Why don't ion thrusters work within the atmosphere?

In summary, ion propulsion engines are only effective in the vacuum of space and cannot operate in the presence of ions outside of the engine. The minuscule thrust produced by these engines is unable to overcome significant air resistance, making them impractical for use in atmospheric conditions. Conventional chemical rockets are still necessary for spacecraft to reach orbit. The pressure inside the ion thruster chamber must be very low in order for the engine to function properly, and the presence of air can disrupt this process. Additionally, the drag caused by air is not the main issue, but rather the interference with the acceleration of ions.
  • #1
yrjosmiel
53
5
So I was reading about ion propulsion when I read this:
Ion thrust engines are practical only in the vacuum of space and cannot take vehicles through the atmosphere because ion engines do not work in the presence of ions outside the engine. Additionally, the engine's minuscule thrust cannot overcome any significant air resistance. Spacecraft rely on conventional chemical rockets to initially reach orbit.
-Wikipedia

I understand the fact that drag will be too powerful for the ion thruster to overcome. However, why does it matter when there are foreign ions? Does the magnetic field of the grids pull ions from the atmosphere, thus pulling the entire thing backwards?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The Wikipedia sentence "...cannot take vehicles through the atmosphere because ion engines do not work in the presence of ions outside the engine..." is nonsense.

The pressure inside ion thruster chambers must generally be very low in order to i) effectively make a plasma in the chamber and to ii) effectively accelerate the generated ions to high speeds. When air at normal pressure would enter the chamber, the processes would break down.
 
  • #3
I think a large part of it is that air creates an immense drag on the vessel.. In space there is virtually no drag, so even a small, steady force applied over long periods of time will make something achieve great velocities, while in air, you'd essentially never get yourself moving
 
  • #4
Drag is secondary to the problem that Lord Jestocost highlighted, the ion engine functions by accelerating ions electro statically. That requires a clear path for the ions to accelerate in. If air intrudes, the ions bounce off the air molecules instead and the acceleration is so diffused that thrust is lost.
 

1. Why can't ion thrusters be used in the atmosphere?

The main reason ion thrusters cannot be used in the atmosphere is because they require a vacuum to function. The charged particles, or ions, that are expelled from the thruster would quickly collide with air molecules in the atmosphere, reducing their efficiency and potentially damaging the thruster.

2. Can ion thrusters be used at lower altitudes in the atmosphere?

Ion thrusters can technically be used at lower altitudes in the atmosphere, but their efficiency would be greatly reduced. The density of air molecules at lower altitudes would cause a significant amount of interference, making it difficult for the ions to accelerate and produce thrust.

3. Why do ion thrusters require a vacuum to operate?

Ion thrusters use an electric field to accelerate ions out of the thruster, creating thrust. In a vacuum, there are no air molecules to interfere with the ions, allowing them to reach high speeds and produce efficient thrust. In the atmosphere, the air molecules would disrupt the electric field and hinder the ion acceleration.

4. What is the benefit of using ion thrusters in space instead of traditional chemical rockets?

The main benefit of using ion thrusters in space is their high specific impulse, which means they can produce a high amount of thrust using a small amount of propellant. This allows spacecraft to travel farther and faster using less fuel. However, this only applies in the vacuum of space, as ion thrusters do not work as well in the atmosphere.

5. Are there any plans to develop ion thrusters that can work in the atmosphere?

There are ongoing research and development efforts to create ion thrusters that can operate in the atmosphere. However, it is a challenging task due to the interference of air molecules and the need for a power source to sustain the electric field. Currently, ion thrusters are most efficient and effective in the vacuum of space, so their use in the atmosphere is not a top priority for most space agencies.

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
23
Views
3K
Replies
27
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Aerospace Engineering
Replies
2
Views
7K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
6K
Back
Top