Why is the moving frame kinetic energy term missing from L'?

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
davon806
Messages
147
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Text problem: write the Lagrangian for a simple pendulum in terms of angle θ, suspended from a railway carriage moving horizontally at speed v(t), then show the moving-frame Lagrangian differs by a total derivative when v is constant.


Homework Equations


The last part of this question is an example of this result:
Text box stating the changes of Lagrangian rule: if L1 and L2 satisfy L1(q, q dot, t) = L2(q, q dot, t) + d/dt F(q, t), then L1 and L2 are equivalent Lagrangians giving the same equations of motion.


The Attempt at a Solution


Here is the solution
Handwritten derivation of a Lagrangian L = T - V = ½ml²θ̇² + mglcosθ, then L' with an added term mlvθ̇cosθ for constant v, and L' - L = d/dt[mlv sinθ].


I think L' is missing a term: If we take the Earth as your frame of reference.(i.e. You are stationary, watching the movement of the railway carriage).Then there should be an extra term for the KE of pendulum,due to horizontal movement of the carriage. (see below, the y dot term corresponds to v of the carriage)
Handwritten derivation of pendulum kinetic energy in the carriage frame and lab frame, with a labelled sketch of a pendulum on a carriage with angle theta, velocity v_p and axes e_y and e_z, plus a lab frame diagram showing v_carriage = y dot.


Why is it not involved in L' ?
 
Your constraint equation is ##\dot y = v(t)##. This implies that the term you are referring to only depends on t and therefore is a total derivative (and hence irrelevant for the equations of motion).
 
Orodruin said:
Your constraint equation is ##\dot y = v(t)##. This implies that the term you are referring to only depends on t and therefore is a total derivative (and hence irrelevant for the equations of motion).
Sorry, could you explain it in more detail? I couldn't get it
 
Which part do you have trouble with? There is only one degree of freedom for the pendulum, the angle ##\theta##. The final Lagrangian cannot depend on ##y## since the motion of ##y## is given by integrating ##v(t)##. The constraint gives you ##\dot y = v(t)## and so ##y(t)## is a primitive function of ##v(t)##. Inserting the constraint into your Lagrangian means your ##\dot y^2## term turns into
$$
\frac{\mu v(t)^2}{2}.
$$
This is a function of ##t## only and does not affect the equations of motion.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davon806