Classical What Lagrangian mechanics textbook should I use?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on finding suitable textbooks for a second-year physics student studying Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics. The student appreciates the clarity of Landau and Lifshitz's volume 1 but finds it lacking in problem sets. They express dissatisfaction with Goldstein's approach, citing its complexity, particularly in the derivation of the Euler-Lagrange equations. Recommendations include Marion & Thornton, which is noted for its accessibility, and Schaum's Outline Series for its problem sets, though it's considered a supplemental resource. John Taylor's "Classical Mechanics" is suggested for its detailed explanations, though opinions vary on its verbosity. Additionally, Donald T. Greenwood's "Classical Dynamics" is mentioned as a potential resource. Overall, the focus is on finding a textbook that balances clear explanations with a substantial number of problems.
jqmhelios
Messages
12
Reaction score
7
I am currently taking a course on introductory Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics in year 2 in the UK.
I find the material easy but do not have access to a resource with a satisfying amount of problems.
Despite being (in)directly told this resource is not useful at my level, I have Landau and Lifshitz volume 1 and love it as the explanations are brilliantly clear and understandable to me. However, it contains a disappointingly small amount of problems!

Does anyone know a suitable textbook? For a year 2 physics student with lots of problems and worked examples?

I also should add that I do not like Goldstein's approach to the topic as I find his explanations too difficult for me at this stage. His derivation of the Euler-Lagrange equations was shockingly difficult to follow (unlike Landau's intuitive and easy approach)
 
  • Like
Likes DeBangis21, dextercioby and PhDeezNutz
Physics news on Phys.org
In my day, there was Marion or Symon.
 
My introduction to the topic was also Marion & Thornton
 
Schaum’s Outline Series offers down-to-the-point fully answered problems; beware, though, it’s supplemental text only.
 
  • Like
Likes George Jones and PhDeezNutz
As @apostolosdt has said, Schaum's Outline are valuable supplements of problems for standard text.

A text that provides detailed pedagogical explanations of concepts is Classical Mechanics by John Taylor. Some folks liked the detailed explanations; some folks find this text a little too wordy.
 
  • Like
Likes weirdoguy and dextercioby
If he likes Landau, Taylor is definitely way too wordy.

Landau's One can show" is missing some words. Like "with half a ream of paper and a free afternoon".
 
Landau & Lifshitz vol. 1!
 
  • Like
Likes apostolosdt
You can take a look at the first 3 chapters of Classical Dymamics by Donald. T. Greenwoord
 
I liked a combination of Taylor and Simon.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top