Which Schools Are Best for Pursuing a Physics Degree and Grad School Prep?

  • Context: Schools 
  • Thread starter Thread starter member 178484
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    School Undergrad
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around selecting suitable schools for pursuing a physics degree and preparing for graduate school, with a focus on the quality of education, research opportunities, and the impact of undergraduate institution choice on graduate school admissions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant shares their academic background and expresses interest in schools like Vanderbilt, USC, and William & Mary for physics.
  • Another participant suggests the University of Texas as a less competitive but good option for physics.
  • Additional recommendations include the University of Michigan, SUNY Stony Brook, and Carnegie Mellon, with a note on the competitiveness of Canadian schools like the University of Toronto and McGill.
  • Concerns are raised about whether the initially listed schools provide a good physics education and if attending a non-top-tier school would hinder graduate school opportunities.
  • It is noted that while attending a top-tier school can help with grad school admissions, it is not the only factor; undergraduate research opportunities are also important.
  • Participants discuss the standard nature of undergraduate physics curricula and emphasize the importance of completing the program and maintaining a positive experience in physics.
  • Questions arise about the benefits of attending smaller private schools versus larger public schools in terms of attention and research opportunities.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that the quality of the undergraduate experience and research opportunities are important, but there is no consensus on the best type of school (small private vs. large public) or the necessity of attending a top-tier institution for graduate school success.

Contextual Notes

Participants express uncertainty about the impact of school choice on graduate school admissions and the importance of personal fit in learning environments.

member 178484
hi, I'm currently a junior in a very competitive public hs in MA. i want to pursue a degree in physics and eventually a PhD in physics or astronautical engineering (MIT hopefully!) i wasn't a stellar student in HS mostly because i didn't care my freshman year and i had some personal issues this year. but anyways, these are my stats so far-

4.0 weighted (out of 5.0)
3.3 uw
2100 SAT
taking subject tests in Math2 and Chem in may
29 ACT, 30 eng, 31 math
only 2 non-honors classes in HS, one ap this year and 3 senior year

my ec's aren't great but they have depth:
i've played basketball year round on different teams for all of HS, didn't make varsity but played aau (similar to club teams for soccer) in both the spring and fall for all of HS, making up about 12-ish seasons of basketball
and I've worked 15-20hrs a week on average since Aug 2009, sometimes more
member of a couple clubs but nothing big
and sadly that's it for the most part

right now, my top choices are probably Vanderbilt, USC, and William & Mary, although i don't know for sure if those are worthy schools of shooting for for physics or not. Also on my list are Boston U, Elon, Richmond, Illinois U-C, VaTech, McGill, and my guidance counselor said i have a great shot at Washington & Lee although somehow i don't believe that

So if anyone has any other schools i should shoot for for a degree in physics and a chance to make it into top grad schools, i would love to know!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Might try University of Texas. Much less competitive than, say, MIT, and it's a very good school. Not very expensive, either.
 
I would look at University of Michigan, SUNY Stony Brook (a public university, but very much racing to the forefront in physics and sciences in general), Carnegie Mellon (likely a stretch, but worth a shot). If you are willing to go to Canada you have a shot at University of Toronto and McGill, they are competitive, but you have a chance.
 
thanks for the quick replies, ill check those schools out. two additional questions though: will the schools i listed above give me a good physics education, or are they really not worth it? and will not going to a top-tier undergrad school for physics not allow me to get into a top-tier grad schools later?
 
All Of the schools I listed are very good schools for physics.

Being in a top tier school helps with grad school, but it's not the only factor. Make sure that the school you go to has undergrad research opportunities (u of m, cmu and stony brook all have this)
 
thanks, i'll try to look into more schools that will give me some research opportunities in addition to education. i checked out those schools, u of m did sound appealing to me but i wasnt sure if i had a shot at it. texas as well, and cmu. but there were a few schools i had looked at that i was wondering if it was worth looking into more or if i would be wasting my time getting a physics degree from the school.

UM-College Park
UI- Urbana Champaign
Boston University
University of Richmond
Elon University
Villanova University
Wake Forest University

also, how are UMCP, UIUC, and BU's aerospace engineering programs? that is my second choice major if physics doesn't work out like i hope
 
amill311 said:
So if anyone has any other schools i should shoot for for a degree in physics and a chance to make it into top grad schools, i would love to know!

The undergraduate physics curriculum is pretty standard, and the best physics program is one that you finish, so your first consideration is to find a school that doesn't leave you hating physics after two years. The other thing is that the difference between "top" and "middle" physics graduate schools isn't that huge, and as long as you finish the undergraduate program with decent grades, you'll make it in somewhere.

Also, you need to apply to one or two "shoot the moon" school since you might just get lucky, and at least one school that you absolutely positively know that you are going to get into.
 
twofish-quant said:
The undergraduate physics curriculum is pretty standard, and the best physics program is one that you finish, so your first consideration is to find a school that doesn't leave you hating physics after two years.

really? wow that honestly makes me feel quite a bit more relaxed about this. so it really won't matter that i didn't get into mit or ucb or stanford or one of their ilk come grad school time?
in that case, would it be a better idea to go to a smaller private school where ill get the increased attention and such or a large public school where i could get opportunities at research and internships and such?
 
amill311 said:
really? wow that honestly makes me feel quite a bit more relaxed about this. so it really won't matter that i didn't get into mit or ucb or stanford or one of their ilk come grad school time?

The first priority is to go somewhere that you will get the physics degree. It's better to get a physics undergraduate at Noname University then to burnout at MIT (which I've seen happen to people).

In that case, would it be a better idea to go to a smaller private school where ill get the increased attention and such or a large public school where i could get opportunities at research and internships and such?

That depends on the way that you learn best. One thing is that you should do is go to a graduate school that is different from undergraduate school.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 38 ·
2
Replies
38
Views
7K
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K