
#1
Nov1905, 11:59 PM

Sci Advisor
P: 1,132

In trying to understand why matter curves space i thought up a model that has the curiosity of suggesting the concept of maximum gravity, suggesting that as the mass of an object increases gravity increases as well, until the mass reaches a point at which the gravity starts to increase more slowly until it actually levels off at some maximum level, after which an increase in mass will not further increase the corresponding gravity. Has any data or observations suggested such a phenomenon? I realize it may be hard to verify this claim.




#2
Nov2005, 07:25 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,322

I don't think so, in fact the data suggests just the opposite. If you believe in black holes, and the data is pretty strong these days, then the strength of gravity has no upper limit.
In the Newtonian approximation, the strength of the field is linear in the mass. Once you introduce GR, the gravitational field gets all kinds of new sources. Moreover, the field can actually contribute to itself (this is the nonlinearity of Einstein's equations). So rather than leveling off in very massive systems, the gravitational actually gets amplified by the nonlinearity in the system. This is why you only have to squeeze a finite amount of stuff into a small enough region to produce a black hole, a gravitational object where the gravitational field (curvature) actually diverges. All that being said, it may be that true gravitational singularities do not exist. The issue is muddled because the heart of a black hole is precisely one of the places where quantum gravity should be important, and as you no doubt are aware, a satisfactory theory has yet to be invented. Nevertheless, many people suspect that quantum effects will smear out the singularity, so maybe in some ultimate way your idea will turn out to be right. Perhaps quantum effects limit the ultimate strength of gravity. 



#3
Nov2005, 10:27 AM

Sci Advisor
P: 1,132

That was helpful, thanks. I have another question now, what is the main difficulty in trying to explain quantum gravity with GR?




#4
Nov2005, 11:08 AM

P: 932

Maximum Gravity 



#5
Nov2005, 11:17 AM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,322

masudr,
I think you may be a bit confused. There definitely is a spacetime singularity at [tex] r = 0 [/tex], the curvature invariant [tex] I = R_{\alpha \beta \gamma \delta} R^{\alpha \beta \gamma \delta} [/tex] diverges at [tex] r = 0 [/tex]. I believe you are referring to the coordinate singularity at [tex] r = 2m [/tex]. This coordinate singularity can indeed be removed by a different choice of coordinates (though the surface [tex] r = 2m [/tex] is still special even if the curvature doesn't diverge there). 



#6
Nov2005, 11:20 AM

Sci Advisor
P: 1,132

Einstein's curvedspace model for gravity seems to suggest the concept of maximum gravity. This stems from the observation that if an object is very massive then it will "sink" spacetime so much, that the space near and around the object is perpendicular to "regular" spacetime outside the influence of this object's gravitational field, so any further distortion of space won't produce a stronger gravity. It also suggests that initially, as an object nears such a massive object, its acceleration due to gravity increases with the distance from the massive object. Gradually, as this object gets nearer the massive object the acceleration does not increase as fast, but at a certain point it reaches a maximum level, beyond which it will no longer be accelerated by the gravity of the massive object.




#7
Nov2005, 05:44 PM

P: 533

well, there is a maximum speed, what about a maximum acceleration?




#8
Nov2005, 08:21 PM

Sci Advisor
P: 1,132

I guess there's certainly the speed of light limit to acceleration. If you can't go faster than the speed of light than the maximum acceleration would be the one taking you from 0 to c in the shortest of time units. This is not what i was suggesting though when i was talking about a maximum acceleration due to gravity.




#9
Nov2005, 08:31 PM

Sci Advisor
P: 8,470





#10
Nov2005, 08:59 PM

Sci Advisor
P: 1,132

I did a search on maximum gravity and found the following number: 5x10^18 kg/m^2
The source is http://www.metaresearch.org/msgboard...p?TOPIC_ID=324 , but it may be under the LeSage model, which i don't find particularly attractive (even if the idea is kind of cool). 



#11
Jan2112, 08:14 AM

P: 11





#12
Jan2112, 03:29 PM

P: 640

The GR geodesic equations themselves directly contradict your statements. There is no limit in GR of "acceleration due to gravity", and no limit on the strength of the gravitational field. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
maximum torque, maximum power  Introductory Physics Homework  8  
How to find the maximum velocity and maximum acceleration?  Introductory Physics Homework  5  
maximum gravity boost  Astrophysics  5  
local maximum and global maximum.  Introductory Physics Homework  3 