Register to reply

Mathematica - using rules to assign integration limits

by izzy93
Tags: limits, mathematica, rules
Share this thread:
Feb18-13, 12:18 PM
P: 30
I'm trying to find the integration of my function f[x] from 1 to 4 using the indefinite integral and inserting limits using rules. I am not sure how to insert the limits with rules, have been playing about with the following

Integrate[f[x], x] /. x -> {1 >= x <= 4}

which ain't working,

any help much appreciated
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on
Physical constant is constant even in strong gravitational fields
Montreal VR headset team turns to crowdfunding for Totem
Researchers study vital 'on/off switches' that control when bacteria turn deadly
Feb18-13, 01:57 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 6,755
How about 1 <= x <= 4?
Bill Simpson
Feb18-13, 02:24 PM
P: 1,043
Try using some undefined function q, instead of Integrate, that will do nothing at the moment, just to see what actually happens with your substition.

In[1]:= q[f[x],x]/.x->{1≥x≤4}

Out[1]= q[f[{1≥x&&x≤4}],{1≥x&&x≤4}]

and that doesn't look anything like


that I suspect you are trying to accomplish.

So does that provide any additional information for your next attempt?

Feb18-13, 03:28 PM
P: 30
Mathematica - using rules to assign integration limits

Hello Bill,

when I put that in , comes up with an error

ln[106]= q[f[x], x] /. {1 <= x <= 4}
ReplaceAll::reps: {1<=x<=4} is neither a list of replacement rules nor a valid dispatch table, and so cannot be used for replacing. >>
out[107] = q[E^(-x/2) x^2 Sin[5 x], x] /. {1 <= x <= 4}

Yes that's what I'm aiming for but I need to do it using rules. Is there another way of going about this?

Bill Simpson
Feb18-13, 07:39 PM
P: 1,043
The reason for your latest error is you left out the "x->" that I had. Compare these:
In[1]:= q[f[x],x]/.x->{1≥x≤4}
ln[106]= q[f[x],x] /.{1<=x<=4}

Now if you need to use replacement rules and you need to start with {1<=x<=4} then I would look at


and see if you can think of a way to use rules to turn that into


If you can use replacement rules to accomplish that then you will be half way to then using that result as another replacement to turn x into {x,1,4}.

But you have two x that you have to worry about, one inside f[x] and one inside q[ ,x]. You only want to replace the second one, not the first one.

You might look at this
and pay particular attention to levelspec. Levels are not exactly obvious to a new user, but with the hint that you want to pay attention to that then you might be able to figure out how to have a replacment only change the particular x that you are wanting it to and leave the other x alone.

So look at that FullForm result and see if you can solve that problem first. Then you can study levels.
Feb19-13, 11:44 AM
P: 30
In[32] = q[f[x], x] /. x -> {1 <= x <= 4}
out[30]=q[{E^(-(1/2) (1 <= x <= 4)) (1 <= x <= 4)^2 Sin[
5 (1 <= x <= 4)]}, {1 <= x <= 4}]
which just substitutes in what I want the limits of x to be

In[1] = FullForm[{1 <= x <= 4}]
Out[2] = List[LessEqual[1,x,4]]

then I tried

In[3]= FullForm[{x >= 1, x <= 4}]
out[4] = List[GreaterEqual[x,1], LessEqual[x,4]]

Afraid I can't see how to turn it into {x,1,4}, is quite beyond me atm!

Bill Simpson
Feb19-13, 02:18 PM
P: 1,043
In[1]:= {1≤x≤4}/.{l_<=v_<=h_}->{v,l,h}

Out[1]= {x,1,4}

So that just used your literal input to make a replacement rule.
Sometimes that won't work and sometimes it isn't obvious why.
In those cases you can sometimes use the FullForm of your
expression to make up your replacement rule.
Feb19-13, 03:45 PM
P: 30
Ok it's odd but I think I see,
Thanks very much for your help

Register to reply

Related Discussions
Integration by parts, help me understand why the integration limits changed. Calculus & Beyond Homework 2
Can anyone tell me on what basis do we assign ok not assign conclude Chemistry 1
Mathematica: How to Do This? (Rules) Math & Science Software 8
Rules of limits (breaking a larger limit into 2 smaller ones) Calculus & Beyond Homework 3
Mathematica assign derivative Calculus 2