Quadratic Formula: Positive or Negative Root?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion clarifies the use of the quadratic formula, specifically the interpretation of the "\pm" symbol, which indicates that two roots are derived from the equation. Participants emphasize that one solution involves adding the square root term to -b, while the other involves subtracting it, regardless of whether the discriminant is a perfect square. The conversation highlights a common misconception about square roots, stating that the notation \sqrt{x} refers only to the positive root. Ultimately, understanding that both operations yield distinct solutions is crucial for correctly applying the quadratic formula. The key takeaway is that the quadratic formula consistently provides two roots through both addition and subtraction of the square root term.
Holocene
Messages
237
Reaction score
0
Regarding \displaystyle{\frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}}

How should "\displaystyle{\pm}" be treated?

I know a square root can be both possitive and negative, but does the quardratic forumla dictate that a possitive root should be added to -b, or does it dictate that a postive root should be subtracted from -b?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
The quadradic forumal yields 2 roots. You do both.
 
Some people get confused because other times they see the plus/minus sign, they have to choose correctly, whilst in this case you do it both. Thats why you may also see the formula written as;

x_1= \displaystyle{\frac{-b + \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}}

x_2 = \displaystyle{\frac{-b - \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}}
 
Integral said:
The quadradic forumal yields 2 roots. You do both.

Sorry, I'm a little confused.

Say a particular solution to a quadratic equation is \displaystyle{\frac{2 \pm \sqrt{7}}{3}}[\tex]<br /> <br /> If 7 was a perfect sqaure, would the root get added to or subtrected from 2?
 
Holocene said:
Sorry, I'm a little confused.

Say a particular solution to a quadratic equation is \frac{2 \pm \sqrt{7}}{3}

If 7 was a perfect square, would the root get added to or subtracted from 2?

It doesn't matter if 7 is a perfect square or not (and it isn't). There are TWO roots to a quadratic equation, hence the quadratic formula has TWO solutions. One of the solutions is when you add the square root part, the other solution is when you subtract it. Look at my previous post.
 
Gib Z said:
It doesn't matter if 7 is a perfect square or not (and it isn't). There are TWO roots to a quadratic equation, hence the quadratic formula has TWO solutions. One of the solutions is when you add the square root part, the other solution is when you subtract it. Look at my previous post.

Okay I've got it. The 2 solutions are adding a possitive root, and subtracting a possitive root, correct? (Subtracting a negative root is = to adding it, adding a negative root is = to subtracting it).
 
Holocene said:
Okay I've got it. The 2 solutions are adding a possitive root, and subtracting a possitive root, correct? (Subtracting a negative root is = to adding it, adding a negative root is = to subtracting it).
\sqrt{x} is used to denote the positive square root of x. Thus \sqrt{4}=2 is correct while \sqrt{4}=\pm2 is incorrect. Thinking that the latter is correct is too common a mistake - make sure you aren't making it.
 
morphism said:
\sqrt{x} is used to denote the positive square root of x. Thus \sqrt{4}=2 is correct while \sqrt{4}=\pm2 is incorrect. Thinking that the latter is correct is too common a mistake - make sure you aren't making it.

Got it, thanks.
 
Back
Top