Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Sushmit Nandy
  • Start date
90 replies · 3K views · last reply
Dale said:
Brans Dicke gravity has a parameter that represents how Machian the universe is (with lower values being more Machian and GR being the limit as it goes to infinity).
I'm not aware of this interpretation of the parameter in Brans-Dicke theory. It doesn't seem to be mentioned in either MTW or Wald. Do you have a reference that discusses it?
 
PeterDonis said:
But that's not the kind of rotation the OP is talking about. The OP is talking about rotation of a test object, one whose effect on the spacetime geometry is negligible.
Maybe you misunderstand me.
The OP asks, in effect, why there is an absolute zero wrt rotation. The Berkelian/Machian explanation is that it is determined by the aggregate motion of the mass of the universe. GR frame dragging can explain that and clarifies that this follows an inverse cube law (yes?), but the corollary is that absolute zero rotation can vary from place to place; one observer may perceive another's zero rotation as rotating.
 
haruspex said:
The OP asks, in effect, why there is an absolute zero wrt rotation.
Yes, and the answer is that there is: the vorticity of the congruence of worldlines describing the object.

haruspex said:
The Berkelian/Machian explanation is that it is determined by the aggregate motion of the mass of the universe. GR frame dragging can explain that
No, it can't; as I've already pointed out, frame dragging is involved in a different kind of "rotation" from the kind the OP is asking about. As I said, the OP's example is set in flat spacetime, where there is no frame dragging. So frame dragging can't possibly explain why the congruence of worldlines describing the OP's rotating box has nonzero vorticity.

haruspex said:
one observer may perceive another's zero rotation as rotating.
"Perceived" rotation in this sense is coordinate-dependent and is not an absolute. So it's not an answer to the OP's question about absolute rotation. Vorticity is that answer.
 
haruspex said:
absolute zero rotation can vary from place to place
I think you need to restate this in terms of actual math. Carefully. There are plenty of pitfalls for the unwary lurking here, and I'm not sure you have considered them.
 
PeterDonis said:
frame dragging is involved in a different kind of "rotation" from the kind the OP is asking about.
To be fair, the OP did talk about rotation with respect to "distant stars" as well as "local" rotation that you could detect even if you're unable to get any information from the outside universe (the latter is the kind of rotation that nonzero vorticity is). As I said in post #5, the two senses of "rotation" are not the same and don't necessarily match in relativity. Frame dragging (Lense-Thirring precession) is one of several effects I mentioned in that post that can make them not the same.

But none of this changes the fact that, as I said, there is no frame dragging in flat spacetime, and the OP's scenario was set in flat spacetime, so frame dragging simply can't play any role in explaining whatever the OP wants explained about rotation in that scenario. (The only effect I mentioned in post #5 that can make vorticity not match up with rotation with respect to the "distant stars" in flat spacetime is Thomas precession.)
 
Demystifier said:
But the thread starter said that he has no background in physics. I understood this thread as a challenge to explain things in an elementary way, at a popular physics level. In fact, I often take such challenges, in spirit of the famous claim often attributed to Einstein, that you don't truly understand things until you can explain it to uneducated people. If, for that reason, I over-trivialized some things, I apologize.
Sir, I am not uneducated. I am not just trained enough in physics.
 
I would welcome any answer that's accurate, whether it's of graduate level or high-school. So one can answer in whichever way they are comfortable in.
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
I would welcome any answer that's accurate, whether it's of graduate level or high-school.
You already have had a number of accurate answers. For example, my answer that the box has nonzero vorticity and the universe has zero vorticity, and that's why the box is showing effects of rotation.

Do you have further questions about the answers you have received?
 
But sorry to say, I just joined yesterday and today I am being called uneducated. Is this the way common people are treated here ? I am no genius. But why am I being disrespected. I am sorry but someone could have just told me that this is the wrong place for me, and I would have left simply. This is too rude
 
PeterDonis said:
You already have had a number of accurate answers. For example, my answer that the box has nonzero vorticity and the universe has zero vorticity, and that's why the box is showing effects of rotation.

