Register to reply

Anders Behring Breivik judged judicially insane

by arildno3
Tags: anders, behring, breivik, insane, judged, judicially
Share this thread:
arildno3
#1
Nov29-11, 05:50 AM
P: n/a
Just now, it has been revealed, to the surprise of us all that the forensic psychiatrists have concluded that Breivik is judicially insane.
This means that if their 230-page report is accepted as valid forensic material, and no second opinion is sought, the court (set for April 2012) may sentence him to involuntary confinement at a psychiatric hospital.

I am not happy with this, but it MIGHT be the best action to ensure his PERMANENT removal from society.
Nor am I happy that I've forgotten mypasword at PF.
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Experts defend operational earthquake forecasting, counter critiques
EU urged to convert TV frequencies to mobile broadband
Sierra Nevada freshwater runoff could drop 26 percent by 2100
Ryan_m_b
#2
Nov29-11, 06:00 AM
Mentor
Ryan_m_b's Avatar
P: 5,477
Perhaps he seriously is mentally ill. Either way he wont hurt anyone again.

Also make sure you PM Greg ASAP about your password.
arildno3
#3
Nov29-11, 06:59 AM
P: n/a
The next phase is now that the National Forensic Board scrutinizes the report made by the two appointed psychiatrists to see if it is a scientifically sound document (this is standard procedure in Norway). The Board's conclusions are expected to be finished by Christmas; what is extraordinar with this case is that the full 9-man Board will be actively involved; usually, only 2 or 3 of the Board members checks the report frm the psychiatrists.

dacruick
#4
Nov29-11, 07:59 AM
P: 1,084
Anders Behring Breivik judged judicially insane

I don't think this news is as bad as it first seems.

The last thing that he wants is to be in the record books as insane.
arildno3
#5
Nov29-11, 08:07 AM
P: n/a
It is not a question of what HE wants, but of what I, and other Norwegians want.
Getting the diagnosis "paranoid schizophrenic" removes the level of personal guilt from him; and to retain that level is more important than the probable length of his confinement.
Ryan_m_b
#6
Nov29-11, 08:09 AM
Mentor
Ryan_m_b's Avatar
P: 5,477
Quote Quote by dacruick View Post
I don't think this news is as bad as it first seems.

The last thing that he wants is to be in the record books as insane.
I was thinking this exact thing. I imagine he wants to go down in history as a martyr for his cause that would stimulate others to do the same and start a revolution. Going down as a deranged mentally ill loser who committed an atrocity is definitely not what he wants.
dacruick
#7
Nov29-11, 08:35 AM
P: 1,084
Quote Quote by arildno3 View Post
It is not a question of what HE wants, but of what I, and other Norwegians want.
Getting the diagnosis "paranoid schizophrenic" removes the level of personal guilt from him; and to retain that level is more important than the probable length of his confinement.
I agree, that's a frustrating sentiment.

I am fairly ignorant about Breivik's current legal situation, it just seems to me like being labelled insane wouldn't be beneficial to him.

Originally, I assumed that his "movement" would lose credibility due to a ruling of insanity. After doing a little bit of reading, I see that it is quite likely that some blame for his actions could be placed on the society that "made him that way".

This is a very tragic incident, and the thought of this man disgusts me. If it were up to me, I'd probably have him killed so I'm not sure I'm the right person to be discussing these matters.
NeoDevin
#8
Nov29-11, 08:54 AM
P: 687
Quote Quote by arildno3 View Post
It is not a question of what HE wants, but of what I, and other Norwegians want.
No, it's a matter of what is legal and just. Unless Norway has descended to mob rule since I last checked?
Ryan_m_b
#9
Nov29-11, 09:00 AM
Mentor
Ryan_m_b's Avatar
P: 5,477
Quote Quote by NeoDevin View Post
No, it's a matter of what is legal and just. Unless Norway has descended to mob rule since I last checked?
Exactly. Justice is not and should not be a democratic process. You can't gather up a large group and vote on what to do in each case, that's ad-hoc justice. Rather you use democracy to establish the laws and the punishment that are then applied to each case impartially.
arildno
#10
Nov29-11, 09:53 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 12,016
Well, several psychiatrists have expressed strong surprise that he has been diagnosed as a paranoid schizophrenic, although a main characteristic of that disease, namely suffering from auditory or visual hallucinations are expressly denied by the observing psychiatrists.
turbo
#11
Nov29-11, 10:18 AM
PF Gold
turbo's Avatar
P: 7,363
Quote Quote by arildno View Post
Well, several psychiatrists have expressed strong surprise that he has been diagnosed as a paranoid schizophrenic, although a main characteristic of that disease, namely suffering from auditory or visual hallucinations are expressly denied by the observing psychiatrists.
Is this diagnosis perhaps an end-run around Norway's short sentences for murder? Can he be locked up permanently with such a diagnosis, for instance, with annual reviews? I don't know how your system works, but a mass-murderer would either get the death penalty in the US, or consecutive life sentences (no chance for release, ever).
arildno
#12
Nov29-11, 10:27 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 12,016
Quote Quote by turbo View Post
Is this diagnosis perhaps an end-run around Norway's short sentences for murder? Can he be locked up permanently with such a diagnosis, for instance, with annual reviews? I don't know how your system works, but a mass-murderer would either get the death penalty in the US, or consecutive life sentences (no chance for release, ever).
That is, indeed, what I suspect.

The convoluted process for a person sentenced by court to compulsory mental health care (questions of factual, if not judicial, guilt must still be determined by a court of law) is as follows:
Every 3 years, the compulsory mental health care program must be reviewed by a court of law. It is the SUFFICIENT for his continued detainment that he is deemed to suffer from the same mental illness as was present during his actions an during the observations that were the foundation for the psychiatrist's report. If a court finds at such a time that no longer can be regarded as criminally insane, but still poses a danger to society, there exists an obscure, little-used provision that he can be transferred to a more conventional detention program.
If, however, the court decides that he no longer is mentally ill, and no longer poses a threat to society, he must be released. so, in theory he could be out in 2015, but probably be confined for his full, physical life.
pftest
#13
Dec9-11, 03:53 PM
P: 271
It also seems like the ultimate way to take revenge on breivik. He really wants his ideas and motivation to be understood and taken seriously, and warn the world about islam (rightly so btw), but if it becomes commonly accepted that he is schizophrenic, his acts will be seen as completely senseless. And for him to be released, he will have to betray his own convictions, which if he isnt insane probably never will.
arildno
#14
Dec21-11, 12:36 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 12,016
Tonight, the national television channel NRK brings interviews with ABBs father and step-father.
I guess I'll have to watch it.
dacruick
#15
Dec21-11, 12:46 PM
P: 1,084
Quote Quote by arildno View Post
Tonight, the national television channel NRK brings interviews with ABBs father and step-father.
I guess I'll have to watch it.
That sounds quite interesting. Let us know how the interview goes.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Breivik - Who made him do it? Current Events 99
Breivik's phone calls to the police Current Events 3
Breivik's bizarre mind&evil actions Current Events 0
Two of Breivik's victims: Can he be charged for pre-meditated homicide? General Discussion 2