Why would Tesla want free enrgy for everyone?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mapa
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Tesla
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the motivations behind Nikola Tesla's alleged desire to provide free energy to the world. Participants explore various theories, historical context, and Tesla's character, touching on humanitarian aspects, financial implications, and the rivalry with Thomas Edison. The conversation includes speculative reasoning and personal interpretations of Tesla's intentions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Historical

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants question whether Tesla ever explicitly stated a desire to provide free energy, suggesting that this may be more of a myth or propaganda.
  • Others propose that Tesla's motivations could have been humanitarian, arguing that not everyone is primarily driven by profit.
  • A few participants speculate that Tesla, having been born into wealth, may have had a different perspective on money and invention compared to others.
  • There are claims that Tesla's experiments aimed to provide free energy through innovative methods, such as transmitting power through the Earth and air, though these methods faced significant technical challenges.
  • Some participants express skepticism about the feasibility of free energy, arguing that even if it were possible, the responsibilities associated with its use would complicate the notion of it being "free."
  • Discussion includes references to Tesla's financial struggles and his willingness to forgo royalties, suggesting that his priorities may have been more aligned with his work than with financial gain.
  • Participants mention Tesla's rivalry with Edison, with some arguing that Edison was more focused on business success and public image, while Tesla was more concerned with scientific achievement.
  • There are references to Tesla's historical experiments, including the chaotic results of his power transmission attempts, which highlight the challenges he faced in realizing his vision.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on Tesla's motivations or the feasibility of free energy. Multiple competing views remain, with some supporting the idea of Tesla's altruism and others questioning the practicality and historical accuracy of such claims.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the lack of direct quotes from Tesla regarding his intentions, the speculative nature of participants' interpretations, and the unresolved technical aspects of Tesla's proposed methods for providing free energy.

  • #31


xxChrisxx said:
Not only that, he was respected enough that an SI unit was named after him.
That's true. Also a band, and a car.
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
  • #32


zoobyshoe said:
That nutcase is coming out of your wall at 60hz as you read this. He had one or two sound ideas.

ya, he was even playing with remote control boats at the time while letting credit for "radio" slip to marconi. the guy was completely brilliant, while edison was a hack who was probably mostly taking credit for the ideas of the guys working in his shop (one of whom was Tesla, briefly).
 
  • #33
Tesla was a great scientist and a terrible business man. He helped the industrial revolution to proceed much faster than it could have without him.
If we look at his last years, the candle is out. He died poor, confused, and broken. He was hit by a taxi and tried to cure himself.
If I recall right, Henry Ford died in a similar way. A spring thaw flooded the river banks near his power house. He died in a dark, cold, wet home.
So don't burn your candle on both ends, it won't end well.
 
  • #34
I believe Tesla would have made money off every tower that was built. There needed to be towers that created and projected the electrical power into the air. I think everyone would also need some way to harvest electric from the air and convert/clean it for household and business use. He would in fact make quite a bit of money from the patented tech every time one was sold and installed.
 
  • #35
Don't know about Tesla, but the notion of free energy for everyone is a bit of a, umm, pyrrhic one, I would say. Imagine, if there was boundless free energy. Rather than some utopia resulting, I think the consequences would be disastrous.
 
  • #36
RaDoonZ said:
I believe Tesla would have made money off every tower that was built. There needed to be towers that created and projected the electrical power into the air. I think everyone would also need some way to harvest electric from the air and convert/clean it for household and business use. He would in fact make quite a bit of money from the patented tech every time one was sold and installed.

wouldn't work. a patent only protects you for a few years. then anyone can build a device to leach off the atmospheric grid that YOU pay money to energize. or, they could ignore your patent rights, leach off the grid before your patent expires, and send you into financial ruin right away.
 
  • #37
Maybe Tesla found a way to get energy for free. There's no shortage of energy in the universe. The Earth intercepts only one part of 2.205 billion parts of energy which the Sun puts out. We still can't reproduce his ball lightning. Maybe he was a nice guy.
 
  • #38
Relay said:
Maybe Tesla found a way to get energy for free. There's no shortage of energy in the universe. The Earth intercepts only one part of 2.205 billion parts of energy which the Sun puts out. We still can't reproduce his ball lightning. Maybe he was a nice guy.

Nice Guy Tesla. Sounds like a meme.
 
  • #41
mapa said:
Why we Tesla want to give away free energy when he knew he could make money off
of it?

His motives were probably psychological. As a boy there was an incident in his village where his interest in machines and devices paid off unexpectedly to increase his status:

"A new fire engine had been purchased, along with uniforms for a fire department, and this called for a celebration. The community turned out for a parade, there were speeches, and then the command was given to pump water with the new equipment. Not a drop came from the nozzle. While the village fathers stood in puzzled dismay, the bright lad flung himself into the river and found, as he had suspected, that the hose had collapsed. He corrected the problem, instantly drenching the delighted village fathers. Long after, Tesla would recall that 'Archimedes running naked thru the streets of Syracuse did not make a greater impression than myself. I was carried on the shoulders and was the hero of the day.'"

Tesla, Man Out of Time
Margaret Chaney, p. 8

I think Tesla spent most of his life trying to regain/maintain that hero status he enjoyed when he saved the day back in his village. Being hailed as the hero who gave free electricity to all would have been a reward more valuable to him than money.
 

Similar threads

Replies
46
Views
8K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
15K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
6K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K