I What travels faster: visible light in water or X-rays in liquid mercury?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on comparing the speed of visible light in distilled water with that of X-rays in liquid mercury. It notes that the speed of visible light in water is approximately 225,000,000 meters per second, while calculations suggest X-rays in mercury could travel faster at about 248,069,886 meters per second based on available refractive index data. However, there is uncertainty regarding the refractive index for X-ray wavelengths shorter than 60 nanometers. The conversation also touches on the practical implications of this comparison, mentioning the use of mirrors in X-ray telescopes for focusing rather than lenses. Overall, the inquiry highlights the complexities of electromagnetic wave propagation in different media.
Dante Meira
Messages
22
Reaction score
5
TL;DR Summary
In which medium electromagnetic waves travel faster, distilled water or liquid mercury?
I could find some approximations in a Google search about the speed of visible light in distilled water, but couldn't find much about the speed of X-rays in liquid mercury.

In which medium electromagnetic waves travel faster, distilled water or liquid mercury? Does the wavelength of the electromagnetic waves influence the speed in each medium?

What travels faster, visible light in distilled water or X-rays in liquid mercury?
 
Science news on Phys.org
Gordianus said:

Thank you. I checked the data there for Hg (mercury) but I didn't know how to use the data to calculate the speed of propagation of X-rays.

But I did find this other website:

https://refractiveindex.info/?shelf=main&book=Hg&page=Inagaki

There I could check the refractive index of Hg for wavelengths between 0.06358 and 6 micrometers. The minimum wavelength in that data set, 0.06 micrometers (60 nanometers), is way above that of soft X-rays. Any way, the refractive index of Hg for that wavelength is 1.2085, then I calculated the speed of propagation of electromagnetic radiation of that wavelength in mercury as 299,792,458 divided by 1.2085 = 248,069,886 meters per second. That's faster than the average 225,000,000 meters per second of visible light in water.

Unfortunately, I couldn't find the refractive index of mercury for wavelengths shorter than 60 nanometers.
 
Dante Meira said:
TL;DR Summary: In which medium electromagnetic waves travel faster, distilled water or liquid mercury?

What travels faster, visible light in distilled water or X-rays in liquid mercury?
Is there any practical context for this question or is it just a Top Trumps type question?
 
If the OP is wondering about possible designs for focussing X rays, there are X Ray telescopes which use mirrors, rather than lenses. Quite smart, I thought; some lateral thinking involved.
 
The OP hasn't been seen in days, so it is difficult to gauge his level of interest. I'm just glad I didn't write a long, involved answer, only then to find that he had wandered off.
 
Back
Top