Which equation is wrong for a mass on a spring

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
Arup Biswas
Messages
34
Reaction score
2
Please tell me which one is wrong! When I put a mass M on one end of a spring!
Handwritten sketch of a spring with a mass M hanging from its lower end, showing extension x below the natural length a, with a mark for a stretch labelled x. Right side gives two methods: equating forces Mg = Kx so x = Mg/K, and energy conversion Mgx = (1/2)Kx^2 so x = 2Mg/K, with the question 'which is true?' written below.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten sketch of a spring with a mass M hanging from its lower end, showing extension x below the natural length a, with a mark for a stretch labelled x. Right side gives two methods: equating forces Mg = Kx so x = Mg/K, and energy conversion Mgx = (1/2)Kx^2 so x = 2Mg/K, with the question 'which is true?' written below.
    IMG_20180113_002527.jpg
    41.9 KB · Views: 735
You need to state the problem. Are you dropping the mass and trying to find out how far it sinks down (before coming back up). Or are you gently placing the mass at its new equilibrium point? Two different problems!
 
Realize that the force equation solution just finds the equilibrium point, which is not the lowest point. To solve for the lowest point, you'll use energy conservation.
 
Last edited: