Work/Energy in a Magnetic Field

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the concepts of work and energy in the context of magnetic fields, particularly focusing on the behavior of magnetic dipoles and the forces involved in their motion. Participants explore the theoretical implications of magnetic forces and their ability to perform work.

Discussion Character

  • Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants question the nature of work done by magnetic forces, with some suggesting that while magnetic forces influence momentum, they do not contribute to changes in kinetic energy. Others explore the distinction between magnetic potential energy and the work done by internal forces.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants sharing insights and examples to clarify the relationship between magnetic forces and energy. There is an ongoing exploration of terminology, particularly regarding the concept of magnetic potential energy and its implications.

Contextual Notes

Some participants express uncertainty about the terminology used in describing magnetic potential energy, noting that it may lead to confusion regarding the role of magnetic forces in doing work.

MyoPhilosopher
Messages
41
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
A compass needle has a magnetic moment of 𝜇. At its location, the magnitude of the Earth’s magnetic field is 𝑩 northward at 𝜃 below the horizontal. Identify the orientations of the needle that represent (a) the minimum potential energy and (b) the maximum potential energy of the needle–field system. (c) How much work must be done on the system to move the needle from the minimum to the maximum potential energy orientation?
Relevant Equations
ΔU = -μBcos(θ)
Sorry if I am asking in the wrong fashion as I am new.

The above questions are easily solvable:
1) U = -μBcos(0)
2) U = -μBcos(180)
3) W = ΔU = 2) - 1)

My question is more related to some theory: where is this work/energy coming from since a magnetic force, to my knowledge can't do "work"?
What force is doing -W (minus W), is it simply the magnetic field, or is there another concrete equation to demonstrate what exactly is happening.

Thank you for anyone that can explain or possibly ask me directional questions
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
Physics news on Phys.org
It's one of those bizarre situations in physics where a force is responsible for the change in momentum (angular momentum in this case since the needle rotates) but is not responsible for the change in the (rotational) kinetic energy (of the needle). For the latter are responsible internal electrostatic forces that appear inside the needle.
Another example of such a force is the friction between a car's wheels and the road. We all know that a car cannot move without friction, however we all also know that the work isn't done by friction but by the car's engine. So friction is responsible for the change in the momentum of the car, but internal forces at car's engine are responsible for the work done that increases the kinetic energy of the car.
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: MyoPhilosopher
Delta2 said:
It's one of those bizarre situations in physics where a force is responsible for the change in momentum (angular momentum in this case since the needle rotates) but is not responsible for the change in the (rotational) kinetic energy (of the needle). For the latter are responsible internal electrostatic forces that appear inside the needle.
Another example of such a force is the friction between a car's wheels and the road. We all know that a car cannot move without friction, however we all also know that the work isn't done by friction but by the car's engine. So friction is responsible for the change in the momentum of the car, but internal forces at car's engine are responsible for the work done that increases the kinetic energy of the car.

Thank you for taking the time, great answer!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman
Delta2 said:
It's one of those bizarre situations in physics where a force is responsible for the change in momentum (angular momentum in this case since the needle rotates) but is not responsible for the change in the (rotational) kinetic energy (of the needle). For the latter are responsible internal electrostatic forces that appear inside the needle.
Another example of such a force is the friction between a car's wheels and the road. We all know that a car cannot move without friction, however we all also know that the work isn't done by friction but by the car's engine. So friction is responsible for the change in the momentum of the car, but internal forces at car's engine are responsible for the work done that increases the kinetic energy of the car.

Nice answer!

So it really shouldn't be referred to as "magnetic potential energy" then, right?

The change in the potential energy should be the work done by the magnetic force, but the magnetic force can do no work. I guess it is just a shorthand way of referring to the potential energy associated with a magnetic dipole in a magnetic field. Saying the electric potential energy in this case, would just confuse people.
 
Rolls With Slipping said:
Nice answer!

So it really shouldn't be referred to as "magnetic potential energy" then, right?

The change in the potential energy should be the work done by the magnetic force, but the magnetic force can do no work. I guess it is just a shorthand way of referring to the potential energy associated with a magnetic dipole in a magnetic field. Saying the electric potential energy in this case, would just confuse people.
Well yes the magnetic field can't do work on matter, hence the term magnetic potential energy becomes problematic at first glance. However we can attribute the work of the internal electric forces as (pseudo) work of the magnetic field force and this can make the magnetic potential energy term viable again.
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
749
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
34
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
3K