Do you have further questions about the answers you have received?
I'll go through them properly sir, and if I have one, I'll ask over here. I guess I can do it ?
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
I just joined yesterday and today I am being called uneducated.
I don't think that remark by @Demystifier was meant as a negative judgment. He was trying to gauge your level of background knowledge in this subject area in order to give you answers that would be helpful to you.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Demystifier and Matterwave
Sushmit Nandy said:
I am being called uneducated. … why am I being disrespected.
He did call you uneducated, but I think it was not intended the way it came out.

Usually here when we ask about someone’s education it is intended to help communicate rather than to disrespect. Every single one of us here was uneducated, and we each needed someone else to adjust their communication for us.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Demystifier, Matterwave and PeterDonis
Dale said:
Yeah, that doesn’t sound particularly enjoyable.

So instead of getting involved in nitpicking, I will just point out that many, perhaps most, types of measuring devices were developed before the corresponding theory. So, if you want to allow science to actually happen in the real world instead of just in theory, then you must allow operational definitions in the absence of a theory.
I agree with that. But the thread starter asked a "why" question. "Why" questions can only be answered by theory.
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
Sir, I am not uneducated. I am not just trained enough in physics.
I apologize, I didn't mean it this way. Moreover, I think you are very smart, because you are asking very good questions that well trained (I would say overtrained) physists usually do not ask.
 
Demystifier said:
I apologize, I didn't mean it this way. Moreover, I think you are very smart, because you are asking very good questions that well trained (I would say overtrained) physists usually do not ask.
No sir, you need not apologize. You are elder than me and also a teacher, and I always respect elders and teachers. I just wanted to clear it. And sir, I am just an ordinary student of chemical engineering, nothing more
 
Demystifier said:
"Why" questions can only be answered by theory.
That is simply not true. (Nor is it relevant)

“Why do we accept the postulates of special relativity?” Can and should be answered with experiments.
 
Demystifier said:
@PeterDonis and @Dale , how to explain the notion of proper acceleration at a popular physics level, to someone without a physics background?

I would concur with the idea that an operational definition is best. In this case, I would suggest that a ring laser gyroscope is the best tool to operationally measure rotation. Actually, it measures the component of rotation along some specific axis, one needs multiple such devices to detect rotation along three different axes to make sure there is no rotation.

We can also point out that such a device must, of necessity, not be pointlike - it needs to have a nonzero area to function.

Then we can say that the sort of rotation measured by a ring laser gyroscope is absolute because it can be experimentally measured by a device, without any reference to an external object or an external reference frame, though one could nitpick about the implications of the need for the device to have nonzero area and whether this implies the existence of a reference frame. I will leave that to others if they wish to do it.

Now we come to the second part, which is a bit harder. It's easy to show that there is a simple device that measures rotation. But how can we prove that there is no such device that measures absolute velocity? We don't imagine that we can or have built all possible devices and done all possible experiments. Instead , we talk about some basic physical principles to show that such a device would violate said basic principles. Hopefuly this is related to the OP's question.

Unfortunately, the concept of symmetry may not be familiar to the OP, I suppose. Saying that the laws of physics don't change with motion is the easiest way of explaining this principle. But I can imagine someone asking "why". Especially if their concept of the laws of physics is entirely based on Newton's three laws. I suppose the easiest thing to point out is that this idea historically goes back to Gallileo, and existed even before Newton formulated his three basic laws. People may not actually be familiar with the details of his work, but usually people are willing to accept that Gallielo and Copernicus are sufficiently authoratative and also not "newfangled" theories like Einstein's. (Of course, at this point, Einstein's theories are over 100 years old). If there are questions, we can find the relevant reference. Specifically, Google finds that the relevant English translation of Gallielo' famous 1632 work, "Dialogue concerning the two chief word systems", translated by Stillman Drake from the original 1632 Italian, is available at https://iiif.library.cmu.edu/file/Posner_Files_520_G15D_1653/Posner_Files_520_G15D_1653.pdf

Now, they might not actually read the whole thing - I know I have not, though it's quite famous. But it seems like a good place to point the curious person at who is interested enough to do the work, and it will do a much better job of explaning than I can, and I suspect it will do a better job than pretty much any short PF post will.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dale and Sushmit Nandy
pervect said:
I would concur with the idea that an operational definition is best. In this case, I would suggest that a ring laser gyroscope is the best tool to operationally measure rotation. Actually, it measures the component of rotation along some specific axis, one needs multiple such devices to detect rotation along three different axes to make sure there is no rotation.

