Why does light bend,not just slow down?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter jadelamlam
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Light
8 replies · 10K views · last reply
jadelamlam
Messages
51
Reaction score
0
When a light beam passes from an optically denser medium to an optically less dense medium(and vice versa),the direction and the speed of light changes.
My question is why light must bend when it goes from one medium to another.
Say,it goes from air to water. Water is optically denser than air, which means the speed of light in air is higher than the speed of light in water.Why doesn't the light just slow down in water, why does it have to bend in the process?
 
If you search google images for "refraction" you will find diagrams explaining this.

Wavefront diagram of light refracting at a horizontal boundary: blue wavefronts above strike the interface at an angle, and green wavefronts below are bent to a different direction, with yellow dots marking secondary wavelet sources along the boundary.


Diagram of a wavefront refracting at the boundary between air (above) and glass (below): wavefront segments AB and CD, angles θ1 and θ2 from the normal, and v1t and v2t marking distances travelled in each medium; blue arrows show propagation direction.
 
Is this phenomenon related to force/torque/direction of velocity?As force is required to change the direction of object.Seems that there isn't any "force" in this situation.
I just can't imagine why the difference in velocity will cause light rays to bend.
(I have not learned waves yet.I have learned heat,mechanics and light.)
 
The law of refraction can be derived from the Fermat's Principle/Principle of least time, which states that light follows the path of least time.
 
Wave moves into the direction that the wave fronts of the wave are facing.

And the wave fronts are mangled, when different parts of wave fronts have different velocities.

Here is a picture of three wave fronts: | | |
That wave moves either into this direction: --> , or into this direction: <--

Here is a better wave front picture:
http://gemologyproject.com/wiki/index.php?title=File:Wavefront2.png
 
Last edited:
A.T. said:
If you search google images for "refraction" you will find diagrams explaining this.

Diagram of a plane wave refracting at a horizontal boundary: blue wavefronts above, slower green wavefronts below, with grey Huygens secondary wavelets along the boundary and dashed ray arrows.

[..]
One picture can say more than a thousand words. :smile:
Perhaps useful to add that it applies the Huygens construction:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens–Fresnel_principle
When the OP understands how that works, then he can answer his own question. :smile:

Jadelamlam, you only need to understand that a wave propagates at constant speed (depending on the medium) in all directions, as you can see when you throw a stone in the water; and that a wave front (green straight lines in the drawing here above) can be thought of as the sum of many little waves (grey half circles).
Next, you have to take a pencil (not a pen, for surely you'll use your eraser!) and try for yourself.
 
Last edited:
jadelamlam said:
I just can't imagine why the difference in velocity will cause light rays to bend. (I have not learned waves yet.I have learned heat,mechanics and light.)
Okay, here a simple mechanical analogy, a rolling axle with two wheels represents the wavefront. The wheels have different rolling resistance on different surfaces:

Diagram of a rectangle divided into a paper surface on top and a foam surface below, with a dashed line marking the boundary. A two-wheeled axle is drawn crossing the boundary at an angle, with a dashed guide line showing its earlier position. Labels show a height of 2.0m and a width of 1.5m.


From:
http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~scidemos/LightOptics/WheelAxleWavefront/WheelAxleWavefront.html


Two-panel diagram of refraction: top shows an incident ray hitting a horizontal surface and bending as a refracted ray, with a dashed line marking the undeviated path; bottom shows a wheel-and-axle wavefront with left and right wheels approaching a glass block, the left wheel reaching it first.


From:
http://www.yorku.ca/eye/refract.htm
 
A.T. said:
Okay, here a simple mechanical analogy, a rolling axle with two wheels represents the wavefront. The wheels have different rolling resistance on different surfaces:
[..]
Yes, that's a good example if presented as an axle with two independently rolling wheels connected to it.