
#1
Jul3004, 12:33 AM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 6,238

Hello all,
I'm reading through this book now and I'd like to know if there are other people who are also doing so, have read it or are planning to read it in order to have a discussion about it. In fact, I've read before about the first half (a bit more) of Peskin and Schroeder and I think that Zee gives a lot more insight, but probably only because I already went through P&S. Do you think that the approach of Zee is intelligible on a first contact ? cheers, patrick. 



#2
Jul3004, 01:17 AM

P: 199

They complement one another well  they each have what the other lacks. Another book I am reading is Kaku's book on field theory  it has a very strong group theory flavor, and again is strong in what P and S, and A. Z's books lack.




#3
Aug1304, 02:11 PM

P: 603

What exactly are the prerequisites for any course in QFT? And is Zee's text the best as an introductory text? Do you have to study relativistic QM in advance? and what is a good book about that subject to read at first?




#4
Aug1304, 02:30 PM

P: 2,828

QFT in a nutshell, by A. Zee.You might prefer to learn the new math whenever you encounter it. The problem is that group theory is a rather long way. See Georgi's "Lie Algebras in particle physics" (FIP). You would also need a serious background in Hilbertean analysis. Topology is welcome when it comes to nonperturbative stuff... But math are so beautiful, they are woth by themselves For an introduction to RQM, see 2nd chapter of Weinberg's fisrt volume. (maybe : by also Wainberg's 3volumes book. ) Another subject on which I would like to have people's opinion : would you advise student to avoid Greiner's series ? I should have I guess 



#5
Aug1304, 05:15 PM

P: 915

I have the book, but it's still too advanced for me




#6
Aug1504, 01:06 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 6,238

So I can't judge for the other volumes (relativistic qm, qed, electroweak and qcd) which I have there, unopened. If they are in the same flavor they are boring, uninsightful, but on the other hand, they really help you through each calculation in meticulous detail. Maybe it is a good thing to browse through if you want to sharpen your calculational skills, after having learned the subject somewhere else. cheers, patrick. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
QFT in a nutshell: Propagators  Advanced Physics Homework  9  
PenroseNewman in a Nutshell  General Physics  0  
QFT in a nutshell: From field to particle  Advanced Physics Homework  4  
Entanglement and interference in a nutshell  Quantum Physics  0  
The Universe In A Nutshell  Science & Math Textbook Listings  7 