Do Electrons Attract AND Repel?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FeDeX_LaTeX
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electrons Repel
AI Thread Summary
Electrons repel each other due to their negative charges, but they also experience a gravitational attraction, albeit a much weaker force. The gravitational force between two electrons is negligible compared to the electrostatic repulsion, which dominates at the atomic level. While electrons in the same orbital do repel each other, they are simultaneously attracted to the positively charged nucleus, preventing them from drifting away. The discussion highlights that the balance of forces, including gravitational and electromagnetic, determines the behavior of electrons in atoms. Ultimately, the repulsive force between like charges is significantly stronger than any gravitational attraction they may experience.
FeDeX_LaTeX
Science Advisor
Messages
436
Reaction score
13
Bit confused here. Electrons repel each other because they both have negative charges. But wouldn't they also ATTRACT each other because of the force of gravity?

F_{g} = \frac {Gm_{1}m_{2}} {d^{2}}

Do two electrons by this law have a force of gravity that attracts them? Is it possible to get two identically charged particles to ATTRACT if the force of gravity given by the above formula is GREATER than the repulsive electron force?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
FeDeX_LaTeX said:
Bit confused here. Electrons repel each other because they both have negative charges. But wouldn't they also ATTRACT each other because of the force of gravity?

F_{g} = \frac {Gm_{1}m_{2}} {d^{2}}

Do two electrons by this law have a force of gravity that attracts them? Is it possible to get two identically charged particles to ATTRACT if the force of gravity given by the above formula is GREATER than the repulsive electron force?

Everything you say is correct. But for fundamental particles, the electric repulsion will always be much greater than the gravitational attraction. However, if you give the Earth and moon each one electron charge, the gravitational attraction will still be dominant :-)
Torquil
 
You're correct. The electron repels each other because of the same charge but attracts because of the gravitational force. Both kinds of force obeys the square law (force is proportional to \frac{1}{r^2}). Two things repelling or attracting depending on charge and mass of themselves.
 
Why don't electrons in the same orbital repel each other
 
Saad Ahmed said:
Why don't electrons in the same orbital repel each other

Of course they do! In a simple 'pictorial' model, they keep as far from each other as possible - but they are, of course, attracted to the + nucleus at the same time, which keeps them from drifting away.
 
FeDeX_LaTeX said:
Bit confused here. Electrons repel each other because they both have negative charges. But wouldn't they also ATTRACT each other because of the force of gravity?

F_{g} = \frac {Gm_{1}m_{2}} {d^{2}}

Do two electrons by this law have a force of gravity that attracts them? Is it possible to get two identically charged particles to ATTRACT if the force of gravity given by the above formula is GREATER than the repulsive electron force?

1. Put two electrons at a fix distance from each other.

2. Compute the electrostatic force between them.

3. Compute the gravitational force between them.

4. COMPARE the magnitude of both forces and see which one DOMINATES!

zZ.
 
Repulsive Forces in greater than Gravitational Force...
Than why electrons does repel each other in same Orbital?
i think due to opposite spin which create opposite magnetic field in btw Electrons As we know opposite Magnetic field of lines attracts each other...
 
why does an electron not collide with nucleus??

why does an electron not collide with nucleus??
 


Saad Ahmed said:
why does an electron not collide with nucleus??

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=511179
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #10


For two like charges moving parallel at a relativistic speed, the magnetic component of the Lorentz force nearly cancels out the electric component of the Lorentz force. According to General Relativity, does the gravitational "force" increase, decrease, or remain the same when viewed from the rest frame of that system?
 
  • #11
"Relativistic speed" relative to each other is zero, surely.
 
Back
Top