Young's modulus calculation for a steel bar

9 replies · 2K views · last reply
chriscarson
Messages
197
Reaction score
26
Homework Statement
Problem to find strain and force
Relevant Equations
F = A E delta L
L
As all attempts to get it right but without success this is one of the problems with my workout . Where i did wrong calculations ?
The questions got the answers in brackets.
Printed physics problem 11: a steel bar stressed to 280 MN/m², Young's modulus 205 x 10^9 N/m², 80 mm diameter, 240 mm long; asks for strain (answer 0.00136) and force (answer 1.407MN).
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten working on lined paper for a stress and strain problem: stress 280,000,000 N/m², E = 205×10⁹ N/m², A = 0.005024 m², L = 0.24 m, strain 0.00137, F = 1410990 N, ΔL = 0.0003288 m, with alternative calculations of strain, ΔL and F = AEΔL/L giving 3386376.96/0.24 m on the right.
    20200219_162618-1.jpg
    39.4 KB · Views: 276
Last edited by a moderator:
It looks like your answers for the strain and force match the book answers. What's the problem?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chriscarson and etotheipi
I know that can be rounded or something but when they have different numbers I need to be sure
 
chriscarson said:
I know that can be rounded or something but when they have different numbers I need to be sure
What’s different?
 
Printed problem text: a steel bar is stressed to 280 MN/m². Young's [modulus] ... eter and 240 mm long. Determine: the strain (Answer: 0.00136); the force (Answer: 1.407MN).
Handwritten values on lined paper: L = 0.24 m, Strain = 0.00137, F = 1410990 N, Δl = 0.0003288 m.


Strain and force have different numbers you can see .
 
This is just because of rounding errors. Either yourself or the author have prematurely truncated the results from previous steps.

This goes to show the benefit of working algebraically and only substituting in numerical values in the final line of working. The alternative is to use the STORE buttons on your calculator, which is much more fiddly...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chriscarson
etotheipi said:
This is just because of rounding errors. Either yourself or the author have prematurely truncated the results from previous steps.

This goes to show the benefit of working algebraically and only substituting in numerical values in the final line of working. The alternative is to use the STORE buttons on your calculator, which is much more fiddly...
The strain maybe close but the force is way out i think.
 
When you multiplied the stress by the area to get the force, you must have made a mistake in arithmetic. When I use your calculated area, I get their force. When I divide the stress by Young's modulus to get the strain, I confirm your value of 0.00137.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chriscarson
Chestermiller said:
When you multiplied the stress by the area to get the force, you must have made a mistake in arithmetic. When I use your calculated area, I get their force. When I divide the stress by Young's modulus to get the strain, I confirm your value of 0.00137.

So for the force you just multiplied stress with by area ?
If you have time you can work all the problem because I showed it .

we also had a formula F = k delta L , is that another way to find the F ? the only problem is what is the k .
 
Last edited:
chriscarson said:
So for the force you just multiplied stress with by area ? I multiplied area, young modulus and delta L over length
If you have time you can work all the problem because I showed it .