What is the minimum time for light to travel through two mediums?

  • Thread starter Annes
  • Start date
1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Annes
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
i simply can't figure out how to make the equations work, so i copied everything into pictures.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a light ray from A to B refracting at point C on the boundary line FG, with labels D, E, F, G, p, q, x, m-x, angles i and b, and speeds v1 above and v2 below. Caption in Danish.
    brydning.png
    9.7 KB · Views: 452
  • Handwritten-style typed working showing limit expressions: lim as x approaches 0 of x/(v1 sqrt(x^2+p^2)) minus (m-x)/(v2 sqrt((m-x)^2+q^2)), times -m/sqrt(m^2+q^2) v2; and lim as x approaches infinity of the same bracket, times 1/v1 + 1/v2.
    2.jpg
    29.3 KB · Views: 397
  • Typed derivation: t(x) = sqrt(x^2 + p^2)/v1 + sqrt((m-x)^2 + q^2)/v2, followed by dt/dx = x/(v1 sqrt(x^2 + p^2)) - (m-x)/(v2 sqrt((m-x)^2 + q^2)).
    1.jpg
    21.3 KB · Views: 420
Last edited:
dt/dx=0 will give local stationary points (minima or maxima). In the general case, there may be several points which satisfy dt/dx=0. So to actually prove that a point is the lowest possible t value, you would need to draw a graph and/or use good reasoning.

I don't understand why you were taking the limit of dt/dx as x goes to zero. This would give the case where the light goes the shortest distance through the first medium. And taking the limit as x goes to infinity makes no physical sense, because we would expect x<m.

In this problem, most teachers expect that you just try to solve dt/dx, rather than go into detail about why this minimises t. I don't know what your teacher is looking for, but I would guess he just wants you to solve dt/dx and provide a reasonable explanation to why it minimises t.