One Big problem with Jackson's Classical Electrodynamics

[qinglong.1397]

Homework Statement

You can find the problem in Jackson's Classical Electrodynamics 3rd edition. Chapter 10.19.I already calculated the transmission coefficients, but mine are fourth of those given by Jackson. I do not know why.

My calculation is based on Problem 10.18. I use dipole moments approximation.

I hope someone can help me correct my error. Thank you very much!

 

[Antiphon]

Does that site violate the publisher's copyright on Jackson?

 

[qinglong.1397]

Does that site violate the publisher's copyright on Jackson?

Oh my god! That is just a photo. If so, I will tell him to delete it.

 

[qinglong.1397]

I have solved this problem. Oh... I should have said I found my problem. I did not read the book carefully enough. Thank you, guys!

 

[paranormal]

As a fellow scientist, I understand the frustration of encountering discrepancies in calculations and results. In this case, it is important to carefully review your calculations and assumptions to identify any potential errors. It is also helpful to consult with colleagues or experts in the field for further insights and potential solutions.

In addition, it is worth mentioning that scientific research and understanding is an ongoing process, and it is not uncommon for different researchers to come up with slightly different results or interpretations. This is why replication and verification of results is crucial in the scientific community.

I would suggest reaching out to the author or other experts in the field to discuss your calculations and see if they can provide any insights or potential sources of error. It may also be helpful to review the mathematical derivations and assumptions made in Jackson's textbook to gain a better understanding of the problem.

Overall, it is important to approach this challenge with a scientific mindset, remaining open to the possibility of errors and seeking out potential solutions through collaboration and further investigation. Best of luck in correcting your error and advancing your understanding of classical electrodynamics.