Why does L'Hôpital's rule fail for lim(sin(x)−x)/x³?

  • Thread starter tornzaer
  • Start date
12 replies · 3K views · last reply
tornzaer
Messages
77
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



lim -> 0 (sin(x)-x) / x^3

Homework Equations



L'Hospital's Rule

The Attempt at a Solution



I could just use L'Hospital's rule since it's 0/0. However, the answer is wrong when I do it that way. What am I missing? It states on the question that it must be rewritten before the ruel can be applied and that it has to be applied more than once.

Please help.
 
will have a closer look, but one way to gain better understading about the problem would be to expand the sin in a taylor series about 0...
 
I don't see why you'd need to rewrite anything. You just have to argue that

lim x->0 f/g = lim x->0 f'/g' = lim x->0 f''/g'' = ... is true for the nth derivate as long as the limit of n-1th derivate is either zero or infinite for both f and g.
 
The first time applied gives me: (cosx - 1) / 3x^2

The second: (-sinx) / 6x

I definitely know this is wrong...
 
lanedance said:
will have a closer look, but one way to gain better understading about the problem would be to expand the sin in a taylor series about 0...

Pretty much what applying L'Hopital's rule does really.
 
tornzaer said:
Third would be -cosx/6
And the limit of that as x goes to 0 is ?
 
Try expanding sin(x) using the Maclaurin series.
You will get the answer directly.
 
Attachments
  • Typeset formula: sin(x) ≈ x − x³/3! + x⁵/5! − x⁷/7!, the first four terms of the Maclaurin series for sine.
    abcd.JPG
    2.5 KB · Views: 491
HallsofIvy said:
And the limit of that as x goes to 0 is ?

That's not the answer according to calculators.
 
tornzaer said:
That's not the answer according to calculators.

According to Mathematica it is.
 
tornzaer said:
That's not the answer according to calculators.

statements like that, with very little information, are hard to help with...

show your method & results and explain why you think there is a disconnect, and we can comment/help out...