Why Do So Few Students Use Graph Paper for Math and Science?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Beanyboy
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the limited use of graph-paper notebooks in math and science education, contrasting practices in different countries. While some educators and students find graph paper essential for integrating numeric and graphic elements, others prefer blank sheets, citing distractions from lines. Cost is a significant factor, with graph paper being perceived as expensive compared to basic notebook paper. In some regions, like India, graph paper is commonly used in earlier education but declines in higher levels due to the availability of software that can generate graphs. Advanced science and engineering fields often rely on technology for graphing, reducing the need for manual graphing on paper. Engineering paper, which combines graphing capabilities with text space, is noted for its utility but is also considered costly. Overall, the preference for graph paper varies among individuals and educational contexts, with many opting for alternatives based on personal comfort and technological advancements.
Beanyboy
Messages
83
Reaction score
20
Can anyone explain the lack of widespread use of "graph-paper" notebooks/notepads" for Math and Science? (Incidentally, the French use them, for all subjects) As a Math/Science learner and teacher, I find the graph paper indispensable. So often you're trying to integrate the numeric and the graphic, so the graph paper is bloody handy. Cost might be a factor, but then, if everyone were using it, the price might come down.

For the life of me, I can't understand why schools don't insist on them from Elementary onwards.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I guess it depends on preference. For me, I use blank sheets of paper with no lines. Lines distract me and I tend to focus more on putting everything on the proper line and spaced out rather than working the problem. But I do think that graphing paper is too expensive. I have a few engineering student friends and I'm told they are required to use it which looks painful because a sheet of about 100 is $15.
 
Here is Louisiana, a spiral bound pad of 100 sheets of 4x4 quad ruled paper is less than $2. It's the "nothing fancy" basic stuff I'm referring to. If you're doing any work at all using the functions, graphs, it's really handy.
 
I never really felt the need for graph paper after high school. If you need something beyond a sketch, then some sort of plotting software seems like a better choice than making an "accurate" hand drawing on graph paper. Graph paper seems particularly suited to the standard algebra and geometry classes in high school.
 
I rarely did enough graphing by hand to justify buying and carrying around 100+ sheets of graphing paper. And the graphing I did do almost never required anything better than a vague sketch of the graph, which I can do on regular notebook paper just fine.
 
Beanyboy said:
Can anyone explain the lack of widespread use of "graph-paper" notebooks/notepads" for Math and Science? (Incidentally, the French use them, for all subjects) As a Math/Science learner and teacher, I find the graph paper indispensable. So often you're trying to integrate the numeric and the graphic, so the graph paper is bloody handy. Cost might be a factor, but then, if everyone were using it, the price might come down.

For the life of me, I can't understand why schools don't insist on them from Elementary onwards.
Here in India, graph papers are extensively used upto the tenth standard in school. After that, the use reduces, because mostly graphs can be done by hand on notebooks. But in practical examinations, they are still used a lot.

In advanced science, graph papers are mostly not used. This is due to the technology available. Softwares like MATLAB will plot a graph for you, draw the best fit line, and do whatever you like. That reduces manual calculations to a great extent.
 
Graph paper makes the writing harder to read, so it's not going to be used unless you need to make a graph.

"Engineering Paper" is specifically designed to let you have graph coordinate lines available if you need them for graphing, but because they are on the back side of the sheets, they don't interfere with reading text on the front side. Unfortunately pads of Engineering Paper are expensive, so they are typically only used by folks who do a lot of mixing of text and figures in their work or schoolwork... :smile:https://www.walmart.com/ip/TOPS-Eng...93696&wl11=online&wl12=21452190&wl13=&veh=sem
c40f5b79-15e0-4c5f-803f-2082003019fa_1.b3e6411c7edcd75863bc4ffbc8fc27d3.jpg
 

Attachments

  • c40f5b79-15e0-4c5f-803f-2082003019fa_1.b3e6411c7edcd75863bc4ffbc8fc27d3.jpg
    c40f5b79-15e0-4c5f-803f-2082003019fa_1.b3e6411c7edcd75863bc4ffbc8fc27d3.jpg
    20.1 KB · Views: 452
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes symbolipoint, Wrichik Basu, ChemAir and 1 other person
opus said:
I guess it depends on preference. For me, I use blank sheets of paper with no lines. Lines distract me and I tend to focus more on putting everything on the proper line and spaced out rather than working the problem.
Same with me.
 
  • Like
Likes opus

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
93
Views
16K
Replies
11
Views
4K
Replies
28
Views
11K
Replies
3
Views
557
Replies
5
Views
4K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Back
Top