Discussion Overview
The discussion centers around the content and structure of a first course in elementary number theory for second-year undergraduate students. Participants explore various topics, resources, and applications that could motivate students in this subject area.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- One participant seeks suggestions for topics and the best order of presentation for a course in elementary number theory, emphasizing the need for motivating applications.
- Another participant recommends the book "An Introduction to Number Theory" by Graham Everest and Thomas Ward as a useful resource.
- A different participant highlights chapter 4 "Rational Approximations" from "Roots to Research: A Vertical Development of Mathematical Problems" by J.D. Sally and P.J. Sally, Jr. as a valuable topic, noting its accessibility to students of all levels.
- Discussion includes the topic of squaring the circle and the transcendental nature of $\pi$, with one participant suggesting that while this is interesting, it may be more geometrical than number-theoretical.
- Public-key cryptography is mentioned as a potential application of number theory, but concerns are raised about its complexity and whether it can be made accessible in an elementary course.
- Modular arithmetic is emphasized as a crucial tool that should be included in any elementary number theory course.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing opinions on the inclusion of public-key cryptography in the course, with some believing it requires a separate course due to its complexity. There is also no consensus on the best order of topics or the most effective resources.
Contextual Notes
Participants note the importance of providing accessible and engaging content while also considering the mathematical rigor required for the course. There are unresolved questions regarding the balance between depth and accessibility in the chosen topics.