What are the right reasons to study engineering ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RufusDawes
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Engineering Study
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the motivations and considerations for studying engineering, exploring the necessary interests and skills, as well as alternative career paths if one were not to pursue engineering. The scope includes personal reflections, career advice, and the relationship between interests in physics and mathematics and engineering as a field.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that a strong interest in physics and mathematics is essential for studying engineering.
  • Others argue that practical, hands-on experience and a desire to understand how machines and systems function are equally important.
  • A few participants express that personal satisfaction and enjoyment in engineering work are crucial motivations.
  • Some contributors mention alternative career paths they might have pursued if they were not engineers, including medicine, teaching, architecture, and urban planning.
  • There are differing views on whether a demonstrated interest in practical work or academic performance in relevant subjects is more indicative of a suitable candidate for engineering.
  • Concerns are raised about pursuing engineering for financial gain or status rather than genuine interest.
  • Some participants reflect on their personal experiences and how they came to their decisions regarding engineering or alternative fields.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the importance of interest in physics and mathematics for engineering, but there is no consensus on whether practical experience or academic qualifications are more critical. The discussion includes multiple competing views on motivations for studying engineering and alternative career paths.

Contextual Notes

Some participants express uncertainty about the motivations for studying engineering and the implications of pursuing it for the wrong reasons. There are also varying opinions on the importance of practical experience versus theoretical knowledge.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals considering a career in engineering, students exploring their interests in STEM fields, and those seeking advice on educational paths related to engineering may find this discussion relevant.

RufusDawes
Messages
154
Reaction score
0
What are the right reasons to study engineering ?

Does an interest in physics and mathematics cut it ?

How do you picture your life if you weren't an engineer.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If you like building and analyzing machines, you'd like being an engineer. An interest in physics and mathematics is essential.

- Warren
 
I guess that about sums it up
 
I think you certainly need to be strong in math and physics. However, you ultimately have to have a very strong desire to determine how machines, systems, electronic devices, and etc. function.

You should also be somewhat practical and 'hands-on'. As an engineer it isn't quite enough to be able to draw and understand the physics involved you also have to be able to determine how things fit together and help solve practical problems that come along when it is time to actually build something.

If I were not an engineer I would have probably pursued medicine.
 
h2oski1326 said:
I think you certainly need to be strong in math and physics. However, you ultimately have to have a very strong desire to determine how machines, systems, electronic devices, and etc. function.

You should also be somewhat practical and 'hands-on'. As an engineer it isn't quite enough to be able to draw and understand the physics involved you also have to be able to determine how things fit together and help solve practical problems that come along when it is time to actually build something.

If I were not an engineer I would have probably pursued medicine.

Aren't are you happy with engineering? It's an amazing field. Why pursue medicine?
 
RufusDawes said:
What are the right reasons to study engineering ?
Because is fun, and one does useful work.

Does an interest in physics and mathematics cut it ?
Certainly

How do you picture your life if you weren't an engineer.
I'd probably be an applied physicist. Actually, I've been an engineer for so long, I can't imagine being anything else - except possibly being a farmer or a mountain man.
 
thinkies said:
Aren't are you happy with engineering? It's an amazing field. Why pursue medicine?

You misinterpret; I meant that as, if I had to choose something else to study, I would choose medicine. I am very happy as an engineer, I find it suits my interests quite well and is challenging enough that I am hardly ever bored.
 
h2oski1326 said:
I think you certainly need to be strong in math and physics. However, you ultimately have to have a very strong desire to determine how machines, systems, electronic devices, and etc. function.

You should also be somewhat practical and 'hands-on'. As an engineer it isn't quite enough to be able to draw and understand the physics involved you also have to be able to determine how things fit together and help solve practical problems that come along when it is time to actually build something.

If I were not an engineer I would have probably pursued medicine.

So would you say that any would be electrical/electronics engineer would be the type of person who has taken the initiative thoughout their life to develop a good practical hands on understanding of the devices ?

Or is the demonstrated interest in physics and mathematics such as taking the high level classes in school enough ?
 
RufusDawes said:
So would you say that any would be electrical/electronics engineer would be the type of person who has taken the initiative thoughout their life to develop a good practical hands on understanding of the devices ?

Or is the demonstrated interest in physics and mathematics such as taking the high level classes in school enough ?

I would say that either could end up being an electrical engineer. Everyone is different, and everyone has different circumstances in their youth. Just because someone doesn't take a bunch of things apart as a child doesn't mean anything I was merely commenting on things that are seen in engineers.

Any desire to be an engineer is great and I would encourage you to pursue it, if that is what you want.

I would avoid pursuing the career if motivation is money or some kind of status, but other than that I say go for it. Also, do not let any decision be swayed heavily by some person on a message board. Talk with a guidance counselor, a family friend, or someone about the decision.
 
  • #10
h2oski1326 said:
I would say that either could end up being an electrical engineer. Everyone is different, and everyone has different circumstances in their youth. Just because someone doesn't take a bunch of things apart as a child doesn't mean anything I was merely commenting on things that are seen in engineers.

Any desire to be an engineer is great and I would encourage you to pursue it, if that is what you want.

I would avoid pursuing the career if motivation is money or some kind of status, but other than that I say go for it. Also, do not let any decision be swayed heavily by some person on a message board. Talk with a guidance counselor, a family friend, or someone about the decision.

I wish I had studied it when I was younger. I'm interested in electricity and at the end of high school I developed an ignorant fascination with the power of calculus that I did not chose to explore.

That and I got a little exposure to what ECE will involve through friends who have studied it.

Everyone I have spoken to has told me not to study engineering but I don't fully trust their judgement.
 
  • #11
If you like science in a practical rather than theoretical way. If you're a big fan of physics I don't think you'd be too happy as a civil or mechanical engineering. There are a lot of design aspects such as material selection and cost analysis, which may bore some people.
 
  • #12
some ppl could be very jelous of you and steer you away from studying engineering.

if I didn't study engineering probably I would be a math/physics teacher or physician,

my father told me; if you don't study I'll be working in European bakery selling fresh bred and yogurt every morning:-) , although I love those euro buns and tasty east euro yogurt
 
  • #13
Study engineering if you're interested in practical things and/or how things work.

if i didnt go into engineering... hmm... I'm probably one of the very few people here who would've gone into a non-technical/science field. architecture or urban planning would've been my major since I've always had a fascination with buildings, structures, and cities.
 
  • #14
Go to engineering if you find theory too hard.
 
  • #15
To do engineering, you have to like making stuff. It doesn't matter so much what particular kind of stuff it is; but as an engineer, you will spend your professional life designing, testing, and/or fabricating things of one variety or another. I think, to truly enjoy it, you have to be the kind of person who likes "doing" more than "thinking". You have to be a hands-on kind of person, a tinkerer. This is not to say that engineers don't do plenty of thinking; but to truly enjoy it, you have to be the kind of person who is turned on by the actual building and completing of projects.

And if you are that kind of person, and good at it, you will make boatloads of money.

If you prefer the more theoretical side of things, considering doing physics.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 69 ·
3
Replies
69
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 52 ·
2
Replies
52
Views
9K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 102 ·
4
Replies
102
Views
8K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K