Which Circuit Breaker Switch to Turn?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around troubleshooting a home water heater that may have tripped its circuit breaker. Participants explore which circuit breaker to reset and the implications of doing so, including safety concerns and the condition of the water heater. The conversation includes technical details about circuit breakers and personal experiences related to the issue.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • One participant asks which circuit breaker to reset for the water heater, listing three options.
  • Another participant suggests unplugging the device before resetting the breaker.
  • A participant clarifies whether the goal is to safely work on the water heater or to reset a tripped breaker, explaining how to identify a tripped breaker.
  • Concerns are raised about whether the water heater is functioning properly and if it might trip the breaker again.
  • A participant recounts an encounter with an electrical company worker who suggested checking the circuit breaker, expressing confusion and frustration about the situation.
  • Details are provided about the condition of the circuit breaker switch, including its loose feel and difficulty in operation.
  • One participant warns that if the breaker trips again immediately after resetting, there may be a serious issue, recommending hiring a licensed electrician for safety.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying levels of concern about the water heater's condition and the safety of resetting the breaker. There is no consensus on the best course of action, and multiple views on the situation remain unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention the potential for further issues if the breaker trips again, as well as the challenges of operating the circuit breaker switch due to its condition. There is uncertainty regarding the proper procedure for resetting the breaker and whether additional work may be needed.

Who May Find This Useful

Homeowners dealing with electrical issues, individuals seeking troubleshooting advice for circuit breakers, and those interested in electrical safety practices.

kyphysics
Messages
686
Reaction score
446
My home water heater is messed up.

If I want to reset the circuit breaker for it, which should I turn? There are three:

1.) garage (where the heater is located)
2.) water heater/dryer
3.) heat pump
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Flipped breaker should let itself be known !?
Anyway, first unplug the suspected device before resetting a breaker.
 
kyphysics said:
My home water heater is messed up.

If I want to reset the circuit breaker for it, which should I turn? There are three:

1.) garage (where the heater is located)
2.) water heater/dryer
3.) heat pump
Do you mean that you want to turn off the appropriate circuit breaker to be able to safely work on the water heater (is it hard wired to power with no outlet?)? Or the water heater tripped the circuit breaker and you need to reset it?

When a circuit breaker trips, it goes to a soft slightly middle position that is not always obvious visually. If you push each breaker in turn towards the ON position, the non-tripped ones will feel solid, but the tripped one will be slightly springy. That is the one you would cycle OFF and then ON to turn it back ON.
 
yes to reset
 
Do you think the water heater is okay now, or might the breaker trip again? Can you unhook the water heater from AC Mains before you reset the breaker?
 
berkeman said:
Do you think the water heater is okay now, or might the breaker trip again? Can you unhook the water heater from AC Mains before you reset the breaker?
I'm not sure if it's okay right now. We had some power/electrical company person come by today to supposedly remove some sort of outdated water meter device. We got a letter from the company they would do this a long time ago.

However, when they showed up, there was no call ahead of time. I was part naked and taking an afternoon nap. I went to answer the door in groggy state and some dude I did not recognize asked me to check if my water heater circuit breaker was tripped. I was thinking "HUH?"

:smile::smile::smile:
He didn't introduce himself, tell me what he was doing, etc. I asked him what he was doing/talking about I think and he alluded to doing the thing the city's electrical company said they would be doing. I said I didn't know how to check that (although, I did...just hadn't done it in a long time). He said to look for a label and see if the circuit breaker was tripped. I said I wasn't sure (I honestly just wanted to go back to sleep, I think...I was barely conscious of what was going on). He said he'd do it for me. I aggressively told him not to do that. I didn't want him coming into the garage.

I have COVID-19 fear, due to the death of my uncle. I didn't want him coming into the garage without me prepping the area, as it's very cluttered. Didn't want to explain that and just said I'd check myself.

He seemed annoyed and left. I checked and it LOOKED like nothing was tripped.

Then, I showered several hours later and ran out of hot water much faster than normal. I thought: "Oh, no!...that dude probably did something earlier that tripped the circuit."

I went to garage again and saw that MAYBE the water heater circuit was tripped. I did have the "middle position" look, but NOT all the way to the off position. Then after reading online that's EXAXCTLY how it DOES look when tripped, I was like, DARN!

I have tried resetting it. But, we don't have hot water yet. It's also:

a.) very loose and not a tight switch and EVERY OTHER switch on the circuit breaker area. For some reason THAT switch is kind of loose (always has been) and kind of hard to push/pull hard.

b.) attached to THREE OTHER switches.. You cannot move JUST that switch. It's in a quad. You have to move all four at once. However, the loose one gets flipped too quick. It's hard to get right. I was told you have to flip them simultaneously and hard. But, that switch is loose and difficult to pull/push hard and even more so as part of a quad.

THUS, I'm not sure what's up. THe electrical dude never said what to do if the circuit breaker was tripped. He didnt' say just reset it and your water heater will be back on. I wonder if it would have required OTHER WORK? He never said and just left after I said I'd check myself. Maybe I'm not coordinated enough with my fingers to properly reset it. Sometimes you have to do these just right for the reset to work.

Lastly, no have no idea what an AC Main is. :smile::smile:
 
If your circuit breaker is in the "in between" position, that means it has tripped. If you tried to reset it and it tripped again right away, then something is seriously wrong on that circuit. You don't want to burn down your house and your family, so I strongly suggest that you hire a licensed electrician.In any case, getting tips from the Internet is a bad idea. Get local professional help.

Thread closed.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: NTL2009, berkeman and BvU

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
29
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
4K
Replies
11
Views
9K
Replies
7
Views
8K
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
961
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K