We can also point out that such a device must, of necessity, not be pointlike - it needs to have a nonzero area to function.

Then we can say that the sort of rotation measured by a ring laser gyroscope is absolute because it can be experimentally measured by a device, without any reference to an external object or an external reference frame, though one could nitpick about the implications of the need for the device to have nonzero area and whether this implies the existence of a reference frame. I will leave that to others if they wish to do it.

Now we come to the second part, which is a bit harder. It's easy to show that there is a simple device that measures rotation. But how can we prove that there is no such device that measures absolute velocity? We don't imagine that we can or have built all possible devices and done all possible experiments. Instead , we talk about some basic physical principles to show that such a device would violate said basic principles. Hopefuly this is related to the OP's question.

Unfortunately, the concept of symmetry may not be familiar to the OP, I suppose. Saying that the laws of physics don't change with motion is the easiest way of explaining this principle. But I can imagine someone asking "why". Especially if their concept of the laws of physics is entirely based on Newton's three laws. I suppose the easiest thing to point out is that this idea historically goes back to Gallileo, and existed even before Newton formulated his three basic laws. People may not actually be familiar with the details of his work, but usually people are willing to accept that Gallielo and Copernicus are sufficiently authoratative and also not "newfangled" theories like Einstein's. (Of course, at this point, Einstein's theories are over 100 years old). If there are questions, we can find the relevant reference. Specifically, Google finds that the relevant English translation of Gallielo' famous 1632 work, "Dialogue concerning the two chief word systems", translated by Stillman Drake from the original 1632 Italian, is available at https://iiif.library.cmu.edu/file/Posner_Files_520_G15D_1653/Posner_Files_520_G15D_1653.pdf

Now, they might not actually read the whole thing - I know I have not, though it's quite famous. But it seems like a good place to point the curious person at who is interested enough to do the work, and it will do a much better job of explaning than I can, and I suspect it will do a better job than pretty much any short PF post will.
Sir, I didn't get that why are we talking about symmetry here. If you could elaborate, then it would be very helpful. And that absolute velocity cannot be detected, that though I know this is not the rigorous way to put it, but just one can imagine, in a train with all windows closed, translating smoothly, perhaps with 1,00,000 km/s wrt the ground, and I can feel it that no experiment would distinguish it from the situation had it been at rest relative to the ground. I again apologize for this imaginative way, and I know it's not how physics proceeds, but just shared how I think of it. And it would also be great, if you could elaborate, what are those basic principles which would be violated, if a device measuring absolute velocity ever existed. Thank you. Don't know whether continuing such long discussions are allowed or not over here. Open to guidance ....
 
Last edited:
Sushmit Nandy said:
Sir, I didn't get that why are we talking about symmetry here. If you could elaborate, then it would be very helpful.
A symmetry in math or physics means that something under discussion stays unchanged under a particular transformation. The sort of symmetry is usually given as an adjective, for example "rotational symmetry" means that something is unchanged by rotation. Rotation here is an adjective modifying symmetry, to specify what type of symmetry. We might say that "distances on a map" (the something) have "rotational symmetry" (remain unchanged under rotation). It's just the sort of language physicists use.

Sushmit Nandy said:
And that absolute velocity cannot be detected, that though I know this is not the rigorous way to put it, but just one can imagine, in a train with all windows closed, translating smoothly, perhaps with 1,00,000 km/s wrt the ground, and I can feel it that no experiment would distinguish it from the situation had it been at rest relative to the ground.

Yes, this is correct. Physicists just use different language, a jargon. I've tried to explain the jargon a little bit, but you don't absolutely need to know it. It can be helpful to learn the jargon, though. Your long explanation would often be described as saying "the laws of physics on a train" (the something) has a "boost symmetry". Boost is a physicists way of talking about a transformation where we add the same velocity to everything. So it follows the same structure, we have a something of particular interest ("the laws of physics"), and a transformation that leaves this something unchanged (a boost transformation).

