What would happen in Carnot cycle if heat engine is less efficient?

2 replies · 966 views · last reply
PLAGUE
Messages
46
Reaction score
2
TL;DR
What would happen in Carnot cycle if heat engine is less efficient than the refrigerator?
Diagram of a cycle linking two heat reservoirs: an Engine X takes +Q_H from the reservoir at T_H and rejects -Q_L to the reservoir at T_L, with work +W driving a Refrigerator X' that returns -Q'_H to the hot reservoir and takes +Q'_L from the cold one.


In this cycle, if $$X$$ has efficiency greater than $$X^{'}$$, then we can show that, heat flows from cold reservoir to the hot reservoir. But this contradicts our everyday observation and we conclude that $$X$$ can not have greater efficiency than $$X^{'}$$.

But what if efficiency of $$X$$ is less than efficiency of $$X^{'}$$? Then, we can show that, $$Q_{H} > Q_{H}^{'}$$ and $$Q_{L} > Q_{L}^{'}$$, which means heat flows from hot to cold reservoir which doesn't contradict any observations. But doesn't it violate Carnot theorem that efficiency of both engine and refrigerator be same?
 
PLAGUE said:
What would happen in Carnot cycle if heat engine is less efficient than the refrigerator?

Efficiency of a refrigerator is not relevant in a Carnot cycle. Engineers instead use coefficient of performance.