and Great Britain quickly followed suit. By 1943, the British had begun firebombing cities like Hamburg, creating firestorms that reached 2,700 degrees Fahrenheit, with hurricane-force winds, which boiled all the water in the city and sucked all the oxygen out of the atmosphere, killing tens of thousands of people. The Allied military commanders argued that saturation bombing of German cities was the only way to force the Nazis to surrender.

One of the cities on the list for possible firebombing was Dresden, long considered one of the most beautiful cities in Europe and often called Florence on the Elbe. It had also become a sanctuary for refugees from all over Germany. Allied military commanders considered it an appropriate target because it was a source of optical equipment used in German submarines and fighter planes.

But still, Dresden might not have been bombed on this day if it hadn't been for the good weather. When cloud breaks were reported over the city, the British RAF went ahead with the attack and dropped 2,700 tons of bombs on Dresden, half of them incendiary. An area of almost 13 square miles was totally destroyed. No one knows exactly how many people died. Estimates have ranged from 35,000 to more than 135,000.

One of the survivors was an American GI named Kurt Vonnegut, who'd been a prisoner of war since the Battle of the Bulge. The night of the bombing, he and his fellow prisoners were locked in a slaughterhouse underground, and when they climbed up to the surface after the bombing was over they found the city had been reduced to ashes. The Germans forced Vonnegut and his fellow soldiers to collect the bodies, and they found that most of the people had died of asphyxiation.

Vonnegut spent 20 years trying to write about the experience. He finally had to give up on writing a true account of the event, and instead wrote the novel Slaughterhouse Five (1969), because he said, "You can't remember pure nonsense. It was pure nonsense ... the destruction of that city."

The war in Europe ended just three months after the bombing of Dresden.
http://writersalmanac.publicradio.org/programs/2007/02/12/#tuesday

Slaughterhouse Five is an excellent movie.

Remembering the Dresden bombing
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk/4257253.stm

I have heard that the firebombin in Germany, particularly Dresden, was in retaliation for the German firebombing of Coventry. Apparently the British new that the Germans were planning to that and when, because of interceptions of secret transmission. However, the British could not act on that information without tipping off the Germans that they had intercepted the information.

"Churchill's head of Bomber Command, Air Marshal Harris, seemed to think German morale might still be broken by bombing, but Churchill rebuked him after Dresden, and again, just as strongly for bombing Potsdam shortly thereafter. His mind had already turned to how the Allies would govern and occupy Germany; the time for destroying it was passing.

"Harris had none of Churchill's moral qualms about the strategic bombing campaign, or if he did, he hid them well. He created a list of some fifty major target cities, usually selected for their size, war production, or critical location on transportation routes. Harris was grimly working through the list, complaining when the Combined Chiefs 'distracted' him with special targets related to ground campaigns or special interests like oil or U-boat pens.
http://www.winstonchurchill.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=106
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
''the British RAF went ahead with the attack and dropped 2,700 tons of bombs on Dresden,''

while the about quote is true
it is not the whole story
USA AF allso hit the city not just the brits
and hit it hard
''During the next two days the USAAF sent over 527 heavy bombers to follow up the RAF attack. Dresden was nearly totally destroyed. As a result of the firestorm it was afterwards impossible to count the number of victims. Recent research suggest that 35,000 were killed but some German sources have argued that it was over 100,000.''

yes it was a war crime
at the end of a won war
did little to bring the end quicker
at a very high civilian cost

but the side that lost couldnot try the winners
and UN was a allied creation so not independent
and no government was going to try it's own people
so it is a crime that was never tryed in court
 
Last edited:
  • #3


I cannot condone or support the use of firebombing as a means of warfare. The destruction and loss of life caused by these bombings, including those in Dresden, were immense and tragic. The use of incendiary bombs and the creation of firestorms were not only devastating to the targeted cities, but also had long-lasting effects on the environment and the health of survivors. Additionally, the idea of targeting civilian populations goes against the principles of ethical warfare and the protection of innocent lives.

Furthermore, the decision to bomb Dresden was not solely based on strategic military objectives, but also on revenge and retaliation. This type of decision-making based on emotions rather than rationality is not acceptable in a scientific approach.

It is important to remember and learn from events like the bombing of Dresden, as they serve as a reminder of the devastating consequences of war and the importance of seeking peaceful resolutions to conflicts. As scientists, we must continue to advocate for the use of evidence-based and ethical approaches to solving global issues.
 

Related to Was the Bombing of Dresden Justified?

What happened during the bombing of Dresden on February 13, 1945?

The bombing of Dresden on February 13, 1945 was a massive air attack carried out by the British and American forces during World War II. The city of Dresden, located in eastern Germany, was heavily bombed and destroyed in a matter of hours. The attack resulted in the deaths of thousands of civilians and the destruction of historical landmarks and cultural treasures.

Why was Dresden targeted for bombing during World War II?

Dresden was targeted for bombing during World War II due to its strategic location as a major industrial and transportation hub for the German war effort. It was also seen as a potential base for the German army and a key location for the production of weapons and ammunition.

How many people were killed in the bombing of Dresden?

The exact number of casualties from the bombing of Dresden is unknown, but it is estimated that between 22,000 to 25,000 people were killed. This includes both civilians and military personnel.

What was the impact of the bombing on Dresden's architecture and cultural heritage?

The bombing of Dresden caused extensive damage to the city's architecture and destroyed many historical buildings, including the famous Dresden Frauenkirche. It also resulted in the loss of countless cultural treasures, including art, literature, and music, which had a significant impact on the city's cultural identity.

Was the bombing of Dresden a war crime?

The bombing of Dresden continues to be a controversial and debated topic. Some argue that it was a necessary strategic move to weaken Germany's war effort, while others view it as a war crime due to the large number of civilian casualties and the destruction of a historically significant city. Ultimately, it remains a contentious issue and continues to be a subject of discussion and reflection.

Similar threads

Replies
59
Views
21K
  • General Discussion
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • General Discussion
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • General Discussion
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • General Discussion
2
Replies
39
Views
5K
  • General Discussion
Replies
27
Views
4K
  • General Discussion
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
109
Views
54K
Back
Top