Weird unconventional geometry problem

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Jarfi
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Geometry Weird
1 reply · 1K views · last reply
Jarfi
Messages
384
Reaction score
12
You are given a cone with height/length "L" and radius R. This cones Length is parallel to the Z axis in an XYZ frame of reference while the radius is parallel to the XY-plane.

This cone is then revolved(spun) around the y-axis, graph the area "touched" by the cone on the YZ-plane.

I am mathematically illiterate so yeah this is not quite as legitly explained as i'd like but I tried.

Here are pictures of this thing:
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn sketch in a rectangle labelled PLANE, with z axis up and x axis right, showing a loop above the origin annotated graphing of the outskirts of the cone, and a z label at the lower left.
    20140921_214019.jpg
    28.7 KB · Views: 444
  • Hand-drawn sketch of a 3D coordinate frame with X, Z and j-plane labels, a cone with length L and radius r, and curved arrows showing rotation about the axis.
    20140921_213629.jpg
    26.2 KB · Views: 475
  • Hand-drawn 3D sketch of x, y and z axes with a shaded cone whose base radius is labelled R, lying along the z-axis, with curved arrows showing rotation about the y-axis.
    20140921_213810.jpg
    27.4 KB · Views: 523
  • Hand-drawn sketch of a rectangle labelled PLANE on axes labelled X and Z, with a dashed arc curving up across the middle, above a partly visible line diagram at the top.
    20140921_213644.jpg
    24.7 KB · Views: 530
  • Hand-drawn sketch of a rectangular plane labelled PLANE j with x and z axes crossing at its centre; a hatched heart-shaped region sits above the x axis, labelled area affected.
    20140921_213733.jpg
    26.5 KB · Views: 504
It should be a cylinder-like thing with a vertical-convex bit which would correspond to the vertical bit of the cylinder, minus two filled cones.

This is far from a rigorous treatment of the problem, but my reasoning goes something along the lines of this:

Orient everything so the cone is horizontal, and the axis it's being spun around is vertical. Consider the cylinder, centered at the origin, which spans the height of the cone (which is equal to the cone's diameter) and goes out far enough to be tangent to the cone's base. This cylinder slices into the cone, making a circle-y cross-section on the cylinder. For every point on the outer wall of the cylinder, some point on the circle-y cross-section will be at the same height as that point on the outer wall, so while the cone sweeps around, the circle-y cross section will hit that point, so every point on the outer wall of the cylinder will be touched by the cone. Using smaller, similar cylinders gives us a series of outer-cylinder-walls whose heights are linearly increasing with radius that get hit by the cone, which corresponds to a cylinder minus two cones.

Now the circumference of the cone's base is further from the origin than the cone's base's center, though, so the curved heel of the cone's circumference will sweep out a convex surface encasing the cylinder. I believe the surface will be a section of an ellipse, swept around the circumference of the cylinder.

I'm unfortunately a little too tired to do calculations right now, so I can't really give a more rigorous treatment than the hand-wavey vague terms I just did.