Why Is the Resultant Force on the Blade Directed Downwards?

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
werson tan
Messages
183
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


why the resultant force on blade is acted downwards (toward A)? why shouldn't it be slanted upwards ?
since the horizontal component of the force acted 2.12kN to the left , and 0.735kN upwards , we would get the resultant force acting slanted upwards , right ?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Attachments
  • Plan view diagram of a jet from pipe V striking a curved splitter blade at A, with outlets B and A and a 60 degree angle marked.
    0089.PNG
    12.5 KB · Views: 480
  • Handwritten-style worked calculation of force components on a blade: Fx = (9.81/9.81)(0.0707)(12 cos 60° − 12) + (9.81/9.81)(0.1414)(12 cos 60° − 12) = −2.12 kN, and Fy = 1(0.0707)(−12 cos 30° − 0) + 1(0.1414)(12 cos 30° − 0) = 0.735 kN, with a resultant of 2.24 kN at 19.11°.
    0090.PNG
    12 KB · Views: 498
  • Diagram of a closed triangle with three sides drawn as vectors: a red diagonal side from the lower left to the upper right with two arrowheads, a black horizontal side with an arrowhead pointing left, and a black vertical side with an arrowhead pointing up.
    0091.png
    2.4 KB · Views: 467
There is a typo in the Fx equation. The second 12cos60-12 should be 12cos60+12.
In the final answer, take note of the direction of the arrow. The angle is 19.11 degrees to the centreline (x axis). The "towards A" just means it is clockwise from that centreline.
 
haruspex said:
There is a typo in the Fx equation. The second 12cos60-12 should be 12cos60+12.
In the final answer, take note of the direction of the arrow. The angle is 19.11 degrees to the centreline (x axis). The "towards A" just means it is clockwise from that centreline.
the horizontal component of force should be -1.272 N + 2.54 = 1.27N N to the right, whereas the direction and magnitude of vertical force is the same ? then , the direction of resultant of force should be upwards just like the diagram below?
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn right triangle in black with a red line from its lower-left vertex to its upper-right vertex, the red line marked with two matching tick marks showing equal lengths.
    5.png
    2 KB · Views: 448
werson tan said:
the horizontal component of force should be -1.272 N + 2.54 = 1.27N N to the right, whereas the direction and magnitude of vertical force is the same ? then , the direction of resultant of force should be upwards just like the diagram below?
The calculated Fx and Fy are forces on the stream of water. To get the forces on the blade you have to negate both, giving 2.12kN to the right and 0.735kN down.
 
haruspex said:
The calculated Fx and Fy are forces on the stream of water. To get the forces on the blade you have to negate both, giving 2.12kN to the right and 0.735kN down.
isnt that the the resultant force on blade and forecs of steam of water are of same magnitude and same direction
?
 
werson tan said:
isnt that the the resultant force on blade and forecs of steam of water are of same magnitude and same direction
?
Action and reaction are equal and opposite. The force the blade exerts on the stream of water is equal and opposite to the force the water exerts on the blade.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: werson tan