Sushmit Nandy said:
I again apologize for this imaginative way, and I know it's not how physics proceeds, but just shared how I think of it. And it would also be great, if you could elaborate, what are those basic principles which would be violated, if a device measuring absolute velocity ever existed. Thank you. Don't know whether continuing such long discussions are allowed or not over here. Open to guidance ....

There's no need to apologize. Asking questions is a good thing.

I'm not sure I've answered your question, but you do seem to be on the right track with your understanding.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
Sushmit Nandy said:
what are those basic principles which would be violated, if a device measuring absolute velocity ever existed.
The basic principle here is called the principle of relativity--although it predates by several centuries the theory we call "relativity" today. Galileo in the early 1600s made the basic observation you have made, that as a matter of actual experience we can't tell uniform motion from rest. Ultimately that's where these "basic principles" come from--we see by experience that the universe appears to obey them, and so we try to figure out ways to incorporate them into our theories.

For example, we observe that experiments generally look the same no matter which direction our lab is facing. We incorporate that into our theories as symmetry under rotation. And we observe that experiments generally look the same when done in labs at different places and at different times. We incorporate that into our theories as symmetry under translation in space and time. Here "symmetry" just means the laws of physics we write down look the same when we apply those transformations mathematically.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
PeterDonis said:
Ok. Yes, in that scenario, an accelerometer attached to a distant star would read zero. And if we used the 6 DOF kind of accelerometer that @Dale described, which also measures vorticity, that would read zero as well.


No. We know the box is rotating because it has nonzero vorticity, and we measure that using devices attached to the box. We can do that even if we can't observe the distant stars at all.

Similarly, we know the distant stars are not rotating because devices attached to them read zero vorticity.


Nature isn't "favoring" anything. We are specifying the scenario such that the box has nonzero vorticity. But we could also imagine a scenario where the box has zero vorticity and the distant stars have nonzero vorticity. We don't live in such a universe, but we could model it mathematically using the laws of physics.


Why would you think that? What in the scenario do you think does not have a sufficient cause?


This does not follow at all, because you are shifting the meaning of "rotating" between the two parts of your sentence. "Seen" to be rotating by some other outside observer is not the same thing as rotating defined by nonzero vorticity.
Sir, after reading the answers, and thinking about it, what I could figure out is this: Imagine we reverse the scenario, the box remains as it is and we rotate all the matter in the universe around the box at the same speed. This scenario is equivalent to the former, because an observer equipped with only rulers and clocks will measure everything the same in this scenario and the original scenario described. Why would the accelerometer disagree in both these scenarios. I mean for principle of sufficient reason to hold, there must be one measurable quantity which must be different for another measurable quantity to be different. Here, one measurable quantity is the accelerometer's reading. But what's the other ? Please correct me if I am wrong. (Note: the accelerometer is fixed to the box and the observer is also fixed inside the box, but his rulers are ideal, in the sense they can measure any external distance, without disturbing anything)
 
Rotating the entire universe about a point does not work because distant objects would need to go faster than the speed of light.
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
Imagine we reverse the scenario, the box remains as it is and we rotate all the matter in the universe around the box at the same speed. This scenario is equivalent to the former
No, it is not.

In the original scenario, the box has nonzero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has zero vorticity. This scenario can be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime, as we have been discussing.

In your revised scenario, the box has zero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has nonzero vorticity. This scenario is measurably different than the first, because vorticity can be measured. It also cannot be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime; the spacetime geometry would have to be something like the Godel universe.

Sushmit Nandy said:
an observer equipped with only rulers and clocks will measure everything the same in this scenario and the original scenario described
If your intent in restricting measurements to only rulers and clocks is to rule out accelerometers and vorticity measurements, then your intent is wrong. "Equivalent" doesn't mean "rulers and clocks agree" if you don't allow other observables to be measured using rulers and clocks. "Equivalent" means all observables agree, and that has to include anything that is an invariant.

Sushmit Nandy said:
Why would the accelerometer disagree in both these scenarios.
Because they are different scenarios. See above.

