Where Did I Go Wrong in Partial Fraction Integration?

Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the integration of the function ∫(2e^x)/(e^(2x)-1)dx using partial fraction decomposition. The user incorrectly set up the partial fractions as A/e^x+1 + B/e^x-1 = 2e^x, leading to erroneous values for A and B. The correct setup should have included proper parentheses, resulting in A/(e^x + 1) + B/(e^x - 1) = 2e^x/(e^(2x) - 1). The final answers differ due to the user’s misunderstanding of logarithmic properties and the need for proper restrictions on x to avoid computing logs of negative numbers.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of partial fraction decomposition
  • Familiarity with integration techniques, particularly involving exponential functions
  • Knowledge of logarithmic properties and their restrictions
  • Ability to manipulate algebraic expressions correctly, including the use of parentheses
NEXT STEPS
  • Review the method of partial fraction decomposition in the context of rational functions
  • Study integration techniques for exponential functions, focusing on substitution methods
  • Learn about the properties of logarithms and their domains
  • Practice algebraic manipulation to ensure clarity in mathematical expressions
USEFUL FOR

Students studying calculus, particularly those focusing on integration techniques, as well as educators looking for common pitfalls in teaching partial fraction decomposition and logarithmic properties.

Yosty22
Messages
182
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement



∫(2e^x)/(e^(2x)-1)dx

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



I was told to solve using partial fractions. When I set up the partial fraction I got:

A/e^x+1 + B/e^x-1 = 2e^x

When I broke it up, I solved for A and B and got that A and B should both equal 1/2. When I plugged it back into the integral, I pulled out the 2 in the numerator, substituted A and B in (so the 2 and the 1/2s all cancel) and integrated 1/e^2x+1 dx and 1/e^2x-1 dx

After I integrated, I got ln(e^x+1) + ln(e^x-1) + C

However, when I looked up the answer online to check my answer, they had something a little different. The answer (on Wolfram Alpha) was nearly the same, but instead was: ln(1-e^x)-ln(e^x+1) +C

I was wondering where I could have gone wrong?

Just to be clear, when I set up the partial fractions, I did the following:

A/e^x+1 + B/e^x-1 =2e^x/(e^x+1)(e^x-1).
=A(e^x-1)+B(e^x+1)
=Ae^x-A+Be^x+B
=(A+B)e^x+(B-A)
I set this equal to the numerator in the integral:
(A+B)e^x+(B-A)=e^2x ---- I pulled the two outside of the integral in the first step
This means:
A+B=1
B-A=0
A=B=0.5

Any idea where I went wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Yosty22 said:

Homework Statement



∫(2e^x)/(e^(2x)-1)dx

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



I was told to solve using partial fractions. When I set up the partial fraction I got:

A/e^x+1 + B/e^x-1 = 2e^x
1. Use parentheses. What you wrote on the left side is this:
Ae-x + 1 + Be-x + 1

What you meant, I'm sure, was this:
A/(ex + 1) + B/(ex + 1)
2. Your equation really would be this:
A/(ex + 1) + B/(ex + 1) = 2ex/(e2x - 1)
Yosty22 said:
When I broke it up, I solved for A and B and got that A and B should both equal 1/2. When I plugged it back into the integral, I pulled out the 2 in the numerator, substituted A and B in (so the 2 and the 1/2s all cancel) and integrated 1/e^2x+1 dx and 1/e^2x-1 dx

After I integrated, I got ln(e^x+1) + ln(e^x-1) + C
I suspect that where you went wrong was thinking this:

$$\int \frac{dx}{e^x + 1} = ln(e^x + 1) + C$$
That is NOT correct![/color]
Furthermore, I think your approach is a dead end. A simpler approach is to do a substitution first, and then use partial fractions on that.
Yosty22 said:
However, when I looked up the answer online to check my answer, they had something a little different. The answer (on Wolfram Alpha) was nearly the same, but instead was: ln(1-e^x)-ln(e^x+1) +C

I was wondering where I could have gone wrong?

Just to be clear, when I set up the partial fractions, I did the following:

A/e^x+1 + B/e^x-1 =2e^x/(e^x+1)(e^x-1).
=A(e^x-1)+B(e^x+1)
=Ae^x-A+Be^x+B
=(A+B)e^x+(B-A)
I set this equal to the numerator in the integral:
(A+B)e^x+(B-A)=e^2x ---- I pulled the two outside of the integral in the first step
This means:
A+B=1
B-A=0
A=B=0.5

Any idea where I went wrong?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
Yosty22 said:

Homework Statement



∫(2e^x)/(e^(2x)-1)dx

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



I was told to solve using partial fractions. When I set up the partial fraction I got:

A/e^x+1 + B/e^x-1 = 2e^x

When I broke it up, I solved for A and B and got that A and B should both equal 1/2. When I plugged it back into the integral, I pulled out the 2 in the numerator, substituted A and B in (so the 2 and the 1/2s all cancel) and integrated 1/e^2x+1 dx and 1/e^2x-1 dx

After I integrated, I got ln(e^x+1) + ln(e^x-1) + C

However, when I looked up the answer online to check my answer, they had something a little different. The answer (on Wolfram Alpha) was nearly the same, but instead was: ln(1-e^x)-ln(e^x+1) +C

I was wondering where I could have gone wrong?

Just to be clear, when I set up the partial fractions, I did the following:

A/e^x+1 + B/e^x-1 =2e^x/(e^x+1)(e^x-1).
=A(e^x-1)+B(e^x+1)
=Ae^x-A+Be^x+B
=(A+B)e^x+(B-A)
I set this equal to the numerator in the integral:
(A+B)e^x+(B-A)=e^2x ---- I pulled the two outside of the integral in the first step
This means:
A+B=1
B-A=0
A=B=0.5

Any idea where I went wrong?

You wrote several incorrect formulas. Never, never write A/e^x+1 (which equals 1 + (A/e^x)) if you mean A/(e^x+1). Always use parentheses, or else use TeX, like this:
\frac{A}{e^x+1}

Anyway, your answer makes sense only if x > 0 (so that e^x > 1) and the on-line answer makes sense only if x < 0 (so that e^x < 1); those restrictions are needed to avoid computing logs of negative numbers. You need to write things differently if you want a formula that works for all x, whether positive or negative.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K