What will be the velocity of flow ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BrnoStudent
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Flow Velocity
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the velocity of water flow in a tube with varying radii, specifically comparing a section with a radius of 1 cm to one with a radius of 3 cm. Participants debate the correct answer to the question, with some asserting that the velocity should be one-ninth of the original value rather than the suggested answer of six times greater. The importance of understanding volumetric flow rate and the underlying physics principles is emphasized, as simply providing answers without explanation is deemed unhelpful for learning. Additionally, there's a call for more tactful communication in academic inquiries. The conversation highlights the need for clarity and accuracy in physics-related exam questions.
BrnoStudent
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Water flows through a rigid tube, the radius of which is 1 cm. What will be the velocity
of flow in a part of the tube with a radius of 3 cm?

Please show your working and any equations that you use, no matter how basic you think it is. If there is no working to show then just explain how you arrived at your answer. I know the answer is e, I just don't know why. Thank you.
a) 3 m.s-1
b) one third of the original value
c) one sixth of the original value
d) three-times bigger than the original value
e) six-times bigger than the original value
 
Physics news on Phys.org
This is another question that should be posted in the Homework and Coursework Questions thread. If you want an answer then you need to show you have attempted to answer by posting your own ideas.
 
sophiecentaur said:
This is another question that should be posted in the Homework and Coursework Questions thread. If you want an answer then you need to show you have attempted to answer by posting your own ideas.

If I knew what to do, I would not be asking for help in the first place. This is a biophysics question from med school and it's an exam question, not a homework question. I'm practicing for my exams.
 
BrnoStudent said:
If I knew what to do, I would not be asking for help in the first place. This is a biophysics question from med school and it's an exam question, not a homework question. I'm practicing for my exams.

It's up to you. Have you looked at any information about the topic or did you come straight here?
I googled 'liquid flow velocity' and that threw up 'Volumetric Flow rate' - which gave me what you want. If you want to be a medic, then that should be the sort of thing you'd expect to do - ain't it?
Just giving you the answer would not do anything for your ability to answer a similar question, would it? You say you want to pass an exam. :wink:
 
sophiecentaur said:
It's up to you. Have you looked at any information about the topic or did you come straight here?
I googled 'liquid flow velocity' and that threw up 'Volumetric Flow rate' - which gave me what you want. If you want to be a medic, then that should be the sort of thing you'd expect to do - ain't it?
Just giving you the answer would not do anything for your ability to answer a similar question, would it? You say you want to pass an exam. :wink:
I don't "want" to be a medic, I already am. I've been scanning through a 400page biophysics textbook, I also have 4 other exams this week, if there's anything that I can do to make my life easier at this point I will. Once again, thank you for your reply. I will ask the question in another section.
 
BrnoStudent said:
I don't "want" to be a medic, I already am. I've been scanning through a 400page biophysics textbook, I also have 4 other exams this week, if there's anything that I can do to make my life easier at this point I will. Once again, thank you for your reply. I will ask the question in another section.

I could suggest a bit more tactful way of wording your original post, then. i.e. "Do us a favour chaps, I have this looming exam . . . ."?
 
The way question is stated, the correct answer is 1/9th. I can think of several different ways to mis-interpret the question, giving me results up to factor of 81, but answer e) isn't even on the radar. Where'd you get this from?
 
K^2 said:
The way question is stated, the correct answer is 1/9th. I can think of several different ways to mis-interpret the question, giving me results up to factor of 81, but answer e) isn't even on the radar. Where'd you get this from?

They are practice exam questions from my uni and it says the answer is e on the paper.
 
Well, it's wrong. I agree with K2 - the correct answer is 1/9.
 
  • #10
cjl said:
Well, it's wrong. I agree with K2 - the correct answer is 1/9.
If the OP googles Volumetric Flow, the main hits give the formula and the reasoning behind it. The 'letter' given in the answer to multichoice questions is useless for learning. The theory is what counts.
 
  • #11
sophiecentaur said:
If the OP googles Volumetric Flow, the main hits give the formula and the reasoning behind it. The 'letter' given in the answer to multichoice questions is useless for learning. The theory is what counts.

True. In this case, I would argue that the letter is actually worse than useless - it is detrimental (since it indicates an incorrect answer, unless there is some background or additional information with the problem that we have not been given).
 
  • #12
This thread has been moved from the General Physics forum where it was originally mis-posted. Because some help had already given, I chose to move it and not delete it, which explains why the first post does not follow the template.
 
Back
Top