Sushmit Nandy said:
for principle of sufficient reason to hold, there must be one measurable quantity which must be different for another measurable quantity to be different
I'm not sure what you mean here, and your use of "the principle of sufficient reason" has already been questioned in this thread. If you can find a reference that discusses how to apply this principle in physics and why it matters, please give it. Otherwise we will need to stick with mainstream physics as it's presented in textbooks and peer-reviewed papers.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
Matterwave said:
Rotating the entire universe about a point does not work because distant objects would need to go faster than the speed of light.
Note that the Godel universe does not rotate the entire universe about a "point". But it is a spacetime geometry in which the entire universe can be said to be "rotating".
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy and Matterwave
Sushmit Nandy said:
This scenario is equivalent to the former, because an observer equipped with only rulers and clocks will measure everything the same in this scenario and the original scenario described.
Actually, an observer with only clocks and rulers will not measure the two scenarios to be the same.

Sushmit Nandy said:
Why would the accelerometer disagree in both these scenarios
Accelerometers measure "straight lines" in spacetime (called geodesics). Clocks and rulers measure "distances" in spacetime (called spacetime intervals). In spacetime geometry the "shortest distance between two points is a straight line" principle applies. So, wherever accelerometers detect geodesics, clocks and rulers will detect extremal intervals.

In both scenarios the clocks and rulers will agree with the accelerometers because they are both determined by the metric. The metric determines the reading of clocks, rulers, accelerometers, protractors, speedometers, and all other spacetime geometric quantities. The metric is different in the two scenarios and that difference is reflected in both the accelerometer and also the clock and ruler readings.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
PeterDonis said:
No, it is not.

In the original scenario, the box has nonzero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has zero vorticity. This scenario can be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime, as we have been discussing.

In your revised scenario, the box has zero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has nonzero vorticity. This scenario is measurably different than the first, because vorticity can be measured. It also cannot be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime; the spacetime geometry would have to be something like the Godel universe.


If your intent in restricting measurements to only rulers and clocks is to rule out accelerometers and vorticity measurements, then your intent is wrong. "Equivalent" doesn't mean "rulers and clocks agree" if you don't allow other observables to be measured using rulers and clocks. "Equivalent" means all observables agree, and that has to include anything that is an invariant.


Because they are different scenarios. See above.


I'm not sure what you mean here, and your use of "the principle of sufficient reason" has already been questioned in this thread. If you can find a reference that discusses how to apply this principle in physics and why it matters, please give it. Otherwise we will need to stick with mainstream physics as it's presented in textbooks and peer-reviewed papers.
I'll look for it in the reputed research literature. If I find anything, I'll post it over here. But sir what is vorticity. Does it mean that if a box is rotating in an empty universe, an observer inside the box, will feel being thrown towards the wall, bcz there is nothing external to even say whether it's truly rotating or just there as it is, since the only thing that exists in the universe, is the box. All relative distances between any two points inside the box, remain same. I think that the observer shouldn't feel anything. But the conclusion is dangerous, that means the inertial forces, are due to the other matter in the universe and inertia is not intrinsic to just one particular object. Am I wrong ?
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
what is vorticity
It is a part of the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the object. @Matterwave gave the basic math in post #43. Also see this Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congr...atical_decomposition_of_a_timelike_congruence

Sushmit Nandy said:
Does it mean that if a box is rotating in an empty universe, an observer inside the box, will feel being thrown towards the wall
Yes, that is a prediction of a congruence with nonzero vorticity in flat spacetime.

Sushmit Nandy said:
there is nothing external to even say whether it's truly rotating
You don't need anything external, unless you want to call the spacetime geometry itself "external". The vorticity is a property of the box itself and the spacetime geometry it's embedded in.

Sushmit Nandy said:
I think that the observer shouldn't feel anything.
This is physics. We don't "think" something without doing the math. If you do the math, you will see that it predicts what the rest of us have been saying, and not what you have been saying.

Sushmit Nandy said:
the conclusion is dangerous, that means the inertial forces, are due to the other matter in the universe and inertia is not intrinsic to just one particular object. Am I wrong ?
The inertial forces are due to the spacetime geometry and the properties of the congruence of worldlines that describes the box. To the extent that the spacetime geometry is determined by other matter in the universe, it has an effect, yes. This is standard GR.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Matterwave and Sushmit Nandy